The average American estimates that 21% of the country is transgender, according to a YouGov poll released two years ago that recirculated on social media during the 2024 holidays.

Ordinary Americans believe that one out of every five individuals is transgender, a staggering number when transgender people are roughly 1% of the population. (The number swells to 1.6% if you include non-binary folks.)

This answers a question that has been bothering me since anti-transgender ads (who can deny the political brilliance of “Kamala is for they/​them, President Trump is for you”?) began dominating the airwaves during election season: Why did so many people seem to care so much about such a small population?

Why do so many Americans feel there are so many of them? Why worry about transgender athletes in women’s sports, when fewer than 10 transgender athletes are actively competing in the NCAA? Why do so many people care so deeply about a population that is tiny enough to be a rounding error (0.002% of college athletes)?

Advertise with us

Turns out, they thought it was a much bigger number.

The terror of knowing

The 2022 YouGov poll reveals other wild mis-estimates by respondents. Average Americans think approximately 30% of the country is Jewish, lives in New York City, or are atheists, when the true figures are between 2 to 3% for all three. We believe that 30% of Americans live in Texas, when the reality is closer to 9%.

But these numbers make sense when held against the cultural landscape. It’s not hard to find television shows set in New York City or Texas, it’s not hard to find representations of Jewish people in televisual media. And, in order to not offend the 30% of Americans who are not Christians, most representations of family life in the U.S. tend to be secular, which too many can read as not religious at all.

Americans believe that 41% of the population is Black, when the real number is 12%. (Pittsburgh is 23% African American.) Americans also believe that we are 39% Latino, when Latinos only make up 17% of the population.

I blame advertising. Almost every magazine ad that features more than three people includes a Black person. As do most television shows and films these days. Latinos are also prominent in the same media.

Advertise with us

This is not a bad thing. Familiarity with people from diverse backgrounds benefits everyone. But it does lead to a skewed sense of exactly how many people comprise any given minority group.

What this world is about

In other words, there’s Perceived America and there’s Real America. When majority Americans begin to feel Perceived America as too foreign, too different, too queer and too un-American, certain candidates and media figures begin exactly the kind of fear-mongering we witnessed last election.

And many people, including voters, believe them. And that’s why in 2024 alone, 669 bills in 43 state legislatures sought to limit trans rights, despite the fact that 58% to 71% of Americans (estimates vary) don’t know a transgender person.

Perhaps the reason is that many Americans feel the identity of our country is up for grabs — is not only up for grabs but being lost — and explain their feeling by exaggerating the numbers of the people they consider threatening.

There’s another group in Perceived America I haven’t mentioned. Americans believe that 27% of their fellow Americans are Muslim, when the number is only 1%. Perhaps that explains why Muslims, both American and foreign, along with the transgendered, are often feared and treated as threats to America. We demonize what we don’t understand.

Advertise with us

Under pressure

The real numbers will never reflect those of Perceived America. The people seen as threats will never be the threats so many Americans fear.

We remain a country with an established majority (Christian, white and heterosexual) that lives in constant panic that it’s under attack by ever-growing minorities (non-Christian, non-white and non-heterosexual). This is why we hear the word “invasion” so much, to keep us afraid of that which will never come to pass.

It behooves politicians from both parties to keep us scared of one another, instead of focusing on one of the most telling details from the YouGov poll: We believe that 20% of us earn over $1 million in household income, when the truth is less than 0.5% do.

A country where 20% of us are millionaires offers more promise than one where not even 1% of us are. But as long as we’re distracted by the threat of invasion by the few, we’ll never notice the financial climb 99.5% of us face each day.

The country we perceive is not the one we live in, and it might be worth considering who has benefitted the most from the gulf between what we think we know and what actually is.

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Does Trump want war with Panama?”