During a court hearing about the merger between two grocery store chains this week, as reported by Newsweek, an email between Kroger executives revealed that grocery stores had raised prices beyond the rate of inflation.
“On milk and eggs, retail inflation has been significantly higher than cost inflation,” Kroger’s Senior Director for Pricing Andy Groff wrote.
The cost of an egg
The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that the average cost of a dozen Grade A large eggs was $3.08 in July. About two years ago, the same eggs were priced under $2, a level that managed to hold steady for six years.
Egg prices depend on several factors. Producers manage inventories and set prices accordingly, as do store owners and other food manufacturing giants. A shortage in eggs would naturally drive prices up, as determined by the law of supply and demand.
Farmers blame bird flu, increased pandemic egg consumption, and, yes, the supply chain and its evil twin, inflation — farmers have costs, too. The egg supply chain is relatively simple, though, and primarily at the mercy of major chicken operations. In fact, last year egg suppliers were ordered to pay over $50 million to food manufacturers for “a conspiracy to limit the egg supply” over a decade ago.
The jury found that the egg-providing farms sold eggs to other countries to reduce domestic supply, as well as deliberately limited the number of chickens producing eggs, according to documents out of the federal court in Illinois.
So what gives? Groff, the Kroger executive, excited to join with Albertson’s in the biggest supermarket merger in our country’s history, accidentally revealed the truth of American capitalism: inflation may be real, but the first rule of price-making is always profit.
“Retail inflation,” the markup that stores apply to their goods, has been higher than “cost inflation” because people will pay $3 for a carton of eggs. They’ll do it complaining the entire time, but they’ll do it.
Paying the price
And because moms still like to bake, because we enjoy omelets for breakfast and because eggs are a part of the American diet, egg consumption will not substantially drop. We’re an egg-eating people.
So long as we are willing to pay the price, there’s no reason for the grocery store to lower it.
But the news about prices has the grocery store chains feeling vilified. In fact, to hear them tell it, they’re barely making ends meet.
Greg Ferrara, president and CEO of the National Grocers Association, explained to Fox Business that “higher labor costs and inflationary pressures that ripple through the supply chain” can only increase prices at the store.
“Our members are not publicly traded companies, but in 2023, our members realized a net profit margin of 1.4%, so they are making very little margin at a time when they’re dealing with inflationary pressures or dealing with increased labor costs,” Ferrara said.
Of course a net profit margin of 1.4% for a business with a trailing 12-months revenue of over $150 billion is still over $2 billion in net profit. No wonder they need to merge to provide fewer options for consumers: We all know that eliminating competition is how major corporations scrape by.
Ferrara believes “labor is a huge component” of the high prices at the stores, and he noted that they’ve seen “significant wage increases since before the pandemic,” across the entire market. Overall worker pay in the United States has increased 12% in that time, which seems like some more money for the average worker, about $900 a year. But during the same period, grocery costs have increased 25%.
Avoiding solutions
Unless, of course, Ferrara is referring to the fact that the industry is used to paying for undocumented labor and now has to switch to paying legal workers minimum wage. Because when Ferrara says “significant wage increases,” he’s partially discussing the fact that our policies toward undocumented immigration and labor since the pandemic have actually lowered the number of farm workers.
Reversing these trends would lower prices. Or as Land O’Lakes CEO Beth Ford told Time, “allowing more immigration would help ease costs in the stretched industry.”
There are fewer hands to collect eggs, but there remains a steady and unyielding demand for them. We import eggs from abroad when there are, occasionally deliberate and occasionally caused by bird flu, shortages. We pay for the fuel supplies to transport eggs from around the world into our stores. And we complain about the cost.
But we don’t want to set price limits, as that would be anti-capitalist. We don’t want undocumented immigrants, as we are scared of them. And we don’t want to pay what something is worth in a system designed to punish working people most of all. We want to be angry, but not actually look to real solutions.
And as long as we’re willing to pay, the prices will never drop.
Previous column: “The BNY Mellon School for All Students.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.