In 2020, President Donald Trump issued an executive order banning TikTok, the popular video-sharing app. The sensitive data collected by the app “threatens to allow the Chinese Communist Party access to Americans’ personal and proprietary information,” the order said, “potentially allowing China to track the locations of Federal employees and contractors, build dossiers of personal information for blackmail, and conduct corporate espionage.”
It never materialized. Trump lost an election. Then last year Congress passed a bipartisan bill agreeing with 2020 Trump, and the Supreme Court upheld it. The company had until Sunday to find a new owner or be banned from app stores and hosting services, meaning a steady loss of their business over time.
Nothing happened, because Trump gave them 90 more days. “I have a warm spot in my heart for TikTok,” he said just after winning the presidency. (There’s a reason the CEO of TikTok attended Trump’s inauguration Monday.)
It turns out that the will of Congress and the Supreme Court are meaningless if the president changes his mind.
Tick-tock on the clock
I get why the youths are angry about the ban. During the pandemic, TikTok created a community for kids and teens suffering through the isolation of quarantine. They made friends and shared hobbies on TikTok. The ban has the potential to cut them off from so much — connections, fame and, for the select few, money.
I should note that I am not on TikTok. I’ve been slowly dialing down my presence on social media over the years. But every now and then, something from TikTok is reposted on the social media I do consume.
And I watch. I’m particularly drawn to BookTok and videos of people cleaning and reorganizing, as well as poignant political observations often recorded, for some reason, in the front seat of a car.
A friend has been telling me to get on TikTok, as I have a book coming out next year, and I absolutely need to “connect with that audience.” Anyone with any kind of public presence can’t easily ignore 170 million U.S. users.
And many more. The world is shrunk immensely through the platform, and it’s easy to watch posts from as far away as Indonesia and the Faroe Islands, and for those Indonesians and Faroese to buy an American writer’s book.
TikTok is also a commercial juggernaut, selling products in its own e-commerce store and hosting millions of advertisements. And, arguably, its most valuable product: users’ data.
But the party don’t stop, no
As many netizens have noted, TikTok is not the only social media company to sell its users’ data. Chinese connections aren’t unique either. The BBC pointed out that back in 2018, Facebook had a “data-sharing partnership with Chinese firms including Huawei, a company U.S. intelligence previously flagged as a security threat.”
Most young adults on TikTok don’t care about their data being collected by the Chinese government. They don’t see China as a threat, and are flocking in incredible numbers to the Chinese version of TikTok, called “Red Note” in the U.S., or “Little Red Book,” in China. Few of them even understand the reference.
Which is to say: young people seemingly don’t care about their data, and certainly not about their data in specifically Chinese hands. Most can intuit that their personal personal information has been sold their entire lives, by every app they’ve ever used. And they aren’t wrong.
On Sunday, the application came back online after voluntarily taking itself completely offline. TikTok said “We are fortunate that President Trump has indicated that he will work with us on a solution to reinstate TikTok once he takes office,” in a pop-up message on every user’s home screen.
DJ, blow my speakers up
As some joyously fete the suspension of the ban, I am worried they don’t see or care about the implications of such clear presidential meddling. A country where the president can simply refuse to enforce the law as written, and as sustained by the highest court in the land, is concerning.
“You know who blocks information?,” one blond teen asked on a viral TikTok video, “fascists do.”
Also, historically, the U.S. Government: the Comstock Act, 1917’s Trading with the Enemy Act, the 1934 Hays Act for films, the Office of Censorship during WWII, the McCarran-Walter Act, and the struck-down Communications Decency Act, to name a few. Some were successful, some were struck down and some of those were eventually modified.
But like the TikTok ban, they were laws properly passed by Congress and signed by the president. The executive branch of our government exists to enforce the law.
But that all hinges on an executive willing to do that.
Presidents are allowed to change their minds. But what they can’t do is change the law. Whether correct or not, America has a law governing TikTok passed by Congress and upheld by the Supreme Court.
Trump may have “a warm spot in [his] heart for the app,” but as president, he should enforce the law, however he feels about it. No matter how much he hates it, that’s the job.
You know who ignores the law and rules by fiat? Not democratically elected leaders, that’s for sure.
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Can John Fetterman influence Donald Trump?”.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.