As my flight approached Reagan National Airport, the first thing I noticed were the cranes, one after the other along the Virginia bank of the Potomac. I can’t approve of the nondescript apartment buildings being raised there — which will look drab and dated within a decade or two, at most — but it still stirred up some jealousy to see so much building.

Cranes haven’t been a fixture of everyday life in Pittsburgh for a long time. That’s not just a symptom of economic stagnation, but a cause, I think, of a certain malaise of spirit. Building big things is a physical expression of the potential for greatness of every person and every community. Grand structures that fulfill grand purposes show everyone, especially young people, what we are capable of, and teach that the ambition to be great is rewarded.

In other words, building is good for the soul.

Civilizational self-esteem

Advertise with us

“I did that!” It’s the phrase my 2-year-old-son utters (or rather shrieks) with the most enthusiasm. Usually he has built some tower or pile of toys that he wants to show off before a sibling destroys it.

What he’s communicating, however, isn’t just pride but astonishment that he has gone beyond what he had thought was possible to achieve. And having done so, he becomes confident that he can surpass his own expectations again, and again, and again, until he reaches the fullness of his potential.

This confidence (or, to use clinical language, self-esteem) that comes from achievement isn’t just part of the psychology of young children. It’s baked into human nature, including the shared experience of communities. And building grandly is one of the most visible and important ways to feed that need.

That’s why I try to point out and seek out impressive examples of construction to the kids. Maybe it’s the new FNB tower in the Lower Hill, or one of UPMC’s many projects around town. Sometimes we’ll just drive around as an activity, and I’ll show off the old stacks in Shippingport and the new cracker plant just up the river.

The implicit message: We — this city, this country, this civilization — are not done yet. We have the energy and know-how to build extraordinary things, at a scale that inspires wonder. And you can be part of something great, too.

Advertise with us

Atrophied potential

I understand, and my children will someday understand, that all these examples are to some degree morally ambiguous. Whether the environmental practices of Shell or the business practices of UPMC, for instance, change the valence of their grand projects from awesome to sinister is something people and communities will have to decide for themselves.

But it’s also possible — not just possible, but an observable reality — that in our hand-wringing we can forget the good that comes from building, in itself. This is how we end up, for instance, with tome-length federal environmental impact statements (EIS) that take an average of four and a half years to compile. That’s about four times what it took Dostoevsky to write “Crime and Punishment.”

To be sure, not every grand project is worthy of being built. I oppose all cartoon-villain death rays, no matter how impressive. More seriously, it’s difficult to regard the scars left by mountaintop coal mines or urban interstates as anything but the result of hubristic overexcitement and disregard for the voices of affected communities.

Today, however, we have the opposite problem: We are so conscious of the costs of building anything awe-inspiring that we’ve forgotten the benefits are more than economic, but psychological and even spiritual. And we ignore the costs of inaction, which include what an earlier generation of thinkers would have called civilizational acedia, or apathy.

Advertise with us

Acedia is a kind of habitual listlessness that becomes learned helplessness: We come to believe that anything worth doing isn’t worth the trouble, so we settle into doing nothing at all. Over time, acedia drains the physical and spiritual energy needed to accomplish great things, and our felt helplessness becomes real helplessness.

Signs of hope

Which brings me to permit reform.

As trivial as it may seem, unnecessary bureaucratic red tape is, in a sense, the political manifestation of acedia. Most regulations begin with some noble and often necessary purpose, but then over time more and more rules and bad habits accumulate. What starts as a one-page certification eventually becomes a labyrinth of lobbying and litigation that bears very little relation to the original policy, and saps the momentum for ambitious projects.

That’s how we ended up with EIS documents that make Tolstoy look concise. The original National Environmental Policy Act of 1970 (NEPA) didn’t foresee anything like them, but after decades of judicial and administrative accretions a bulletproof statement now takes longer to produce than a James Cameron film.

Advertise with us

Thankfully, the Biden-McCarthy debt ceiling deal included a flexible two-year NEPA deadline, which is more than enough time to consider the environmental consequences of even large and complex projects.

This is part of an emerging, encouraging bipartisan consensus, across all levels of government, that permissions processes are broken. Besides slowing down or smothering economic development, these often-arbitrary hurdles contribute to a culture that obsesses over costs and risks at the expense of reaching the fullness of human potential.

Pittsburgh, to be sure, needs more than permit reform to multiply the cranes on the skyline. But these reforms do suggest a change in mindset that will be necessary to the region’s future, and the country’s: a recognition that settling into stagnation is riskier not just to our prosperity, but to our spirits, than taking bold steps to build grand projects.

As my kids come to know and to love their hometown, I don’t want them to see it as a changeless museum piece. I want them, for their own sake and for the city’s, to see it as a place where great things are possible, where one day they can point to something grand and say with pride and astonishment, “We did that.”

Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.