State Senator Lisa Boscola, D-Northampton, believes that the time has come for Pennsylvania to take a stand.
The 18th Senate District lawmaker, whose constituency includes the Lehigh Valley, has signaled that she wants to introduce legislation to controversially recognize a distinctive representative of the state’s perseverance — something we can all rally around with pride.
We are, after all, the state of the Constitutional Conventions, the Whiskey Rebellion and the Liberty Bell. We have a proud history showcasing our fight and tenacity. So it makes sense that a new symbol would capture the revolutionary spirit of Pennsylvania — something Boscola knows well.
And yes, this is important to do at this moment in American history, as our country stumbles shakily into a constitutional crisis, testing the checks and balances of our government to achieve outcomes half the country cheers as needed comeuppance, and the other half worries will unwind the very fabric of democracy in America.
In this climate, what could be more crucial than designating Pennsylvania’s official state candy?
Pour some sugar on me
“Given Pennsylvania’s rich confectionery history, it is fitting that we finally honor one of our own with this unique designation,” Boscola wrote in a memo proposing legislation to designate Peeps, the marshmallow treat typically associated with Easter and manufactured in Bethlehem since 1953, as the official candy of the commonwealth.
“Peeps are not only a symbol of Pennsylvania’s well-earned reputation for satisfying candy cravings, but of our imagination and enduring spirit,” she noted.
And while the bill has not been submitted for introduction, the official co-sponsorship memo details are available. The senator’s arguments for Peeps are mainly that people love them around the world (including artists!) and the company contributes economically to the state. There’s a reference to the company’s record on “charitable initiatives, civic engagement and regional identity,” as well as a shoutout to the 5.5 million Peeps “born” each day.
But Boscola faces some competition. Senate Bill 1107 — introduced in the 2023-2024 session of the General Assembly (when the world was less on fire) by Sen. Steven Santarsiero, D-Bucks, and cosponsored by nine senators including four Republicans — seeks to designate Hershey’s Kisses as Pennsylvania’s official candy.
In the name of love
Peeps was always going to have a rough time challenging Kisses. Hershey has a theme park and worldwide recognition for myriad products, including the iconic and universally beloved Kisses.
According to Statista, 93% of Americans recognize a Hershey’s Kiss. The other 7% are probably under the age of three. An overwhelming number of those surveyed thought positively about the chocolate. We associate Hershey’s with S’mores, classic Americana and self-pampering at the end of a long day.
Peeps have a similar market recognition: About 90% of Americans know the brand but, crucially, only about 51% of Americans like them, with 81% associating them directly with Easter. Peeps are fine, don’t get me wrong, but I mostly think of them as a replacement for marshmallows in games of Chubby Bunny.
Still — there is a comfort to this ridiculous and lopsided rivalry (sorry, Peep lovers). It reminds me of the Before Times, like three months ago, when headlines about candy fights would have drawn us all into fierce debates.
I can imagine the marketing strategies of both companies, as cities across the commonwealth voted for their favorite confections, with outsiders judging us accordingly. It could have been fun. We could have argued for our favorite candy without feeling like we were distracting ourselves from something far more important.
Saccharine
But now, it feels like Boscola should have bigger priorities when it comes to defending the interests of her constituents — including Peeps. As their corporate website proclaims, “all of our candy is proudly made in the USA and Canada using globally-sourced ingredients.”
Those “globally-sourced ingredients” include sugar and gelatin. And despite being a producer of both of those products, national household consumption far outpaces what any domestic sugar grower or gelatin provider can yield.
There are many ways the senator could advocate for the candy industry, given that over 20,000 Pennsylvanians work for Hershey’s in addition to the 600 that work for Peeps. But if tariffs continue to rise and fall unpredictably, industry experts predict that layoffs are looming. Like many of the manufacturers in the state, Hershey’s and Peeps find themselves in a tough position.
There is no immediate solution to replacing international imports of raw goods. The U.S. cannot make enough sugar overnight to keep the confectionary industry from hurting. Candy-makers also can’t raise prices too much more without damaging their profits. According to Consumer Price Index data, prices have risen 89% since 2005 and consumption has decreased in response.
It’s telling that despite the senator’s memo creating a little buzz in the commonwealth’s media and around the watercooler, the state’s confectioners remain mostly silent, avoiding headlines as their industry lobbies at the federal level for relief.
I also would stay quiet if I owned a candy company — I wouldn’t even make a peep.
Adriana E. Ramírez is the editor of InReview and a columnist who writes about books, popular culture and politics for the Post-Gazette. She is the award-winning author of “Dead Boys.” Her previous column was “Is antisemitism the new McCarthyism?”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.