The Pittsburgh Public School District is broke or broken — perhaps both. The district’s finances seem convoluted, both excessive and insufficient, and it’s created a panic about the future of the 20,000 students who attend its schools.
I know because I’m one of those people, worried about sending my kids into PPS for their education when everything seems so unclear and uncertain.
It shouldn’t be this way. PPS spends somewhere between $24K to $35K per student each year. When factoring in the size and budget of the school district, PPS spends more per student than most other school districts in the state. Our schools should be flush.
All the problems money hasn’t fixed
If the schools can spend so much per student, why do buildings lack proper air conditioning and ventilation systems? Why have so many restoration projects fallen aside? Why are so many teachers and staff members unhappy?
How is it that neighboring Fox Chapel School District spent $6K less per student than PPS in 2022 and is able to outperform PPS on crucial academic and satisfaction metrics? This is true of most school districts in the Pittsburgh suburbs.
It’s not entirely PPS’s fault. An aging infrastructure, retiring teacher population and decreasing enrollments have stretched their seemingly ample budget. But those decreasing enrollments might be a consequence of the problem as much as they are the result — parental dissatisfaction with school districts is one of the main reasons people leave.
Read More
A friend of mine was considering a move to Fox Chapel until her children were accepted at a prestigious charter school in the city. She’s not alone. Over 5,000 students are now enrolled in Pittsburgh charter schools. Many parents who still believe in the district prefer to send their kids into magnet schools instead of the ones down the street.
On my block, not a single family sends their kids to the neighborhood school. All are enrolled in magnets, charters and private schools. And that neighborhood school, in the middle of an upper-middle-class neighborhood in the city, suffers for all those potential students leaving.
And now, as the district faces financial shortfalls due to decreases in tax revenue, the situation looks dire. There is talk of school consolidation, increasing classroom sizes and making an already-complicated system even more difficult to navigate.
It’s the working class kids who’ll suffer
Both my husband and I are public school kids. He went to a magnet school in Chicago, and I attended one of the worst school districts in the state of Texas. But we had safety nets to catch us. We were both identified as gifted early in our educations and that allowed us access to a certain privilege, even in dire circumstances.
Which is to say, I’m not worried about the obviously gifted kids. Or the upper-middle-class kids on my street. There are gifted and talented programs that will find them, teachers that will identify them and after-school support their parents will seek out. I’m not worried about the kids whose parents can afford a tutor.
I’m worried about working class kids in neighborhood schools, whose parents do not know how to navigate the magnet lottery, who will not be accepted into a private school no matter how many vouchers the governor grants them, who will most suffer from the aging facilities and dissatisfaction of their instructors.
A decent public education is a mandate of good government. Pointing fingers does little to alleviate the harm that a badly run school district can inflict. No amount of money will help if there isn’t a cogent plan and the leadership to implement it.
One of my children is finishing up kindergarten this year in a PPS school. My child loves their teacher and so far, my husband and I have been happy. But we’re not deaf to the concerns that other parents are expressing on Facebook and in school board meetings.
Given the ages of my children, I will be a PPS parent for the next fourteen years. I am hopeful that by the time my youngest child graduates, PPS will have gotten its act together.
Good schools can save a city
If we want to talk about how to save our city from shrinking, how to keep people invested in Pittsburgh, we have to talk about its schools. Good schools lead to good outcomes for everyone, even people who do not have children.
Kids who are engaged in the act of learning in school are more likely to attend college and less likely to commit crime. Communities with strong school districts have more civic pride and engagement across the generations. The county and region as a whole will prosper. We all need to be invested in what happens to PPS.
Maybe that means paying more in property taxes, as PPS says. But I worry about throwing more money at a problem that it seems cannot be solved with money alone.
We all want Pittsburgh children to succeed. It’s time to focus on what needs to be done to help them do exactly that.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Find her on X @zadri. Her previous column was “A royal mess with the press.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.