Robert Bowers was my neighbor. No, he didn’t live right next door, and as far as I know I never met him. But he spent most of his childhood in Whitehall, the same small South Hills borough where I grew up. He worked at a Dormont bakery I’ve visited. And he spent his last horrible years of freedom in a ramshackle apartment about five minutes from the house where I spent most of my life.

I know the streets and shortcuts and shops and landmarks he knows. We probably bought milk at the same Giant Eagle. He was one of my people, one of our people.

Pure evil

I use the past tense to describe him as if he’s already dead. And there is some truth in that: A jury and judge have duly declared his life forfeit, for the crime of mass murder on the basis of religious and racial hate.

Advertise with us

But even that short-sells the extent of his transgression against society and humanity. October 27, 2018, was for him just the start: He hoped to inspire a torrent of Jew-killing. And if he had the diabolical power all to himself, he would not have stopped with Tree of Life and New Light and Dor Hadash. He would not have stopped until he was finished.

That’s why many people who oppose the death penalty find it hard not to make an exception in this case. Among the spate of mass killings in recent years, this one stands out because it was so clearly, in the determined mind of the killer, incomplete. The three congregations at the corner of Wilkins and Shady stood in for all the Jews of the world. That’s a peculiarly pure kind of evil.

Which is the main reason I use the past tense to describe him: It’s much more comfortable that way. It gives me, and all of us, some distance from him. To say that he is a Pittsburgher or a South Hills man would suggest that he is still in some way a part of our community. But how could that be?

Still human

The defense tried to portray the shooter as someone whose experiences and upbringing had already placed him beyond the bounds of humanity — and our signal ability to reason, and to choose. There, beyond the pale even before he opened fire, he would be out of reach of our most final form of justice.

Advertise with us

The jury rightly rejected this desperate defense. The shooter’s past was traumatic, to be sure, but many people — more than we want to believe — carry the scars of familial collapse and abandonment and abuse. While they may struggle, even very seriously, and even in ways that mitigate responsibility for bad choices, they do not descend into hellish hatred. They do not lose their humanity.

In the case of this killer, it would be comforting if he had. That way he could be not man but monster, and we all would be free from the obligation to consider how man’s world — our world — might have failed him. We could say that it was always going to be this way, that some people can’t be helped, because at some point they ceased really being people at all.

But that’s not true. He was a man. He is a man. And he could have been helped.

Person to person

You never hear about a mass killer of any variety who was part of a stable and loving family, or of a group of committed and caring friends. The radicals, like this shooter, are always part of a community, but a strictly online one — that is, a disembodied community, where concepts and conspiracies thrive without reference to the complications of physical reality.

Advertise with us

This ersatz communion pulls people away from real communion, in part by denying its value. Real people become impediments: The natural affection a person has for another, in whom he sees himself, is a stumbling block to accepting the deeper truth, peddled by the cultists, that enmity is man’s true calling.

It is popular to assume that because the problem is so very online, then the solution must be as well. Shut down or stigmatize sites like Gab, where the shooter announced his final intention. Track “extremist” discourse. Delete offensive or untrue content.

But there will always be dark corners where the light — even of a burgeoning surveillance state that carries its own risks — will not reach. More important, sequestering the problem out there comfortably but wrongly absolves us of responsibility right here.

One of us

As much as online radicalism can dissolve interpersonal bonds, having strong relationships to begin with is an inoculation against hatred and violence. And building, maintaining and strengthening those bonds is a task that belongs to all of us.

Advertise with us

There’s no one person out there who could have saved the shooter from his self-degradation. No one person can bear the full weight of another’s disorder and despair.

But as a community, we must examine ourselves. How did this man fall through the cracks? What care or grace might have been extended to him, before his hatred hardened? How could we have made our shared humanity manifest to him, and to everyone with whom we share our neighborhoods, in a way that would make such dehumanizing hatred and violence unthinkable?

And what can each of us do, in our own near orbits, to keep people close and to treat them well — especially those who don’t always seem to deserve it? What hospitality or kindness or generosity might we extend that takes us outside our comfort zones?

Building hate-resistant communities isn’t just a task for law or policy. It’s a task for every person, every day.

Because Roberts Bowers is my neighbor. He is all our neighbor. And that’s the hardest truth of all.

Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.