People in their early 40s, such as myself, are often referred to as Xennials, blurring the divide between Gen X and the Millennial generations. One of the defining characteristics of people my age is the analog nature of our childhoods, full of landlines and dot-matrix printers, and the digital dominance of our adulthood.
I received a cell phone soon after I earned my drivers license, which I was expected to leave in the car during school hours. Before that, I’d enjoyed a relatively free-range childhood, with a “come home when the street lights turn on” ethos that so many people older than me share. There were limits to “free-range,” of course, as my parents required me to call from my friends’ homes to report my location.
Digital technology grew into adulthood as I did, and I’ve had the taste of both The Way It Was Before and The Way It Is Now. I understand the arguments for and against giving kids phones, and I’m firmly on the side of limiting my kids’ exposure to the digital world as long as possible.
Still, as the parent of two young children, after an afternoon where I could not find my son (who was playing at a friend’s house without calling), I caved. I deliberated with my spouse for a few months, and researched intensely, before buying the kids a cell phone. Even though both are only in elementary school.
Call me!
When my son opened the Light Phone, we explained to him and his younger sister that this is a tool, not a toy. Unlike a regular-degular smartphone, a Light Phone only has a few applications, mainly texting, directions and a handful of other crucial items, including a camera. There is no store or internet browser, and the interface is the most uninteresting black and white.
Which is to say: I bought my children the most boring phone I could find on the market. When they are out playing on our street, they are required to take the phone and a fanny pack I keep nearby, so they cannot drop or lose the phone without effort.
I’m trying to have my cake and eat it too. In this way, I’m not so different from my other mom friends, navigating the need to stay connected with our children, via fancy watches and dumbed-down phones, while also protecting them from the dangers of the digital world. In buying a not-so-smart phone, to some degree, I’m trying to give my kids a taste of the kind of childhood I had: a little bit analog, a little bit rock n’ roll.
“Don’t give away your attention to things that aren’t worth it,” I said to my son the other day, forcing him to close his school-issued laptop. “Go outside. Run around. Do something! Make something!” He stared at me like I was a dinosaur, and not even the cool kind he can spout facts about.
“Momma, I am learning math when I play this game. I’m not learning math when I’m playing on the street.” I made him put on 10,000 layers, including the fanny pack, and go outside anyway.
Any-anytime!
On Tuesday, the Pennsylvania Senate Education Committee voted to advance a bill to make Keystone State schools phone-free. I hope that this ban becomes law, and Pennsylvania gets to join the other 27 states that restrict student cell phone use.
Smart-phone addiction plagues all generations, from the oldest of us to the youngest. They’re designed that way; we’re meant to be glued to their attractive graphics and dopamine-releasing interfaces. There’s little I can do about my dad’s addiction to his phone, but there’s a lot I can do to prevent my children’s.
Putting phones in inaccessible pouches during the school day seems like a no-brainer to me. Mental health outcomes and grades improve with a cell phone ban. Cyber bullying decreases. Or as Pennsylvania State Education Association vice president Jeff Ney put it, “Mobile devices disrupt students from learning.”
“Your average teenager gets 237 texts per day,” he continued. “Think about all those pings and how many they are getting during their seven hours at school while they are supposed to be learning.”
But I know parents who object to cell phone bans nonetheless, citing legitimate medical reasons, as well as fears of a school shooting situation.
On the line
There are a lot of corporate interests competing for our, and our children’s, attention spans today. We are meant to never be bored, constantly glued to our devices, instead of to the very real world that surrounds us.
I understand parents who give their children phones-that-are-not-just-phones when they’re too young. I understand the ones who resist as long as possible.
We’re navigating uncertain times, and the ground can feel uneven for us all. I get the fear of school shootings, but I’m also not one to let fear rule my life. It’s one thing to say you’re scared, it’s another to sacrifice your child’s attention span to assuage your worries.
Then again, I still gave my kids a phone. It’s the Xennial in me, trying to navigate two worlds — to have my phone, and ban it too.
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “A ‘painfully American’ World Cup.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.