In these times of uncertainty, my family has turned to our faith to ground us, despite decades of being less observant than we should be. But now, my husband and I are trying to be better about celebrating Shabbat every week — and personally, I’m trying to embrace the savory side of being Jewish.
And so, for the last few months, I’ve rolled up my sleeves and done my best to bake my kids the best challah ever. (So far.)
The problem is that I’m a really bad breadmaker.
Give faith a fighting chance
Or maybe I just haven’t found the right recipe. I have a fraught relationship with Jewish cuisine.
As someone who didn’t discover her Sephardic lineage until her early 20s, I didn’t grow up within Jewish cooking traditions. I grew up making Mexican and Colombian food, forever flattening and frying corn while making both tortillas and arepas. But I want something more for my children, a better connection to the ancient and a better sense of all the people that made them possible.

A few years ago, I began collecting Jewish cookbooks. We have some pretty good ones. “Sephardi: Cooking the History” by Hélène Jawhara-Piñer focuses on the cuisine of my ancestors. “The Children’s Jewish Holiday Kitchen” by Joan Nathan highlights recipes I can make with my children.
I love looking up recipes, deftly scanning the physical pages for whatever dish I seek when I’m in a rush, or, if I have the time, taking a few minutes to read through the accompanying text.
Every Jewish cookbook involves storytelling. This, one author will assert, is how my grandmother prepared this meal. This, another will echo, is how this recipe was passed down and modified over the generations.
And like any work dictating tradition, there’s wiggle room for disagreement. Don’t have orange blossom water? Try vanilla extract and orange zest. Don’t have sour cream? Try Greek yogurt.
All cooking requires negotiation between what we have in our possession and what we need to acquire to make it work. Shall I follow the recipe exactly? When is it okay to improvise? And exactly how many jalapeños can I add to this before my husband complains?
Always keep that hunger
There is no consensus on how to make challah. All of my cookbooks have different ratios of yeast, egg, flour, oil and water. Some require a 45-minute proof (letting it rise in a warm, dry place) before braiding, and another requires a 2-hour proof after. Some use sugar, some honey.
It is easy to get overwhelmed. “This is not supposed to be so stressful,” my husband told me, after watching me punch a giant ball of dough into submission. “It’s supposed to be relaxing.”
I was avoiding the news, I told him, and this seemed better than anything on CNN. He laughed before offering to knead it himself (“this might need some more water,” he offered, before seeing the expression on my face).
“I am following the recipe,” I said. But the recipe, which I followed to the letter, yielded a bread that sounded like five wooden doors glued together when I knocked on its surface, instead of the hollow sound I expected.
We ate it anyway — a little butter and jam fixing all flaws. It was still bread, after all. Just not the bread I wanted.
A wheel in constant motion
The best recipe I’ve tried so far is from “Nosh: Plant-Forward Recipes Celebrating Modern Jewish Cuisine” by Micah Siva, a cookbook that’s quickly become a staple in my home (my husband is vegetarian).
It’s rare for me to reach a point in the recipe when the author writes, “the dough should be sticky,” and I actually find myself with dough that’s sticky. But when I made Siva’s challah — well, reader, the dough was sticky!
It was a thrill, but I tried a completely different recipe right after, trying to learn as much as I could from all the ways it went wrong. My children often join me in blundering my way through a new challah recipe. I’m not sure we’ve learned much about making bread, but we’ve learned a lot about failure.
We do not talk about failure enough. It’s difficult, in a country that values winning the way we do, to embrace the positive side of our missteps. But traditions are messy and always have been — we persist with them not because we seek perfection, but because they connect us to our ancestors and help us define ourselves on this convoluted planet.

My mother-in-law joined us in our baking endeavors this weekend, and she reminded us of a book she loves to read to our kids, “Bubbie & Rivka’s Best-Ever Challah (So Far!)” by Sarah Lynne Reul. In it, a woman and her granddaughter work hard to perfect their challah recipe, and each one becomes the best one, “so far.”
In my house, the best challah (so far!) was made months ago, but we’re still failing and learning — for the fun of it, and for a chance to cover our mistakes in butter and jam and eat them anyway. Because the next recipe might be the best one yet, and there’s no other way to find out.
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “We can’t change Washington, but we can change Pittsburgh.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.