Terrible things are happening outside … poor helpless people are being dragged out of their homes. Families are torn apart; men, women and children are separated. Children come home from school to find that their parents have disappeared,” wrote Anne Frank in 1943 about Jews in Nazi Europe, but she may as well be writing it about immigrants in the United States today.
A family I know in Texas is, right now, debating whether or not to pack a bag and get out of the country. All four people in this family are here legally, but they are firmly aware that if they present themselves at their upcoming immigration hearings, to finalize the paperwork for their green cards, they will likely be picked up by I.C.E. Two other family members have already been taken in similar circumstances.
Some people will read about this family and be outraged on their behalf. They followed the rules, made asylum claims legally, and never broke a single law. An overwhelming majority of Americans — according to extensive polling — ostensibly support families like this.
But others — namely our president, his acolytes, and tens of millions of supporters — will enjoy this family’s fear. We are the nation of the free, unless, of course, your paperwork hasn’t been finalized. Then, in order for I.C.E. to easily meet quotas, anyone can be deported without regard for the process or the spirit of international asylum laws. Even a law-abiding family on the verge of getting their green cards.
Donald Trump’s War on Immigrants was never about criminality — otherwise they would not be picking up the people who follow the letter of the law. These public spectacles are about power and xenophobia.
This is authoritarianism, by every definition of the word. It’s time to be honest, it’s time to say the quiet part out loud.
Destroy the passersby
President Obama deported 3.1 million people over eight years, averaging out to 387,500 per year. For this feat, he earned the sobriquet “The Great Deporter.” If Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin in the Department of Homeland Security is to be believed, this administration is on track to surpass Obama’s record with more than 207,000 deported in five months alone.
But unlike the Obama administration, who removed undocumented expatriates without much fuss or bedlam, Trump’s people have chosen to do their jobs in the most terrifying and unconstitutional ways possible.
Conducting illegal sweeps at places of business, schools and churches? Check. Sending over 250 people to a Salvadoran gulag without due process? Check. Terrorizing people who are following the law and showing up for their immigration appointments? Check.
The authoritarian tendencies of the Trump administration transcend immigration: ignoring both the judiciary (despite a six justice conservative majority) and Congress (despite controlling both houses), politicizing the armed forces, federalizing the National Guard, attempting to prevent states from legislating against tech companies, attacking or demanding absolute fealty from private institutions like universities, law firms and media companies.
Shall I continue?
A shopping scheme
Trump’s use of immigration to take authoritarian control of the country has worked incredibly well. And I don’t believe that it’s actually driven by racism and white supremacy — I think simply having an “other” to collectively hate was enough. It just happens that most of the people targeted look and sound like me.
If Stephen Miller has his way, I’ll be denaturalized in the next year or so, stripped of a citizenship that I actually had to earn. I used to think that thoughts like this were exaggerations, impossible to actually see play out on the streets of Pittsburgh.
But it’s happening — again, as history is wont to demonstrate. Anne Frank’s words have returned to haunt us. People like her — refugees from Nazi Germany — had been ordered to leave their homes for places like present-day Guantanamo, just outside the reach of human rights laws. She was in the Netherlands illegally, hiding rather than be rounded up at an appointed time.
And here’s another quiet part worth saying out loud: some of the very fine people reading my words right now would have picked up the phone and reported Anne Frank to the authorities. After all, 39% of polled Americans recently said they approve of the Trump administration’s approach to immigration.
They don’t mind the “terrible things happening outside.” They don’t care that Trump is undermining civil liberties and the Constitution. They love that he’s throwing himself a parade, like some kind of king. They don’t mind the image of hundreds of tanks rolling into our nation’s capital. They think America should be what it was never designed to be — an authoritarian nation under a fearless leader.
It’s coming
I love my country. I filled out paperwork, I waited in lines, I passed tests to become a U.S. citizen. I take my oath seriously, and I firmly believe in the shining city on a hill that America aspired to be. And it is because I love my country that I am worried. Trump could have used the mechanisms of government to remove people the way Obama did, with dignity. But instead he chose authoritarian violence.
To quote the tweet that got Terry Moran, another casualty of the Trump administration, fired from his role as a Senior National Correspondent at ABC News: “Trump is a world-class hater. But his hatred [is] only a means to an end, and that end [is] his own glorification. That’s his spiritual nourishment.”
And our downfall.
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “America to Tourists: ‘Don’t come here’.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.