With the Democratic Party primary for mayor of Pittsburgh only a few weeks away, incumbent Mayor Ed Gainey seems to be stumbling against his challenger, County Controller Corey O’Connor.
One would imagine that, like most incumbents, he would be running on his achievements. Violent crime is lower in Pittsburgh, many neighborhoods are safer than they’ve ever been, he’s done his best to stand up for immigrants, and the city’s job growth is outpacing the region. Not to mention the NFL Draft!
All City Champion
But the first thing a potential voter sees on the mayor’s election website is a pop-up with garish red arrows making an argument that his opponent has Trump-adjacent “MAGA operatives” who are “working to elect Corey O’Connor.”
This talking point also has made its way into several of the mayor’s recent speeches. For an incumbent, he sure seems to talk a lot about O’Connor, unprovoked. He attacks his opponent as if O’Connor were already in charge and the one with a mayoral record to defend.
And Corey O’Connor’s website? Doesn’t mention Ed Gainey, not even once.
A lot of Democrats are scared right now. We’re watching the executive branch seize control in real-time, and most Democrats I know are pretty worried about democracy in America these days.
Gainey is taking advantage of these fears, hoping that enough voters will be convinced that O’Connor, a solid Democrat, is somehow beholden to “Trump advisers.” It’s a wild gambit and one that’s put Gainey on the defensive side of the ball, instead of at quarterback, where, as the one in office, he should be. “O’Connor hangs with Republicans!” is not the win Gainey thinks it is.
O’Connor’s website reveals someone with progressive values that square with the city’s electorate and with Ed Gainey himself. Both men agree on the problems, they just don’t agree on quite the same solutions.
But in choosing to ground this election in fear, Ed Gainey is taking the nuanced conversation the electorate needs about the issues away and into uncertain territory. And it’s not working.
Most Pittsburgh voters do not care who funds their mayoral election. Most Pittsburgh voters aren’t even aware that over a million dollars have been poured into this race.
Everybody is second-string
But people are aware that the mayor is embattled. People are aware that Pittsburgh needs more housing and that development here has not kept pace with cities we consider our rivals. If I had a nickel for every “we could be as nice as Cincinnati,” I’d use the money to buy my friend from Cincinnati a ride home. (She already moved to Missouri anyway.)
Still, we do need more housing. And I know that under the Gainey administration, developers, who build both homes and apartments, have felt stymied by many of the city’s demands regarding affordable housing. Some of the mayor’s advocates applaud this, but even they cannot deny that it has provided incentives for those developers, and other local businessmen, to donate to the challenger — who has shown himself more open to building in the city.
Republicans usually do not win elections in Pittsburgh, but they can use their money to indicate their displeasure with an incumbent. And I’m not sure Corey O’Connor should reject those funds — a coin in the donation bucket is a coin in the donation bucket.
A more cynical writer might say that O’Connor cannot ignore his biggest financial supporters nor can he ignore the people in his circles — that a “MAGA operative” speaking at the same event is a tacit association with their politics.
But I’m not so sure. I have not seen any evidence that O’Connor has pivoted to the right.
I got my own stickers now
The last few days, I’ve seen many work crews on the streets of Pittsburgh, patching some of the potholes — not enough, but still, an effort to mitigate a few of the worst ones. This is better politicking for voters like me, the ones who care about both their vehicle’s suspensions and the aesthetics of where they live.
If Gainey needs a reminder of what can happen to an embattled mayor, he doesn’t have to look very far back in Pittsburgh history. When former Mayor Bill Peduto found himself on the defensive in a tight election, he lost — to Ed Gainey. Still, I’ve heard more than one person mention how much they miss Peduto.
Ed Gainey needs to stop talking about Corey O’Connor and start talking about Ed Gainey. He needs to make a case for things staying on track, for his vision. He needs to articulate to voters like me why we shouldn’t want someone with new ideas in office, no matter who has funded that person’s campaign.
As of this moment, weeks from the election, Corey O’Connor is winning the yard-sign battle in the East End of Pittsburgh. If Gainey wants to change the narrative, he has to start with his own messaging, which means he needs to act like an incumbent mayor, one who’s worked for his city and can point to his accomplishments — without mentioning anyone else.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.