Pittsburgh has the potential to be a great city. Our city has that potential right now, in 2025, as much as it did back in 1868, when an English-born New Yorker named James Parton wrote about what was then “Pittsburg.”
It is in this essay for the Atlantic Monthly that Parton coined the phrase “hell with the lid taken off,” describing the spectacle one could view from Cliff Street. But more important is how he opens his essay:
In other towns the traveller can make up his list of lions, do them in a few hours, and go away satisfied; but here all is curious or wonderful, — site, environs, history, geology, business, aspect, atmosphere, customs, everything. Pittsburg is a place to read up for, to unpack your trunk and settle down at, to make excursions from, and to study as you would study a group of sciences.
I love that phrase, “all is curious or wonderful.” This is potential incarnate — a city of depth, possibilities and contradiction. Pittsburgh is a city both unfathomable and knowable.
I read Parton’s “Pittsburg” before I moved here in 2006 in my early 20s to pursue graduate studies at Pitt. Years later, I taught this essay to undergraduates. And now, another decade after that, I’m quoting it to you, dear reader.
And every time I’ve read it, I’ve seen something different, as I’ve better gotten to know the city I call home.
Everybody’s smilin’
“I chose Pittsburgh, it didn’t choose me,” I said to a friend last week, and I wasn’t kidding. I chose to stay here — and over the years, I’ve enticed other friends to move here too, including my then Seattle-based husband.
Pittsburgh has always been a city that attracts outsiders. In 1868, Parton’s “iron workers” hailed from over 20 countries, and their languages were widely represented throughout the region — including in Pittsburgh’s downtown Chinatown. The demographics have changed, but the diversity of our region has not.
Pittsburgh is a forever changing space, worthy of study. My views on the Steel City are also constantly evolving — which makes sense, given Parton’s description. But underneath my constant churning of opinion, there is a steady and immovable love.
But loving Pittsburgh, its rivers and its hills, its people and vernacular, its history and its food, does not make one blind to its deficiencies. One can deeply care for one’s city while also acknowledging its warts. And Pittsburgh has its warts.
I gotta get out
When I moved to Pittsburgh, I quickly realized how tough it was for nonwhite people. In the almost 20 years I’ve lived here I’ve experienced more outright verbal racism than I ever did growing up in Texas.
I wasn’t prepared to be told so many times to “go back to Mexico” for speaking Spanish in public. I used to think that was something cartoonishly racist people said in movies, until it was said to me on campus in Oakland with full yinzer sincerity.
My Black friends report worse. They cite examples of redlining, the lack of Black people working construction jobs (“look at who is holding the traffic flags, and who is operating the machinery”), the difficulty of getting a foot in the door. There’s a deep and complex history in this city of muting and ignoring people of color that cannot be easily reconciled with its goodness.
The city’s shortfalls don’t end there. Much of it looks shabby, when it really shouldn’t. Fixing up the streets and cleaning up trash could go a long way. Pittsburgh has access to tremendous natural resources that should be exploited, but we seem averse to actually developing our river- and hillsides into public spaces. Not to mention the schools and administrative issues.
The pandemic killed 90% of Pittsburgh’s nightlife, and after midnight, “ghost town” feels like a kind description of most of the city. Which isn’t the worst, except that something fun seems to have disappeared.
There was something cool about being “hell with the lid taken off.” Now, we’re a city perpetually on the verge of being cool, but never quite arriving.
Still, the potential cannot be denied. It’s all there — “site, environs, history, geology, business, aspect, atmosphere, customs, everything.”
Get me some of those rays
Mayor Ed Gainey recently lost the mayoral primary. He is a good man who was not reelected for a lot of reasons — only some of which were under his control.
The winner of the primary, current County Controller Corey O’Connor, will most likely prevail in November’s election and inherit all of Pittsburgh — the good, the bad, the warty.
But the fate of the city is not entirely in his hands. That responsibility is shared with all the people who live here. We are all in it together, and we should all do our parts. Even if it’s just putting on some rubber gloves and grabbing a trash bag.
Look around. The hills are alive, the rivers are singing, and there’s a chance that between all the rain-showers, there will be a sunshine day. What a glorious place to be. All curious or wonderful. Just like Pittsburgh.
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Pittsburgh, it’s time to change the mood.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.