Several years ago, I was in the Bay Area for the first time to give a talk at Stanford, and a friend offered to show me the city of San Francisco. It was only a single evening, but I was immediately infatuated.

The first thing I remember is the colors — it was the most colorful city I’d ever seen. We dropped in around the ballpark, where crowds were converging for a Giants game. Then we passed through the Financial District to the Marina, where we paused to gaze at the straits. The Golden Gate Bridge appeared as an apparition in the mist.

We ended up in the Mission, where my friend took me for a Michelin-starred dinner (my first and thus far only) followed by a visit to a tequila bar. The city was a dream.

But, like a real dream, something was off. I couldn’t put my finger on it, until we passed a school with a speed limit sign that said “when children present.”

Advertise with us

And I realized: Neither in the baseball crowds nor the parks nor the sidewalks had I seen a single child.

Built for living together

When I return to my Brookline home from the newsroom, I can only guess how many kids will be there, and what percent will belong to me.

Of my own six, the baby (11 months) and the toddler (just turned three) are safe bets. The five-year-old isn’t allowed to walk the neighborhood on her own yet, so she’s probably there, but the seven-, eight- and ten-year-old are often visiting their friends — or, as we look forward to spring, at the park.

And then there’s the likelihood that one or two or more of the dozens of kids of our Brookline friends are visiting us. I love being greeted with “Dad!” when I walk in the door, of course, but there’s something special in a different way about “Mr. McGinley!”

This, as far as I’m concerned, is what living in the city is supposed to be. My father grew up in Sheraden and my mother in the Hilltop, and they describe all-day pickup baseball when there was never a doubt of having enough players to fill the field, and carrying nickels to Isaly’s, just the kids, for a cone.

Advertise with us

I grew up in the suburbs, where I had a childhood for which I can only be grateful. But we lived almost within sight of a 50s-era shopping center, with restaurants and barber shops and ice cream and a post office, to which we almost exclusively drove. There were no sidewalks, and the idea of walking there myself never crossed my mind (and likely would have been frowned upon if it had).

The city, on the other hand, naturally developed as a place for spontaneity and serendipity: Deciding on a whim to go for a walk, to make a visit, to go for coffee or to the library, and then bumping into a friend, and chatting and bringing them home for dinner, maybe their whole family, and then they walk home, because they can, because the world is built for that kind of experience.

Land of enchantment

The city is also built to be explored using children’s means of getting around. This means it offers independence, and opportunities for enchantment, that only few places can match.

Our eldest now asks to go to Brookline Blvd all the time, to get a hot chocolate or a library book. I worked at the library on Wednesday, and she and her sister and two of their friends walked in, giggling at the idea of encountering Dad in the wild, and asked for cash to pick up something at Pitaland. I think they know I’ll never say no to Pitaland.

The places that grown-ups see primarily for their utility — a place to work, a place to pick up something we need, a place to fulfill an errand — become places of excitement and anticipation for children, especially when they can explore them on their own.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh, and Brookline in particular, also has the advantage of having walkable wild places. During a recent warm spell I took some of the kids to the woods behind Brookline Memorial Park, former farmland that had been slated for development generations ago. Along one of the rough trails there suddenly appears a concrete staircase, built for a house that was never finished.

The kids knew the land better than I did. They had named one prominent hill “Mount Doom,” which we found and they climbed. And then we found some of their older friends, my friends’ tween boys, swinging from vines, and we joined them. They told us some of the valley had been trapped for coyotes.

From the boulevard to the forest, the city is a place of imagination and exploration. It is a place for children.

A place for children

So when cultural or economic factors — or the collapse of public education — make the city inhospitable to children and their families, it loses something of itself. It’s no longer really a city at all, because the physical city is meant to sustain a society, and there is no society without children.

The city without children is just an enormous lifestyle center, with all the life sucked out of it.

Advertise with us

There are — there must be — more children in San Francisco than I saw that single evening, but it is clearly no longer a place organized with children in mind. It is a place for grown-ups with a few spaces set aside for children, when in a real city children are made welcome (nearly) everywhere, while some spaces are set aside for adults.

One of Pittsburgh’s great strengths (and Brookline’s in particular) is that it is still, by and large, a place for children, which they can safely explore and test their limits, which they can come to love. No conversation about Pittsburgh’s future is complete without prioritizing the people who will be its future.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.