One lunchtime when I was in high school, the table had been making food puns, when my friend Jason told a joke about the Holocaust. When a few of us hesitated in saying it was funny, he accused us of having no sense of humor. We didn’t get it, he said.
Later that day, as Jason’s joke spread, Joey, a tall red-headed dude who played on the football team, pulled Jason aside and threatened to beat him up. In my journal, I wrote “Joey might kill Jason. And for good reason.”
Joey was Jewish, the grandchild of Holocaust survivors. That joke wasn’t funny at all to him.
I hadn’t yet discovered the Jewish side of my family, but I understood Joey’s offense. I also knew, despite choosing not to laugh, why Jason’s punchline was funny to him. The shock of the joke was the point.
Just the man in the back
It would be easy to say that Jason, a white kid from Texas with one Latino great-grandfather, did not comprehend the impact of the Holocaust. But he did.
Years earlier, in middle school, we had all read “The Diary of Anne Frank,” and Jason specifically had been in a production of “I Never Saw Another Butterfly,” a play about the detained children in Terezin Concentration Camp. Our freshman year required a viewing of “Schindler’s List.” Even as Jason made that joke, our class had been reading “The Hiding Place” by Corrie ten Boom.
Jason hadn’t been kept in the dark about the horrors of Nazi Germany. He knew. We all knew.
That’s why he told the joke. He knew the power of the joke was in the taboo. It was about taking something that was absolutely sacred and using the dehumanizing juxtaposition to make people laugh. He could do that, because the kind of person who can laugh at a Holocaust joke is the kind of person who can never imagine such a thing happening to them.
Just demeaning the pack
A few weeks ago, after the death of political commentator Charlie Kirk, Republicans felt a deep sense of outrage at the crude and tasteless jokes, the taboo jokes, many people made about it.
After being reported, many of those people lost their jobs, with Republican approval. Students from abroad were denied visas, and Jimmy Kimmel was in the Trump administration’s crosshairs.
This week, after Politico exposed a group chat of under-40 Republicans full of Holocaust and rape jokes, as well as Nazi references and racial slurs, the official party line from Republicans is “Boys will be boys” (about mostly men and women in their 30s, including one state senator) and “What Liberals said about Charlie Kirk is worse.”
But as one person put it on X, “If you’re ok with jokes about gas chambers, slavery and rape, I assume you’re also ok about joking about Charlie Kirk’s death? No standards for anyone?”
It seems that rather than dial things down, both sides are choosing to escalate our collective agreement on what kinds of jokes are the most offensive, disagreeing not only on the standard but to whom it applies. There is no common belief that no one should make jokes about real people being killed.
The problem with our current cultural moment, and the ease with which we mock the deaths of others, is that it normalizes their deaths. This opens the door for even more offense, as a group of people that enjoy telling jokes about the extermination of a people will make offensive jokes about anyone.
It’s not hard to find examples of how far we’ve fallen: In the last 24 hours alone, a prominent attorney and former law clerk for a Supreme Court Justice, called an elected government official a “house slave,” and a legislative correspondent for a Congressman displayed an American flag with a swastika on it.
Maybe some people are comfortable with what Vice President Vance called “edgy jokes,” because, to them, they aren’t edgy at all — they’re a fantasy of complete security and absolute power.
A little shame
It should be easy to condemn both the under-40 “young” Republicans and the people who mocked the death of Charlie Kirk. It should be easy to disavow the abhorrent statements made by Democrat Jay Jones in Virginia, wishing death on a colleague. It should be easy for all of us to disavow hatred.
But when people in power choose to dismiss these tasteless jokes and call these grown group-chat folks “kids,” they’re excusing these 18 to 40 year olds from accountability and giving permission for others to say something far worse.
These aren’t kids by any definition — some are barely younger than the vice president defending them. These are the future leaders of the Republican party, not stupid youth who don’t know any better.
But I’ll tell you this: after Joey threatened to beat up Jason for his joke, and after a lot of long discussions, Jason apologized. He eventually understood that jokes are better when they punch up, fighting power instead of mocking those that cannot defend themselves. That there’s a reason for certain taboos. He was able to get that, even as a high schooler.
“Kids” know better — when they’re taught a hard lesson. I’m not sure the same can be said about some of the adults in the room right now.
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Loving the coal but killing the miners.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.