I grew up Republican in South Texas in the 1980s, and despite changing my mind on many things and moving away, I retain many of my childhood friends to this day. We exchange photographs of our kids, talk smack about sports and current affairs, have a meal whenever I make it back into town and stay connected via social media.

When I post something political on Facebook, a few of them will inevitably comment, occasionally writing things that cause my other, more liberal friends, to write and ask, “Why are you still friends with these people?”

Oftentimes, I respond with “It helps me not live in a bubble,” and “they’re really kind about other issues.” Sometimes I’ll evoke childhood nostalgia and the importance of old friends. As our country, and the world, becomes more and more divided, though, the nostalgia of shared teenaged beers can do little to justify having to read the hatred and vitriol some of those childhood friends express online.

After one particularly bad exchange, a good friend cautioned me: “You should block or unfriend these people.” I did not disagree. I also did not unfriend anyone.

Advertise with us

I knew you were trouble

Bear with me: Taylor Swift has a friend who liked some pro-MAGA comments online. This person, the wife of a big deal football player, is photographed often with Swift, as Swift is dating a player on the same team — yet Swift, as established in her documentary “Miss Americana,” is supposedly liberal and actively invested in American politics.

“How can she be friends with a Trump supporter?,” the internet cried. Or as a capitalization-hating post on X with over a half-million views notes, “taylor swift hugging brittany mahomes, a sexual assault apologist who is a proud trump supporter, who trump literally shouted out on his social media platform the other day… Miss americana? ‘activism’? lmao”

Y’all. We have lost the plot.

Taylor Swift, like all human beings, is allowed to have friends who disagree with her politically — if she does disagree, that is. Swift is allowed to enjoy the company of her boyfriend’s co-worker’s spouse. Being friends with someone does not mean that you endorse or subscribe to their political beliefs, nor does it negate your activism.

“Friendships are complicated,” a sociologist trained at the University of Pittsburgh told me in an email interview. “It’s really tough for people over the age of 35 to make new friends, and some people might be willing to overlook differences in the name of getting along.”

Advertise with us

Shake it off

“Of course, going along to get along has some risks,” he added. “Everyone has lines: for some people they are very deep things. For other people, their reasons might seem shallow to the naked eye.” He went on to note that political disagreement alone, historically, is a common cause for friendships to collapse, but also, those kinds of friend-breakups are on the rise in the era of Trump.

The sociologist believes that things will change once the political temperature cools. Both Taylor Swift and I will be allowed to have controversial friends without commentary or judgment. In his estimation, to quote the pop star, “we need to calm down.”

I spoke to a political activist acquaintance, one of the folks who often recommends culling my friends list, and asked if being “calm” was the answer. She vehemently disagreed.

“What’s the old saying? ‘You are the company you keep’? Hypothetically, how can a woman who is a billionaire, from decades of hard work, hang out with another woman who espouses retrograde views about a woman’s place? At some point there is a deep incompatibility that is impossible to shake off.”

“We live in a country where roughly half the inhabitants want to deport, deny, forcibly impregnate, and jail the people who disagree with them,” she added. “Political disagreement is no longer about tax rates or the economy. It’s about the character of our country.”

Advertise with us

Look what you made me do

My conservative friends from Texas agreed, albeit in a different way. “Liberals want the government to pay for everything, while murdering the unborn, confusing gender, and stifling business,” a good friend from high school texted. “Y’all are unhinged and live in a fantasy world, and then turn around and call us the bad guys? I’m not racist or a rape-apologist for liking Trump. That kind of talk only pushes people further away.” I demurred on some points and agreed on others, like friends do.

I emerged better from the conversations, an experience that happens when I talk with any of my friends.

I know people who no longer speak to relatives over their political views. But more often than not, it’s the lack of civility that causes the alienation, not the politics themselves. And on that front, nuance has been abandoned for fervent party-speak, on both sides.

It’s harder and harder to be a moderate, at least when it comes to friendships. Maybe there is too much at stake? Perhaps Swift and I need to rethink who we “mad love”?

I asked my conservative friend why he still kept up with me, despite all my horrible points of view. He laughed for a solid ten seconds.

Advertise with us

“Because it’s good to know the enemy, Ramírez.”

Previous column: “No, JD, grandma and grandpa can’t always help.”