In the immediate aftermath of the assassination of media personality and conservative activist Charlie Kirk, many people on both sides of the aisle asked “When is enough enough?”

“We will never forget this,” a journalist wrote on social media. “This should have never happened,” wrote a politician. “We must never let this happen again,” an influencer echoed.

But the truth is that our country is very good at forgetting tragedies — even political assassinations fade from today’s news cycle and public discourse too quickly. Both the killing of Minnesota state representative Melissa Hortman and her husband, as well as the two attempts on President Trump’s life, illustrate this too — a sign of how numb we’ve all become.

So what does “never” mean? What is it that we are calling on one another to remember or not do? What happens when we forget? What happens if we let it happen again and again and again? What is it that we value, if not one another?

Advertise with us

I remember when

From buses to banners, one often encounters the slogan “never forget” regarding September 11th. But an event that happened 24 years ago is becoming less and less sacred in the cultural imagination. To someone born in 1998, too young to remember, what does it mean to “never forget”?

I was a college student when it happened, and I remember the fear we all felt, how we all cried and clung to each other. The social media of the time (e.g., Blogger and Live Journal) encouraged longform posts, where people had the space, and bandwidth, to engage one another with nuance and complexity.

College students today don’t have the attention span to read a long post on anything. And perhaps that’s why, given the alignment of both the anniversary of the national tragedy and the Backyard Brawl football game between WVU and Pitt, a WVU supporter thought it appropriate to post a video of an airplane crashing into Pitt’s Cathedral of Learning.

The post was up for more than a day before the author deleted it. But only half the comments beneath called it wrong.

I cannot imagine making a 9/​11 joke. For those of us who remember it well, the collective trauma of that day is not something we can laugh about, even in the name of a sports rivalry.

Advertise with us

But others can. How can someone remember something they never experienced in the first place? Ninety to 95 million Americans were born since 1998. How can they understand what it means to the people who do remember?

‘Used to be’s’ don’t count

As a Jewish person, “never forget” and “never again” evoke the Holocaust, and the importance of remembering how a society can succumb to true evil. It is meant to be a universal statement, one that applies to all human beings subjected to systemic erasure.

“Never again” was never meant to be only about our own. Yet, the Los Angeles Holocaust Museum recently courted controversy by stating exactly that, posting an image on their social media with the caption “‘Never Again’ can’t only mean Never Again For Jews.”

The statement was interpreted by many as a condemnation of Israel’s ongoing, U.N.-designated genocide in Gaza. I know many Jewish people who agree, but it is by no means the prevalent sentiment.

Within 48 hours, the museum issued an apology, noting that the original post “intended to promote inclusivity and community that was easily open to misinterpretation by some to be a political statement reflecting the ongoing situation in the Middle East.”

Advertise with us

However perceived, the original statement and the apology both point to the problem with “never.” It’s either all-encompassing or it isn’t. And it won’t be.

“Selectively forget” and “selectively again” is the way the contemporary world processes such things, and few of us manage to do better. But we need to try.

You’d think I could learn

We say “never,” because we instinctively know that it’s better to keep such memories alive. We talk about the personal fear we felt at national tragedies, because it makes us part of the story, a part of the memory — and possibly part of the reason it won’t happen again, or will happen less often.

“Where were you on 9/​11?” is a question people used to ask one another, the same way that Americans once spoke of the JFK assassination and other events crucial to the story we tell of our nation and ourselves.

The further we remove ourselves, the worse we do at keeping our memories central to the discussion, the easier it will be to forget. And the more we forget, the more it all becomes selective, or partisan — and an opportunity for a big joke, a cruel laugh, no matter how sacred the subject.

Advertise with us

And then, when the next tragedy occurs, the “never agains” will come out again, because people want a world where these things do not happen. And we’ll do our best, for a moment, to remember why “never” matters, only to forget after a time. It could be different.

A young firebrand is dead, and with him, there is so much more about our country we need to grieve. Something, perhaps, we should all remember.

Adriana E. Ramírez is the editor of InReview, a member of the editorial board and a columnist writing about books, culture and politics for the Post-Gazette. She is the author of “The Violence,” available for pre-order from Scribner. her previous column was “Let me tell you why I don't like stop light cameras.”