In my first column for the Post-Gazette two years ago, I told the story of Billy, a 6-year-old boy who was struck by a car, and of how the community who loved him responded to the near-tragedy.
Billy almost didn’t make it: He stopped breathing in the ambulance and paramedics brought him back. Then he confounded his doctors by healing from devastating hip fractures more completely and quickly than they thought was possible. In a matter of weeks, Billy’s family went from living a nightmare to savoring a miracle.
That should have been the end of the story. But it wasn’t. And that’s why I’m writing about Billy O’Mara once again.
The letters
In insurance, there’s a concept called “subrogation.” This is when an insurance company makes a claim, usually against another insurance company, to recoup its payout to the insured. So, you’re hit by a negligent driver and make a claim to your insurance company. After it has paid you, your insurer might pursue the other driver’s insurance for that same amount, to make itself whole.
With that foundation laid, you might have figured out where this is going.
After Billy had healed, his parents, Bob and Stephanie O’Mara, started receiving threatening letters from a man named Eugene Bederman, Esq., of Bucks County, attorney for the Atlantic States Insurance Company.
“After proper investigation, we have determined that this accident was caused by your child’s negligence. As a result you are legally liable for damages caused by this accident in the amount of $2,445.82.”
A 6-year-old boy who dings up a Lexus to the tune of $2,500 should be contacted by the Steelers, not a lawyer. But back to the letter.
“Please be advised that we intend to file a Civil Complaint seeking [these] damages ... plus attorney fees, court costs and the suspension of your driver’s license, if you fail to respond within ten (10) days of this letter. ... Kindly govern yourself accordingly.”
The O’Maras presented these letters to an attorney and to their insurance company, both of whom were bewildered at the gall. It was a scare tactic, they said — nothing more.
The lawsuit
And that’s what the family believed, until last week. Two years is Pennsylvania’s statute of limitations for insurance claims, and right on cue Mr. Bederman and the Atlantic States Insurance Company followed through: They sued a family of nine, living on a teacher’s salary, for nearly $2,500 plus costs — because a driver they insured hit a first-grader.
The lawsuit names the driver as plaintiff, but that’s typical in a subrogation claim. I’m not naming him because, as far as I know, he had nothing to do with bringing this action. All he did was get his car fixed after it struck a child apparently made of tungsten.
I talked to Etti Baranhoff, an insurance expert from Virginia Commonwealth University, and she was as appalled as everyone else I’ve told this story. She suggested the claim could have been coded not as “collision,” but as “uninsured driver,” though other insurance professionals have disputed this. In that case, the driver wouldn’t have been on the hook for his deductible, and the O’Maras wouldn’t have been hassled by a soulless insurance company and its ghoulish lawyer.
While most homeowners policies include personal liability coverage that is meant to cover accidental property damage — including legal defense — many people don’t know that, and pursuing claims against a grievously injured child is uncommon enough that even the family’s insurer was apparently confounded.
When the O’Maras didn’t respond to the lawyer’s cartoonish threats, Atlantic States was perfectly free simply to absorb a $2,500 loss — that is, after all, what insurance companies do — and allow a family to keep its peace. Instead, they chose a detestable form of legal extortion.
Fighting back
A recent survey concluded that 44% of Americans can’t afford an unexpected expense of $1,000. That percentage would go up substantially at $2,500, and much more still if we’re talking about paying a competent lawyer to defend against such a claim, which would certainly cost more than the claim itself. The vast majority of American families, the company and Mr. Bederman wager, will panic and fold — even if that requires going into debt.
In this case, they wagered badly. Besides the fact the O’Maras are friends with a newspaper editor, their families also have deep roots in the community. A relative told their story to an experienced attorney, who enthusiastically took the case pro bono.
For my part, I left a voice message for Kevin G. Burke, president and CEO of Donegal Insurance Group, which owns Atlantic States. (Surprisingly, if you plug in his name when prompted by the main menu, you get his direct extension.) I have received no reply.
I also called Mr. Bederman’s office, and was given his email address. I wrote with several questions, but he has not responded.
The question that has haunted me since the beginning is whether the company and its lawyer would have pursued the O’Maras even if Billy had been maimed or killed. Based on their actions, however, the answer is pretty clear: Of course they would have.
After all, there’s no way they could’ve known that Billy was alright before they initiated this inhumane process. For all they knew, he could’ve been paralyzed or worse. But their logic takes no account of suffering or trauma or mercy or life and death themselves, except inasmuch as they can be monetized.
Living in freedom
“This is why people don’t like the insurance industry,” said Ms. Baranhoff. That’s certainly true, but this is a peculiar kind of cruelty: Most insurance companies have the good sense to know that, if nothing else, the legal fees and risk of publicity aren’t worth chasing families of injured children for $2,500.
And this episode points beyond insurance to deeper problems in American society, where widespread economic precarity means many Americans, if not most, are easy targets for bullying, whether it’s corporate extortionists and their legal enablers or usurious payday lenders or keyboard warriors targeting opponents’ livelihoods over social media posts. It’s hard to live freely and well with a target on your back.
That was the point of the absurd threat — “kindly govern yourself accordingly” — at the end of Mr. Bederman’s letter: to replace freedom with fear of the bully, and of what might happen if you cross him.
In the case of little Billy O’Mara, however, it didn’t work.
A few days ago, I returned from the office to find a boy’s bike outside, and Billy at our dinner table. Afterward, I went outside to see him off, and he mounted that bike and rode it with a confidence that neither the Lexus nor the lawyer could knock out of him. I lingered longer than usual, watching this free little boy ride home, heedless of the knaves and the bullies who want to chain him down, and I smiled.
Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.
Editor’s note: This column has been updated to reflect the fact that most Pennsylvania homeowners insurance policies include personal liability coverage.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.