On Tuesday, July 15, our very own Republican Sen. Dave McCormick convened a group of powerful political figures for a dinner and “fireside chat” at the Carnegie Museums in Oakland — ostensibly a private reception following the Energy and Innovation Summit at nearby Carnegie Mellon University.
The Carnegie Museums, explains its published policy, “does not accept bookings for partisan political events or fundraisers, including voter education, registration and get-out-the-vote drives led by partisan groups.” As a certain kind of nonprofit, it is obligated to refrain from “directly or indirectly participating in, or intervening in, any political campaign on behalf of (or in opposition to) any candidate for elective public office,” according to the IRS.
The organizers, which included PA Rising, a political group that promotes McCormick’s causes, assured the museum both in conversation and in writing that the event would not be a political fundraiser, and that no kind of contribution would be asked from attendees. The museum approved the event, in accordance with its own policy, as it would for any similar group. Indeed, not approving a Republican senator’s event would have been arguably partisan.
But the event was a ticketed event to support an organization with a partisan aims, costing $5,000 per person to attend both the dinner and chat, per their own advertising. Corporate “Marquee Event Sponsor” rates were $500,000 and included 24 dinner tickets and other benefits through PA Rising. To be clear: $5,000 a ticket is definitely a contribution.
Snakes in the grass
But the ensuing rage has not been directed at McCormick or PA Rising. Everything I’ve encountered, from one of my concerned neighbors, to people all over social media, has been directed at the museum.
“Time to cancel your membership,” a good friend of mine texted me.
“No,” I replied. “Time to cancel Dave McCormick’s.”
Carnegie Museums President Steven Knapp sent a letter, as reported by TribLive, less than a day after the event. “A number of you have raised questions or expressed concerns about the event that took place last night in our Oakland facility,” he wrote. “Whatever interpretations of the event may be circulating in social media and elsewhere, Carnegie Museums did not host or endorse the event.”
The museum received no money outside the standard rental fee, and I’ve been assured by sources close to the museum that none of their staff or leadership participated in, or were invited to, any part of the evening.
But a certain amount of skepticism remains. “How could they not know?” a local unaffiliated arts administrator told me. She also pointed out that even if they did know, the museum was in a bind.
“Let’s pretend for a minute that they found out before the event that it was essentially a fundraiser. If they cancel a clearly Republican event, after hosting so many liberal speakers and authors over the years, it will look partisan, too. Not in a tax-code way, but in a bring-attention-to-MAGAs way.”
“No arts organization wants to be under any scrutiny right now,” she added.
Their fangs, they bite deep
Either the museum was completely deceived by McCormick’s people, or the museum tried to look the other way to not invite examination from McCormick’s party. The local arts administrator had a point: There was no good decision.
Still, no good need exists to cancel one’s museum membership. We want the museums to thrive — with their art, history, dinosaurs, and bias toward accurate information.
I understand the online rage, though.“Seems like everyone is caving to the fascists lately,” someone wrote on a Reddit post about the matter, echoing the sentiments of many people across Pittsburgh-region social media. Local liberals have been watching public-serving institutions capitulate to the Trump Administration with horror, but it’s really hard to boycott any of them from here.
And it’s not like liberal rage aimed at McCormick doesn’t already exist. A Republican lying is not news (see everything from “no Medicaid cuts” to “we’ll release the Epstein files” to “we’re only deporting the worst of the worst”). Getting mad at the Carnegie Museum doesn’t solve anything, but it brings a certain amount of catharsis, even if it’s just blaming a victim for believing a lie in the first place.
But rage without direction is useless, and we risk throwing out the proverbial baby with the bathwater. The Carnegie Museums are not the bad guys here, not by any measure.
And their venom will creep
“Shame on the Carnegie Museums,” a local grassroots organization proclaimed in a social media post with hundreds of reactions and re-posts. And no matter how much I see the activist intentions behind their thoughts on this, I cannot help but be sad at how misguided and wrong they really are.
I urge everyone to visit both the Carnegie Museum of Natural History and the Carnegie Museum of Art before hovering over the “delete account” button. Canceling our museum memberships only hurts our own. We cannot eat our own tails in an attempt to show our enemies we have bite.
We should be encouraging our friends to buy more museum memberships. The nation needs us — all of us, across the political spectrum — to step up and defend whatever trustworthy institutions still remain. And Pittsburgh’s Carnegie Museums are certainly that, and more.
Adriana E. Ramírez is the editor of InReview, member of the editorial board and a columnist writing about books, culture and politics for the Post-Gazette. She is the author of “The Violence,” available for pre-order from Scribner.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.