Our 9-year-old and 4-year-old boys share a bedroom. You can guess what state it’s in.
Children don’t seem to notice this problem until it’s too late. They tell their parents their room is fine, and often they really mean it. Then, one day, often when they can’t find something they really need, they realize just how messy it is, and the mess is so overwhelming they don’t know where to start in fixing it.
You’ve probably figured out where this is going: Pittsburgh is a mess, much more so than its leaders let on. And if the fantasy that everything’s alright continues to prevail, it will soon become nearly impossible to clean up. Or, rather, redd up.
Alternative reality
I thought about this as a campaign document for Mayor Ed Gainey’s re-election came across my desk. The one-pager includes a set of bullet points describing Mr. Gainey’s claimed accomplishments, as well as his plans should he receive a second term.
It’s the nature of such documents to present a rosier-than-reality picture, but this one was unusually fantastical.
Take the claim that Mr. Gainey secured a “first-ever” commitment from giant nonprofit Highmark Health to contribute to the city. In Highmark’s very statement making the promise, the organization said it was a restatement of a principle it has held for many years, under multiple mayors.
Or that Mr. Gainey “fulfilled the promise of the Office of Community Health and Safety.” In fact, his administration has never accounted for $10 million in federal money it claims to have spent, but never actually did, for an OCHS street medicine program.
Or that the mayor “made the rental registry a reality to hold landlords accountable.” The registry may be real, but it’s also voluntary (and its future is still clouded by litigation), so it’s hardly holding anyone accountable. Just today, the administration boasted it has inspected an entire 12 units.
But rather than dwelling on campaign fibs and exaggerations, I’d rather focus on the plans for the future. That’s where the real conflict between fantasy and reality is found.
Socialism in one city
Mr. Gainey’s proposals, especially for housing, are only realistic (while likely still imprudent) for a high-growth city with healthy finances and an expanding tax base. In other words, not Pittsburgh.
The mayor wants to “use government resources to solve the housing crisis without having to rely on landlords and for-profit corporate developers.” In other words, a city government that can’t balance an honest budget or handle a brief snow squall wants to fund, and possibly own and manage, thousands upon thousands of new public housing units — also known in left-wing lingo as “social housing.”
Now, I’m very sympathetic to criticisms of subjecting a human necessity like housing to a capitalist marketplace, but this kind of socialism-in-one-city is senseless — especially when the city in question has a stagnant population and economy.
And where will those “government resources” come from? In part, according to the flyer, from a promised (or threatened?) second major bond issue. The first one, shamefully approved by a City Council that should have known better, produced $30 million in usable funds but will end up costing the city over $60 million due to high interest rates.
Now Mr. Gainey wants to saddle the city, for a generation to come, with another tranche of high-interest debt — all while City Controller Rachael Heisler is rightly warning that the mayor’s dodgy budget math is risking another round of state oversight of city finances.
At the end of the day, of course, what all this really means is a big tax hike on Pittsburgh residents and businesses, making climbing out of its economic and demographic rut all the more difficult, if not impossible.
Admitting the problem
It’s one thing to fudge the facts for campaign purposes. It’s something else to construct an entire alternative reality — and then to predicate policy on that fantasy. But that’s exactly what Mr. Gainey and his progressive clique are attempting to do.
The people of Pittsburgh, and its leaders outside and beyond City Hall, have to look at reality with clear eyes: Pittsburgh is a struggling mid-sized city. The optimism of the 2010s has melted away. Peer cities are lapping us. Tiny Harrisburg is building more housing than we are. There is no obvious engine of regional economic growth — or at least one that is being nurtured and boosted by public authorities. There is no shared plan for renewal.
The city, in other words, is a mess. This isn’t negativity for its own sake: This is reality. Refusing to acknowledge it out of misplaced Pittsburgh piety doesn’t help the city. It only makes it more likely the problems will persist until they’re too entrenched to dislodge.
This week, however, there was a hopeful sign that Pittsburghers are beginning to see reality more clearly: Corey O’Connor, the challenger in this spring’s mayoral primary, trounced Mr. Gainey in January fundraising twenty-to-one — carried almost entirely by donations from private individuals, not PACs.
Today, Pittsburgh is not in a position to experiment with extravagant progressive boondoggles. Today, Pittsburgh needs to redd up its room.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Every baby is a story waiting to be written.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.