In 1972, George McGovern thought the 26th Amendment would be his ticket to the White House. It didn’t go as planned.
That year, with the franchise extended to 18-year-olds for the first time, McGovern looked at a cohort of 25 million voters, up to age 24, who would be voting for president for the first time, and saw a possible victory margin of 8 million.
After all, everyone knows young people are more liberal than their parents, all the more so in the age of Vietnam. The 1970 Cambodian campaign had triggered a new wave of campus protests, culminating in the horror at Kent State. Surely if McGovern could count on one demographic, it would be the youth.
But by late summer, opinion polls showed they weren’t rallying to McGovern — in fact, Nixon had the edge. In the end, the Republican won a historic 24-point landslide, while carrying first-time voters.
Young voters are a lot more complicated than protests and TikTok. And there’s good reason to expect they’ll go GOP once again.
Unconventional wisdom
“It’s not Joe Biden’s poll numbers that worry me, exactly,” writes New York Times columnist Ezra Klein. “It’s the denial of what’s behind them.”
Read More
It was last week’s Times/Siena battleground state poll that finally convinced me Donald Trump is the favorite. But, as with Mr. Klein, it wasn’t so much the numbers themselves. It was the reports that Mr. Biden and his team don’t believe the results showing them trailing everywhere.
Nowhere is this denial more evident, especially in the media, than in Mr. Trump’s apparent strength among young voters.
The poll showed Mr. Trump leading among 18- to 29-year-old registered voters 46% to 43%, and 30% to 26% when third-party candidates are added. Mr. Biden does somewhat better when only likely voters are considered — which means high youth turnout would actually favor the Republican.
These results has been deployed to delegitimize the Times/Siena poll, because everybody knows Mr. Trump isn’t actually leading among young voters. To which I respond: Do we?
Elite preoccupations
Campus protests over the war in Gaza have sharpened the sense that young people are predominantly left-wing, just as Vietnam protests did two generations ago. But this is a red herring. Pitching up on the quad is a fundamentally elite pastime, and it gets disproportionate coverage because members of the media generally come from the same elite cliques and institutions.
During the Vietnam War, Americans under 30 were actually the age cohort least likely to believe the war was a mistake, even as a small number of students generated headlines. In 1973, only a bare majority of young adults agreed the war had been folly, compared to more than two-thirds of people over 50.
The truth is the vast majority of young Americans hadn’t gone to college, and most students were themselves ambivalent about or hostile to the tumult on their campuses. Sixty percent of Americans blamed Kent State on the students; only 10% blamed the National Guard.
Today, campus pro-Palestinian actions do indicate a broader shift: The Times/Siena poll shows twice as many young people sympathize with Palestine as with Israel, a historic reversal. But a paltry 4% named Gaza as their top issue. The real top issue among young people: the economy.
While more Americans go to college now than in the 70s, still only about 40% under 30 have finished, or will finish, a bachelor’s program. For most of them, their gravest concerns aren’t faraway: It’s making rent; it’s buying a home; it’s finding long-term stability in an economy that’s no longer designed for it.
It’s unfair to lay this at the feet of Mr. Biden, or of any single president. But that’s what voters do, and that’s what young voters, in particular, are doing: They favor Mr. Trump on the economy more than any other group, 68% to 25%.
Blow it up
But that’s not the most interesting data point in the Times/Siena poll. That would be this question: Do you prefer “a candidate who promises to bring politics in Washington back to normal,” or one who “promises to fundamentally change America”? Voters over 65 want a return to normal, 71% to 18%. Young voters want fundamental change, 68% to 27%.
If there’s one thing almost all voters agree on, it’s that Joe Biden is the candidate of the status quo, and Donald Trump is the candidate of change.
Mr. Biden’s most potent argument is that Mr. Trump will wreck the American political system. But what if you don’t particularly care for the system? What if you feel the system isn’t working for you, or you’ve been told since childhood the system is irredeemably unjust, or captured by the bad guys?
What if you’ve never seen the system work, in the way previous generations remember it working? What if there’s no “normal” to return to?
And then, consider this: In every presidential election voters under 30 have participated in, Donald Trump has been on the ballot. He is normal. He is for many young people — disaffected, disillusioned, disappointed — the reckoning.
Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.