In mid-April our nine-year-old son played his first ever Little League game. He batted second and took the second pitch — this is the youngest kid-pitch league — off his behind. Moments later he scored on a hit that never left the infield.

It was chaotic, hilarious and utterly thrilling.

The scene was made all the better by the setting. Skookum Field is at the very top of Duquesne Heights, tucked into the northwest corner of Mt. Washington. Homes seem to tumble down the hillsides beyond the outfield. And behind the first-base bleachers, one can see the Ohio meandering into the distance, almost as it would have been seen by the man for whom this hill is named.

The sky went from daylight to magic hour to dusk during the game, which had to be called after two hours and before four innings of mostly walks (and a few strikeouts) could be finished. It was the worst baseball I have ever seen. And the best.

Advertise with us

Community connection

In our neighborhood of Brookline, Little League is finally emerging from the post-pandemic doldrums. After a period when the viability of the 70-year-old program was in doubt, twice as many children — over 300 now — signed up this year as last.

Restrictions on open-air sports that now appear ridiculous broke the habit of baseball for many families, and wiped out a generation of kids who never picked up the game to begin with. Even with the resurgence, the boys program doesn’t have enough players to field a single team in the upper age brackets.

It’s clear Brookline Little League will never return to its glory days: Not long ago, the program would field five or six teams per age bracket. In the 70s, according to the frighteningly comprehensive history website Brookline Connection (which features over 100 articles on Brookline Little League alone), Post-Gazette sports editor Dan McGibbeny moonlighted as a Little League columnist for the neighborhood “Journal,” reporting on every game.

But due to the hard work of leaders and a new generation of parents and volunteers, it has undoubtedly returned to vibrancy. The ballfields at Brookline Memorial Park are packed and lit nearly every night of the week. My family has lived in Brookline for nearly a decade now, and never have I felt as connected to the community as I do in those bleachers.

As much as this connectedness is about our shared joy at watching our boys learn the game and compete, it is at least as much about participating in the tradition of the neighborhood we share. Baseball has been played in Brookline since at least 1914, and Little League since 1951. The fields even hosted the Pennsylvania Little League finals in 1959.

Advertise with us

This makes youth baseball distinct from other sports, including the one I expected my son to love best because it’s the one I loved best: dek hockey. But after his first baseball practice he declared that this was his favorite. And suddenly it’s mine, too.

Better bad than serious

My son’s a beginner on a team of mostly beginners, and I like it that way. After all, if the Brookline program is going to continue to grow, it’s going to be in part through making space for older beginners.

What’s so remarkable and encouraging is seeing how much better the boys are now than they were only four weeks ago, when a single first-base put-out seemed beyond the horizon.

You can plot youth sports on two axes, one labeled “Good” and “Bad” and the other labeled “Casual” and “Serious.” We’re Bad and Casual. I’d take that any day over Good and Serious.

In fact, if our team had been Serious, whether Good or Bad, we probably wouldn’t have stuck it out. Neither my son nor his parents (nor his siblings) needs the pressure that comes with Serious kids’ sports, which are usually more about parents living their athletic dreams vicariously through their children.

Advertise with us

I believe in my bones that it’s possible to be Good and Casual, where “Casual” doesn’t mean abandoning high standards, but pursuing those standards with understanding and good cheer.

I think of an opposing coach I observed, whose instructions were invariably direct and whose tone was invariably encouraging. That was a very good team, and they had fun and were supportive of one another.

Strength and character

Players and patrons access Brookline’s main Little League fields through a brick-and-concrete archway that gives the small venue a stadium-like feeling. (I had nothing like this playing ball in the suburbs as a kid.) There’s even a “Wall of Fame” chronicling Mayor’s Cup victories and other triumphs.

Above the arch, there’s a concrete plaque chiseled with these words: “From the ranks of youngsters who stand now on the morning side of the hill will come the leaders, the future strength and character of the nation.”

It’s a quotation associated with several Little League programs around the country and said to be from Abraham Lincoln, though I can’t confirm this. There’s a grandness to the whole scene — the arch, the wall, the words — that feels like being transported to another time when we built big things for little kids, and expected big things from them.

Advertise with us

But the things we built weren’t about turning them into professionals, as it too often is now, but about helping them enjoy their childhood. And our expectations were less about their winning right now, and more about building their moral and personal strength and character for the long run.

After all, childhood is meant to be the morning side of the hill, not the summit. This is the time of growth, of playing, of failing and learning from failure (and learning when failure doesn’t really matter), not the time of achievement, of finality, of anxiety, of wisdom, of regret.

It is the time of taking the mound against a twilight sky, and listening to parents’ cheers, and making a good throw, and hitting the batter in the butt.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.