Michelle and her husband Roger, friends when I lived in Texas, had spent years trying to conceive. All they wanted in the world was a child. She came from a family of eight, and he came from a family of six. Both of them had imagined a large, rambunctious crew of kids, playing in their large suburban yard. (Names and identifying details have been changed for this story.)
But Michelle’s body seemed to have trouble staying pregnant. She suffered natural miscarriages six times, never quite making it to the second trimester of pregnancy, and enduring trauma after trauma.
A horror show
“The first few pregnancies, we were so excited. By the fifth time, we braced ourselves. How will we miscarry this time? I heard six little heartbeats and then, weeks later, each one of those lub-dubs became crushing silence,” she said. “I am not even going to tell you how it went, the miscarriages, but, yes, it was a horror show.”
She didn’t have to tell me. I have suffered miscarriages in my life, and I’m painfully aware of the understatement contained in “horror show.”
And like many people who lose a pregnancy early, Michelle and Roger suffered quietly. “The first or second time you lose a pregnancy, you tell people,” Roger told me. “The sixth time, you sob into your latte, pick yourself up and go teach — work can be a blessed distraction sometimes.”
And then, in the fall of 2021, Michelle had a pregnancy that seemed to stick. She celebrated each milestone with exuberance: the strong heartbeat, an ultrasound that revealed a spine, the slow formation of the person they would love: their miracle baby.
Twelve weeks, they found out the gender — a girl. They painted the nursery pink, green and yellow to welcome her. And then in the second trimester, after the joyous Facebook announcement, after the baby showers, after an old family crib had been restored and lovingly repainted, Michelle went in for some standard genetic testing.
To say the results were devastating does not do justice to their pain. Michelle and Roger learned that the fetus suffered from a genetic disorder. An amniocentesis confirmed what the doctor already suspected — trisomy 18. There was over a 90% chance that their child would never live.
Weeks later, as they figured out what to do, Michelle began bleeding and visited the emergency room twice, each time with increasing complications. For her own health, their doctor suggested they terminate.
“We prayed. And we prayed. And we talked to doctors. We talked to our pastor. We prayed some more. And then we made the hardest decision of our lives. But I knew that if I wanted to have a baby, a successful pregnancy, we had to terminate this one. Seeing [this one] through could eliminate that possibility.”
So in early 2022, holding her husband’s hand so hard that he still has a small scar bearing the bow of her nails, Michelle had an abortion. She does not remember a moment of the entire ordeal when she was not sobbing.
Cruel fate and cruel laws
“My baby girl, she was born dead,” Michelle said through tears. And reader, I couldn’t help but also cry.
If Michelle had fallen pregnant only four months later, she would not have been able to have an abortion — at least not in Texas.
Today, Michelle is following the Kate Cox case with deep concern. Michelle believes that Ms. Cox should have been the poster child for health exemptions — a woman with an unviable pregnancy, also suffering from trisomy 18, who would face great risk ever conceiving again if the pregnancy was allowed to continue.
“She should have been allowed to terminate immediately,” said Michelle. “I cannot imagine how she feels.” She paused before adding, “I can imagine a little.”
“There, but for the grace of all that is holy and a few months, is me.”
Michelle doesn’t like telling people about her experience. She finds more judgment than empathy — people who tell her she should have seen the pregnancy through. People who tell her that she is a terrible person. She and Roger remain grateful that abortion was an option.
“People have the idea that women who have second and third trimester abortions are just monsters, but most of us are severely traumatized women who had planned on seeing our babies.”
Late-pregnancy abortions represent less than 1% of abortions. But in listening to the rhetoric, one could easily think they account for the majority. Most women in this position are women like Michelle, like Kate Cox, like the six thousand other women in our country every year who will suffer the inhumanity and cruelty of fate, only to then encounter the inhumanity and cruelty of our laws.
Michelle ended our video chat early, all this discussion had upset her, and she didn’t want to spend the afternoon upset. She had a baby to take care of, after all.
Baby R was born a year after Michelle and Roger terminated their pregnancy. She’s a chubby little princess, festooned in pink, oozing health and starting to babble.
To all the Kates of the world
“I had to wait longer for my miracle baby,” Michelle said. “It’s sobering to think that without my perfectly safe and legal abortion, there’s a chance she wouldn’t be here.”
“To all the Kates of the world, I see you. And I’m sorry, I’m so sorry that the impossible is so much harder for you. It shouldn’t be. I’m so sorry.”
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com. Her previous column was “Being Jewish when everyone is talking about — and for — us.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.