When I was 19, I was arrested for a Class C Misdemeanor in Texas. I was not convicted of a crime, instead I pleaded “no contest” and rejoined polite society with only an arrest on my record.
Today, over twenty years later, I am worried that my youthful arrest — or the opinions expressed in this column — will be enough to officially deem me a person of “not good moral character.”
Normally, I would not care about such things, after all, haven’t we all committed at least one misdemeanor in our lives? I just got caught and put in jail for a few (terrifying) hours. Trust me, I learned my lesson.
But I’m also a naturalized U.S. citizen.
Got to be free
A Justice Department memo, released this week, directs U.S. attorneys to prioritize denaturalization in cases where people who have acquired U.S. citizenship do not have “good moral character” — which is “a subjective and broad term with little defined parameters,”as José Olivares writes in the Guardian.
The Trump administration is no longer just targeting people who are here illegally. This DOJ memo is horrifying, not just because of the subjectivity regarding “moral character” to more easily strip Americans of their citizenship, but because it also shifts the denaturalization process from federal courts into a civil process, where defendants have no rights to an attorney or due process.
Which is to say, if a Trump administration official decides on a whim that I fit the criteria, I can be disappeared overnight without legal recourse, sent to a detention center or deported to a country I haven’t lived in since I was three months old.
“When do we leave?” my husband asked me months ago. “When they start de-naturalizing people on flimsy pretexts,” I answered, sure that this would never happen. I hope I’m still right.
My husband is not one to resist a challenge — it’s in his genetics to stay and fight the good fight. He’s an American, with generations of family here dating back to colonial times, and he’s also the great-grandson of Joseph N. Welch, the lawyer who famously went up against Joseph McCarthy, asking him if he had no decency, sir, at long last. But even my husband can see the writing on the wall.
He’s also worried. The stories we have both heard from our hometowns in recent weeks, both in South Texas and in the midwest, are of people being taken in the night, sometimes by mistake, sometimes in error, always in the cruelest ways possible.
This morning, as we read over the DOJ memo, trying to parse what makes “good moral character,” I considered getting a lawyer to try to overturn or seal my arrest record, lasering off my two tattoos (in case someone thinks a small triceratops on my hip, or the owl on my back, is a gang symbol), or quitting writing to do something more anonymous.
“You’re too opinionated to be anonymous,” my husband has always told me.
Carry on
I’m worried that’s exactly what will get me in trouble. I care deeply about other people, about people across the world being killed just for existing, about people in my home state who will lose access to Medicaid and not get treatment for their terminal illnesses, about trans kids who are trying to figure themselves out in a world that wants to deny their existence.
Are these signs of “good moral character”? Or the opposite?
What does it mean that I had to earn my citizenship, screened and tested, when people with birthright citizenship are also being denied? When people who worked hard to be here, following the rules, are being whisked away overnight to South Sudan or an alligator swamp in the Everglades?
“Until this moment, Senator, I think I never really gauged your cruelty or your recklessness,” Joseph N. Welch said to McCarthy before his iconic line about decency.
Our immigration system was broken — too complicated, too underfunded, taking too long and costing too much. No one is denying that. But right now, the fallout, cruelty and recklessness of the Trump immigration agenda will be far worse than any of us could have ever gauged.
If my husband is considering leaving the U.S. for an offer elsewhere, how many others are doing the same before some small misdemeanor will come haunt them or their spouse?
We are losing top scientists and academics to universities abroad. Bloomberg reports that U.S. students have applied to study for undergraduate degrees in the U.K. in record numbers. More and more corporations are looking to open offices in Canada and elsewhere, “refugee” offices for people who are concerned about working in the United States.
This song of hope
I still love my country. After dropping my kids off with their grandmother in Ft. Lauderdale, my husband and I have been slowly driving our way home up the East Coast. It’s been beautiful, and every time we’ve spied preparations for the Fourth of July parades in each city we’ve driven through, my heart has swelled with patriotism.
This is my home, and I embrace everything about it — the good, the bad, the reckless, the breathtaking, the kind and the cruel. If only the feeling was mutual.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.