One of my old writing professors at Pitt, Bruce Dobler, told me not to worship any writer. One of his writing professors — and a writer I deeply admired — Kurt Vonnegut, had cautioned him not to do that.
“Writers are deeply flawed people,” he said Vonnegut told him. “You are too. It’s what makes you interesting. It’s what makes you want to write. It’s what makes you worth reading.”
But that’s not how fandom works. Fans often idolize the person they think the writers are as much as they love what they put on the page. It’s why people face such crushing disappointment when their idols turn out to be as deeply flawed as so many are.
A tarnished legacy
When short-story master Alice Munro died this spring, many readers grieved for the Nobel laureate, once called “Canada’s Chekov.”
Her short stories captured the inner lives of women in small-town Ontario, beautiful and deft portraits that revealed something more troubling under the surface. Munro’s creative life grappled with large questions about family secrets and feminine desire — all while she depicted her non-writing life as boring, stable, and full of love.
But in the last few days, the literary world has reckoned with unsavory revelations from Munro’s youngest daughter in the Toronto Star, chronicling how Munro stayed with her second husband despite her daughter detailing how he’d sexually abused her.
This was not a case of she-said-he-said. Andrea Skinner painfully recounts how her step-father abused her when she was nine. She writes about eventually telling her mother, about taking her step-father to court 30 years later, where he pleaded guilty to the assault. She writes about her mother remaining with him, forgiving him and loving him — which only deepened Skinner’s feelings of isolation and hurt.
Eventually, Skinner went from little to no contact with her mother, who kept claiming a “very close” relationship with all her children in interviews.
As the details of Skinner’s experience spread, many of Munro’s fans find themselves in shock — weighing their love of her writing with her actions as a mother. But as people wrestle with how to reconcile the woman with her art, I find myself trying to unpack why we ever expected Munro to be so perfect in the first place.
I am not trying to defend Munro, but as someone who has read many of her stories, her pain and confusion around this subject seems very clear. Many of her characters find themselves in parallel situations, choosing between what they desire and what they know they should do.
“The heart wants what it wants” is not always healthy or good, as far as life philosophies go, but it drives many of the stories we’ve been reading for centuries.
Munro’s children, Skinner and her three siblings, are not asking for Munro’s Nobel or work to be canceled. They’re asking for a complete portrait of their mother to exist, one that reveals a woman we would not hold up as a perfect role model, but a woman who made incredible art worthy of praise.
Unforgiveness
When we speak of Munro, we should speak of her mastery of a written form as much as we speak of her complexity as a human being. Her actions in life have cast a shadow over her works of art and creativity. We should read her work again, knowing what we know now.
Her legacy is big enough that it can hold conflicting emotions. Alice Munro hurt her child. Alice Munro wrote some of the best short stories in the North American literary canon. Both of these things can be true.
We don’t have to forgive artists to love their work. We don’t have to forgive the bad to love the good. But what we must do is discuss it — even if it feels disrespectful, even if Munro has no opportunity to reply.
In an incredible essay in the Massachusetts Review, “Fire to the Grass,” Amba Azaad articulates the importance of “radical unforgiveness,” and considers the importance of talking about abuse and estrangement.
“Here’s a freeing thought,” Azaad writes. “What if one has a responsibility to unforgive, what if one is achieving some measure of restitution by being a stone against the flood that tries to wash away the evidence of wrongdoing? By not being able to forgive, you are not failing at humanity. You are reforming humanity — by being a record keeper, by bearing witness.”
As our idols fall, we must bear witness. We must unforgive. We can love them without editing away all they are — imperfect and perfect all at once.
Our heroes are deeply flawed people. It’s what makes them interesting. It’s what makes us want to write about them. It’s what keeps us reading. But we also need to hold them accountable: We should condemn their actions, loudly and clearly, so they are never imitated.
Or as Asaad put it, “Radical unforgiveness renames your experience from acceptable, and therefore good enough for others, to unacceptable and not to be replicated.”
We don’t have to forgive Alice Munro to love her work or to learn from her mistakes.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Her previous column was “The brutal death of a 14-year-old reminds us how fragile trans lives are.” Find her on X: @zadri.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.