On March 14, 2025, Dr. Wayne N. Walters, Pittsburgh Public School superintendent, wrote in the Post-Gazette: “Just as our city prepares to host the NFL Draft — without knowing all the details but trusting in leadership and expertise to deliver a world-class event — we must apply that same trust and belief in creating a world-class education system for the children of Pittsburgh.”

I’ve been thinking about this paragraph a lot in the last three months, trying to give Walters the benefit of the doubt. I like the man, and I know he has the district’s best interests at heart. But I also know that the school district’s administration, along with the school board, have not necessarily earned the “trust” he is invoking here.

The NFL Draft’s leadership has a proven track record in getting things done. Our school district cannot say the same.

“Do you have backup?” a fellow soccer mother asked me at our final game last weekend. She is pulling her children out of the PPS in favor of a private school because “all the uncertainty is too much.”

Advertise with us

In a trance

She’s not wrong, the uncertainty has been a lot. The superintendent’s March op-ed came after 15 tumultuous months of solid public disapproval over how the district has approached the absolutely necessary facilities plan, including 14 possible school closures and new feeder patterns. It was not well received.

On the morning of March 19, a concerned parent sent a letter to the district noting they were “deeply troubled by the district’s insistence on moving forward without key financial and demographic data necessary for responsible decision-making.”

“I respectfully request that the board delay the vote until the district completes and publicly shares a full financial analysis, demographic study, and transportation impact report,” the letter continued.

“If the board proceeds without this essential information, I will have no choice but to pursue legal remedies, including seeking an injunction, to prevent the district from taking action without transparency and due diligence.”

That evening, during an agenda review meeting, a handful of Pittsburgh Public School directors “raised concerns about voting next week on a resolution that would open state-required public hearings on the closing of 10 school buildings,” as reported by the Post-Gazette’s Megan Tomasic.

Advertise with us

The directors pointed “to a lack of information such as cost estimates for proposed capital improvements, timelines for how long the improvements would take or when schools would actually close.”

I took the chance

The next Monday, over a hundred parents and community members protested outside the district’s administration building in Oakland. They were hoping to delay any school closures.

“There is still so much data that you need to inform your vote,” parent Andy Kubis told the Post-Gazette. “New attendance zones, feasibility of transportation, the basic price tag. Why are we rushing into a vote that can have such devastating consequences for this city?”

Two days later, the board of directors delayed a vote on closing 10 schools and finally began the search for a demographer, almost 18 months into the process.

“I recognize that we cannot avoid the impact of the erosion of trust this had on our relationship with members of the Pittsburgh Public Schools community,” Walters said at the meeting. “While this erosion has a long history, I fully accept the responsibility of helping to repair this.”

Advertise with us

“It’s more than just people being mad because we’re closing schools at this point,” Emma Yourd, member of the board, said. “It’s more that people are going to be mad because ... we have not done our own due diligence to provide those answers to them.”

In April, it was reported that no demographers were hired, after the district only received two weak bids after a just three-week call for proposals. Walters declared the district would be analyzing data in-house, citing the need for a quick turnaround.

“No wonder we only got two proposals and neither could do the job,” said Valerie Webb-Allman, parent and local activist, as reported in Public Source. “Anyone that knows the scope of work that is needed to be done could have told you that 75 to 90 days for a final report wasn’t nearly enough time.”

A lesson alright

In May, the district announced that only 12 schools would be closing, and that the gifted center would remain open another year. And last Wednesday, just a few days after parents launched a change.org petition to keep magnet students grandfathered into their schools whenever possible, Gene Walker, board president, and other board members pushed for the school to proceed with their plan for uninformed upheaval.

How can they move forward without the requested financial, transportation or demographic data? There is at least one board member who understands that the information is crucial.

Advertise with us

“I’m not trying to hold up the process,” Devon Taliaferro said. “I know there are people who feel like we are pausing, pausing, pausing. I don’t think we would have needed to pause if a little over a year ago we actually sat down and had a conversation first and laid out what this could look like before we just started doing. … But here we are about to make decisions.”

And so are the parents watching all this unfold. “What’s your backup?” is a question thousands are asking themselves right now. I’m not leaving yet, but I don’t blame them. The uncertainty is too much.

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “From Jim Crow to Juan Cuervo, the public gets it wrong.”