During an interview on C-SPAN, vice-presidential candidate JD Vance was asked by Charlie Kirk of Turning Point Action, “how will we lower the cost of daycare?”

As Kirk pointed out, most employed parents of preschool children often pay a significant amount of money each month for the privilege of working. I pay over $1,000 for my preschooler’s childcare, and I’m lucky: there was a spot in a great school that met our needs. And, more importantly, my family can afford it.

Instead of discussing the very real plight of the parents who cannot, though, Vance answered Kirk’s question by saying “families could choose whatever model they want,” including getting grandparental assistance. Which betrays Vance’s ignorance about how few Americans have access to those kinds of support networks.

No help

“Maybe Grandma and Grandpa want to help a little bit more,” he said with a serious face before adding, “maybe there’s an uncle or aunt who wants to help a little bit more.”

Advertise with us

As many on social media have already pointed out, not every grandparent wants to help out with their grandchildren — and not every grandparent, aunt, or uncle who wants to can afford to do so. Vance’s comment also makes a lot of assumptions about people’s relationships with their parents.

My parents live in South America, so dropping off our youngest whenever we need to go to our jobs is not really an option on that front. My husband’s parents live in Chicago. We have no blood relatives in the Pittsburgh area, and when we did years ago, we saw them rarely, as both our families were quite busy. And we get along with our relatives.

But as many prestigious magazines, including the Atlantic and the New Yorker, have been pointing out for years, parental estrangement is on the rise, which means that many people my age purposefully choose not to include their parents.

Millennials and Xennials have cut off relatives more than any other generation in contemporary American history, and the trend is only rising. Plenty of people would prefer to struggle more with bills than to engage with their parents, who are often perceived as toxic.

This trend cuts across race, class, and spirituality. Roughly 30% of Americans are currently estranged from a close family member, according to polling from YouGov, with an additional 10% having reported experiencing familial estrangement at some point.

Advertise with us

Toxic relatives

Anecdotally, more and more people are discussing their estrangements, especially from parental figures, on social media. Familial toxicity, it turns out, is a significant part of American culture.

But, sure, JD Vance, maybe a family member wants to help. The question is: should we let them?

Initiating estrangement is not easy, and for many there are great personal and financial risks and losses. Youth are preferring foster care and homelessness to remaining at home, while adults would rather be a little more cash-poor and pay a stranger to raise their children than interact with their own relatives. And the wild thing about it? Most are happier for it.

“[After] four years of no contact with my mom and almost two decades without my other parent,” Emi Nietfeld wrote for Slate, “I want to shout: Estrangement can also feel wonderful!”

Attached to that happiness is a greater societal cost as well. Being disconnected from family means more people relying on government services when traditional support systems are unavailable. And that means having a very real discussion about keeping preschool affordable for people who, for whatever reason, cannot find a nontoxic relative with enough free time.

Advertise with us

Reality

I like the world JD Vance is proposing though, one in which everyone lives near and gets along with their family. I can imagine villages working together to raise children. But in order for that to happen, there would have to be real support for mental health and other medical issues that allow communities like that to thrive.

That’s not our reality. We live in an America where almost half of adults have experienced some form of familial estrangement in their lifetime. We live in an America where most children do not live in the same cities as their parents. We live in an America that requires access to good daycare and preschool facilities.

Vance followed up his initial comments with a consideration of all the certifications required for early childhood education, suggesting that the cost of daycare and preschool would depreciate if teachers required less training.

Once again, Vance misses the mark completely. Parents don’t want just any person looking after their children. They want someone who knows what they are doing, with all the credentials and certifications to reassure a parent that they are leaving their children in good hands.

Otherwise, they would have just called in the grandparents.

Previous column: “1, 2, 3, 4, I declare an egg war.”