At the heart of the questions surrounding women’s reproductive rights is the question of “life.” Many people in this country believe that life begins at conception. As a Jewish person, I believe that life begins at birth. My friend, a developmental biologist, believes that life begins at viability.

And while we can argue the question of life for millenia, as we have, that question centers the real-or-potential-depending-on-your-view baby and leaves the mother completely out of the equation. Discission of women’s reproductive rights often tends to omit, well, the woman.

But on this, the week of the second anniversary of the Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization decision that overturned both Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood v. Casey, leaving it up to individual states to determine their own abortion laws, it’s time to recenter the conversation.

Some states, like Texas and Louisiana, have dramatically restricted access to abortion. Idaho’s equally restrictive laws remain selectively paused until things can unravel themselves after a recent (and weirdly leaked) Supreme Court decision. In this way, former President Donald Trump’s vision of “allowing the states to decide” has worked out well for the more conservative states.

Advertise with us

But it has not worked out for their women.

Maternal death zones

A recent study by the Center for Disease Control revealed that the U.S. was not as big of an outlier in maternal mortality rates as we previously believed. Due to an error in checking off “pregnant” when a person died, many non-pregnancy-related deaths were counted as maternal deaths. Our number went down from over 22 deaths per 100,000 live births to slightly over 10.

Still — most of the developed world reported fewer than five deaths per 100,000 live births, the same numbers as some states in the U.S. The states with the lowest maternal mortality rates, states like California, Illinois and Colorado, had numbers that were a third of our highest reporting states, places like Arkansas, Kentucky and Alabama.

There is a direct correlation between high maternal mortality rates and restricted access to abortions at the state level in our country. In the 24 months since Dobbs was decided, the data are beginning to emerge, and it doesn’t look good for pregnant Americans living in states without access to abortion. States with abortion restrictions had maternal death rates that were 62% higher than states with better access.

Of course, correlation is not causation. I’m not saying that abortions save maternal lives, although that’s not to be discounted either. I am saying that the states that center their laws around women, and their health, have indisputably better outcomes than states that center their laws around the unborn. And that’s as uncomfortable to type as I imagine it is for you to read.

Advertise with us

Bodily autonomy

When Democrats talk about abortions, they talk about women. Dr. Jill Biden recently addressed a crowd on the anniversary of Dobbs here in Pittsburgh, where she shared stories of very real women who had abortions. She talked about the shame, about the hurt — about the person whose body carried a question neither government nor faith can solve to everyone’s satisfaction.

When I think about abortion, I think about my friends, the women who have had difficult pregnancies and whose bodies put them in untenable positions. I think about a young girl I knew in Texas whose extraordinary life, now saving countless of other people’s as a research oncologist, would have ended up differently if not for the abortion access that used to exist there.

In the estimation of those who ignore the body carrying a fetus, the woman is not the protagonist of her own story once she is pregnant. And in removing those stories, in removing the “I” that gets bodily autonomy, we endanger that body. Or as the maternal mortality rates reveal: A woman who is pregnant in Pittsburgh will have a better chance of not dying than if she was equally pregnant in Dallas.

The Supreme Court

Right now, the fate of women’s reproductive rights is in the hands of the Supreme Court. Democrats believe that possibly two seats will open up during the next administration, given the number of rising septuagenarians, and are pushing voters to overcome any distaste for Biden into a vote for a solidly liberal jurisprudence.

But the Supreme Court seems to be signaling a shift in its rhetoric with its recent Idaho decision, reinstating a pause on banning emergency abortions. The dismissal tables the subject until after November, but it also opens the way for women in Idaho to receive life-saving healthcare.

Advertise with us

And until the pause is lifted, it might give Idaho a chance to decrease its maternal mortality numbers, which were higher than the national average — before and after the CDC recalibrated its metric.

There is a lot more to say about the maternal mortality rate in this country, including an equally uncomfortable discussion of race. But that would require talking about women as human beings with bodily integrity and dignity. I know why women get lost in the debate — I think sometimes for good reason. But even the best reasons can lead to bad outcomes.

We need to show that as a country we value our women, we respect them and, most of all, we want them to live.

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Her previous column was “The nuanced politics of Summer Lee.” Find her on X: @zadri.