A friend loves meeting new people, but hates standard-issue small-talk. The usual ice-breaker question — “So what do you do for work?” — he finds terribly reductive, as if our jobs should define our entire persons. Instead he asks, with a visible openness that invites a sincere response, “What’s your story?”
This is the question I asked last Saturday, looking forward rather than looking back, as I held my new daughter for the first time. “What will your story be, Louisa Josephine? Who are you? Who will you become?”
Good stories
Every new life is a new story. But also: Every great story begins with new life.
I’ve been reading John Le Carré’s spy thriller “Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy.” It’s a great yarn, with an unusual and complex hero in the spymaster George Smiley. We meet Smiley in a forced retirement, and his age is anyone’s guess, but of course at some point he had to be born. No Smiley, no spy, no story.
No Badger and Mr. Toad, no “Wind in the Willows.” No Frodo and Sam, no “Lord of the Rings.” No Odysseus, no Odyssey.
Stories need characters, choices, personalities. Stories need life, and life starts with birth.
And life needs stories. They are the primary way human beings make sense of themselves and their world — and they aren’t all pleasant or satisfying. Le Carré exalts in moral fogginess, where the good guys do bad things and the bad guys have honorable traits.
Not only is there no “Tinker Tailor” without Smiley: There’s no “Tinker Tailor” without the mole he’s chasing. Stories need people who make bad choices, too. The human experience wouldn’t be complete without them.
It’s what makes the stories so good, because they represent the chaos and complexity and contingency in every life, and in the shared life of a family, a community, a society.
Going beyond
To this day, my favorite video games involve stories of exploration. I love an empty map that gives up its secrets pixel by pixel, as your character ventures beyond the boundaries of his knowledge to discover what lies beyond.
In the “Civilization” series, for instance, you might discover resources, harbors, natural wonders — or barbarians who will menace you for the next several centuries. Every step into the unknown is necessary, but also risky. What’s beyond our knowledge and control will always come with the risk of danger.
It’s the uncertainty that’s so alluring. If the map were the same every time, or always and only revealed good news, it wouldn’t be nearly so realistic — and not nearly as interesting.
In the real world, there’s nothing more completely beyond our knowledge and control than another person. Sociologists and economists offer many theories for why people are having fewer children these days, many of which surely help explain it.
But I think there’s one, perhaps the most intimate of all, that falls between the analytical cracks: It’s scary to invite another person into your life, especially a baby whose story is yet unwritten. And especially when you know that you will not be the only person writing it, and that people who will not love her will be writing it too.
Your baby’s story may not be a happy story, at least in the usual sense. If you’re (rightly) pessimistic about human civilization in the twenty-first century, you may think it’s likely to be an unhappy story, or at least less happy than your own.
Regardless, there’s just no telling what will happen — to you, to your existing relationships, to this tiny person who depends on you but over whose story you have only the barest influence — when you step into the greatest unknown of all.
But there’s no future for humankind without people taking that step.
The more the merrier
Louisa is our seventh child and fifth daughter, and every time I mention the size of our family to someone new I can see the question flitting across their synapses: Why?
There are a lot of reasons, but here’s a preeminent one: We love a good story.
A good story doesn’t have to be the story you’d expect or even want. Three summers ago, I wrote here about the early miscarriage we suffered. John Isaiah’s story was very short, but it resonates to this day among those who loved him.
Better a sad story than no story at all.
The story of a soul, and of all its interactions with others, is never linear or immaculate. There will be sorrow and suffering, anxiety and betrayal, and some stories — maybe Louisa’s — will have more than their fair share of pain, and others more than their fair share of joy. But they will all take their place as part of the human story we all share, which only becomes more lush, more textured, more magnificent the more threads are interwoven.
So what will your story be, baby Louisa? We can’t yet know, but we do know that ours is richer with you here.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “How the activism-industrial complex props up Ed Gainey and distorts Pittsburgh politics.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.