All the preschool talk these days is about kindergarten. Pittsburgh Public Schools released its lottery results last week, and most of the parents I know are discussing the results, figuring out how to navigate the city’s various magnet, charter and private schools, in addition to their district’s regular public offerings.
“I’m second on the waitlist for Montessori,” a fellow mother told me at ice-skating class. Another mentioned in the hallways at our preschool that she was on the waitlist for the Environmental Charter School.
Yet another mom I know was resigned to the fact that her daughter was going to go to her neighborhood-assigned school: “We can’t afford private school, and didn’t get into anywhere else, so we hope this works out.”
“You don’t sound happy,” I wrote back.
“Well, we’re thinking about moving in the next couple of years anyway,” she texted. When I asked her how far away she intended to move, she sent a crying laughter emoji before replying, “not far. Cranberry? Or maybe Mt. Lebanon? We’re looking for better schools.”
It’s a fickle world
Schools are only one reason people leave, but after several decades of suburban flight, Pittsburgh has fewer children living within its city limits than ever before. That’s why the district has to close schools and consolidate its offerings.
But rather than work with parents to keep them in the fold, Superintendent Wayne Walters instead sat on several recommendations for four months, only to go with the school board’s original consultant-driven plans, and lied to parents about doing all this in the name of equity. But closing a school like Fulton Elementary, while keeping a less diverse but better-performing school like Montessori open, will only exacerbate issues of equity.
Highly-motivated parents will play the lottery game, and when their child is not accepted into Montessori (the only remaining available K–5 magnet school) or CAPA (the only 6–12 magnet remaining), they will do exactly what any parent who could would do — seek out the best possible education for their child. And a lot of them are going to move out of the city.
PPS should have been honest and just said they did this to save money. They should have included parent representatives from the get-go. There would be less confusion and less hostility today if they had. But as I talk to people I know at school pickups for both my preschooler and first grader, I see their frustrations — and I cannot blame them at all.
Turned the darkness into sunlight
Fulton Elementary in Highland Park used to have a reading proficiency rate of 37%. In the last five years, they’ve brought that number up to 57%. A combination of veteran teachers and new hires have banded together to improve these numbers, and the efforts are paying off. Math scores are up too.
The school, which is 73% African American in a neighborhood that’s only 13% Black, is by all accounts an educational success story, and continues to trend upwards. The sharp contrast in demographics is due to PPS’s magnet system, which allows students from all over the city to attend schools like Fulton, which has a French-language focus. The Fulton Parents I spoke to are incredibly happy with their school.
“The teachers care so much about their students,” one parent, who lives across town, told me. “It means a lot for my daughter to attend school in a different — and nice — neighborhood. I want her to imagine a bigger life than the one we have.”
“It’s good for these kids to see what life is like in a different neighborhood,” she continued. “And Baby Girl is reading. Like … I cannot check out enough books from the library. That’s because of Fulton.”
But this parent is also concerned. In Fall 2026, when her daughter is supposed to start fourth grade, Fulton will close, leaving her three options: try to get her child into Montessori via a lottery, try to get into a charter school with an equally long wait-list, or attend her assigned school in an area of town that makes her uncomfortable.
There is a fourth option she doesn’t want to consider: “Then I gotta move, right?”
It’ll be a long road
I want to keep as many parents in Pittsburgh as possible. I often tell people that I attended a pretty mediocre school district in Texas, going by the numbers, and I managed just fine. But I had a mother who worked part-time and volunteered at my elementary school.
Any highly-motivated parent, with the time and ability, is going to make sure their child is educated, no matter which school they attend. These are the type of parents who will read and do math with their children. I don’t worry about these students, they’ll be fine at any school.
But there are some parents who depend more on schools to do the job. They work demanding hours and try to keep their households afloat. They want to trust in a district that respects them and hears their concerns. And right now, Pittsburgh Public Schools has disappointed a tremendous number of parents through the absolutely-necessary consolidation process.
I don’t know anyone who feels good about district administration these days — and I would not be surprised if future enrollment numbers reflected this. We have a district with big wins and great teachers — I only wish the school district understood that too, instead of shuttering the very places whose work we should be replicating. The kids of Fulton deserve more.
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Progressives should admit that Donald Trump might do something right.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.