It is about half an hour after the Pirates’ walk-off win against the Reds when my two oldest children and I enter the North Side T Station. In the lobby at the base of the first elevator, I see the Pittsburgh Regional Transit screen listing upcoming train arrivals.
Ten minutes? Not great for postgame crowds, but not terrible either.
Then I look more closely. Above the number “10,” I read the dreaded gray word: “Scheduled.”
When I started at the Post-Gazette last October after nearly a decade working from home, I was really looking forward to commuting by transit. Robust, reliable transit systems are essential to thriving cities, and I get a kick out of navigating them. It was a bonus that my Brookline-to-North-Side trip would be relatively short, but still a multi-leg, multimodal adventure.
On my first day, I took a picture of the “Next Trains” monitor at South Hills Junction — my usual bus-to-T transfer — and sent it to family members. How fancy! How modern! Pittsburgh had really made it.
It didn’t take me long to realize that the screens lie.
First of all, when the word “Scheduled” appears above the ETA, that means “good luck, sucker.” It signifies that the transponder for the train that’s supposed to arrive isn’t functioning, which usually means the train is out of service. (Sometimes the ghost train does in fact pull up to the platform, and one boards it warily, hoping it won’t return to the parallel dimension whence it came.) Instead of removing that train from the list, the screen taunts you with the broken promise of the schedule.
On the way into the office, this is mostly a source of mild annoyance. Light rail vehicles show up every five minutes or so; a missing train will set me back ten minutes, tops.
The ride home, however, is another matter. When the screens at North Side Station lie, that means I’ll likely miss my connection at South Hills Junction — and Brookline buses only run every 30 minutes, at best. And that means a choice among bad options for getting home, which include spending half an hour sampling the scents of sewage at the Junction, bugging friends or family to pick me up at a T station, or walking long distances along pedestrian-hostile roads.
And I’m lucky: For those who depend on transit for more than just getting home while the meatloaf’s hot, being unable to trust either the schedule or the screen can make daily life miserable. It means missed appointments, tardiness to work — and not newsroom work, but the kind of work where ten minutes’ delay can be the difference between keeping and losing a job — and hours upon hours of life snatched away.
There’s no question reliability has declined since the springtime. For me, the inflection point was PRT’s enforcement of its vaccine mandate on operators. Missed trips peaked at 18%, and my evening commute has never recovered.
While PRT insists that it is once again approaching its goal of only 2% missed trips, that doesn’t include regular occurrences like the preposterous spacing of trains, with two following each other as if they’re hitched with the next not coming for 15 minutes, leading to empty cars and full stations.
It also doesn’t account for when the screens really lie. Sometimes the trains seem to violate the rules of space and time, like when one was listed alternatively as “Approaching” and “2 minutes away” for about 10 minutes before disappearing entirely. I left the station, walked across the Allegheny and caught a bus Downtown.
PRT is in a catch-22: Offering more transit options will increase ridership, but it needs more riders to justify increasing the options. Someone has to take a leap of faith first. But when basic systems like rider notification screens are unreliable, and sometimes downright deceptive, it makes it very hard for the people of Pittsburgh to make the first move. Why should we choose to organize our lives around the PRT if the PRT can’t be trusted to tell us when our ride is coming, or if it exists at all?
Back in North Side Station after the Pirates game, I overhear a woman counting down with the monitors. “Just a few minutes,” she says. “Don’t count on it,” I reply with a grim smile while my exhausted-energetic kids roughhouse on the platform. Predictably, the Red Line listing goes from “Scheduled / Approaching” to disappearing entirely. No train.
The next listing is a Silver Line, 15 minutes away. Ten minutes later a Red Line train emerges from the tunnel. Is it the Red Line train promised by the screen? Is it some other unscheduled train? Does it exist in this dimension at all?
I hustle the kids on the train and it screeches into the tunnel. Where it’ll take us, I can only guess.
Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.