Last Tuesday, Western Pennsylvania came out to vote. And while the results overwhelmingly favored Democrats for most statewide offices, the two highest-profile offices in Allegheny County were split.
Sara Innamorato defeated Joe Rockey for Allegheny County executive by a margin of 2%. She will be the first woman to serve the position, and the most progressive Democrat as well.
For many progressives in the Pittsburgh area, this feels like a mandate. Ms. Innamorato joins a coalition of similarly minded elected officials, like Mayor Ed Gainey, Councilperson Bethany Hallam and U.S. Rep. Summer Lee. Voters seem to be firmly entrenched in giving leftist politicians a chance.
On the other hand, in the race for Allegheny County district attorney, Republican Stephen A. Zappala Jr. defeated Democratic challenger Matt Dugan by 3% — a strangely Republican victory for Mr. Zappala, who had been defeated by Mr. Dugan in the Democratic primary.
Mixed messages
If one were to view both these victories strictly through the lens of campaign advertisements, though, it would seem a mixed situation. Mr. Rockey ran a campaign that depicted Ms. Innamorato as an “extremist” who should be “feared” with her “Socialist agenda.”
Mr. Dugan ran ads depicting Mr. Zappala as an “out of touch” former Democrat, describing his 20-plus years in service as “arrogant, stagnant and lacking leadership.” A victory for Mr. Zappala, according to Mr. Dugan, would mean elevating someone responsible for “stark prosecutorial racial disparities” into office.
Mr. Dugan seemed poised to ride Ms. Innamorato’s victory to the DA’s office, but voters didn’t oblige. Thousands of people chose differently, and the Innamorato-Zappala voter made all the difference — even though they seem to stand for wildly disparate principles.
Mr. Zappala represents an older, more centrist kind of Democrat than Ms. Innamorato. She promotes holistic solutions to incarceration, like social services and attacking the roots of poverty, while he promotes taking criminals off the streets and putting them in jail. But, in a climate ruled by fear of encroaching encampments by unhoused people, and by a fear of crime downtown (even though on the whole, crime is down), Mr. Zappala’s positions remain popular. And for all the Democratic candidates’ progressive values, having Mr. Zappala to balance out Allegheny County’s progressive mandate is a positive — for now.
Striking a balance
“It just seems like [Mr. Zappala] will continue to clean up the streets, and [Ms. Innamorto will] make sure he’s not going overboard,” one voter in Squirrel Hill told me, erroneously assuming the county executive has oversight of the district attorney. “I feel like [Mr. Dugan] is an unknown quantity — he can say all these liberal things, but I’m not sure I actually trust him to keep the city safe.”
Another voter, in Highland Park, thought that “the county needs a yin and a yang. Sara will be the human being who cares about people, and Steve will make sure the streets are safer. They’re a good combo, and one that shows that Allegheny County isn’t just a bunch of single-minded people.”
A voter in Greenfield expressed disappointment. “I’m probably the strangest person you’ll talk to,” he said. “I voted for Rockey and Dugan. I liked the idea of a former business executive becoming our county executive, and I liked the idea of having a progressive liberal in the D.A.’s office. It seemed like a good balance.”
“We aren’t just one thing,” a voter in Oakland commented. “Pundits and political analysts like to pretend voters are one thing — a D or an R on a checklist. But people pay more attention than you think,” she added.
Another voter in Oakland disagreed. “It’s about name recognition. People knew Zappala was a Democrat. And they liked him more — historically. They knew his name. It has nothing to do with people paying attention. Most people vote down party lines. Zappala is an exception, not the norm.”
A political scientist at Pitt and voting expert told me that the “Innamorato-Zappala” voter is not an unusual beast, and that most of the people I’d already spoken to were correct. “What propelled Innamorato and Zappala to victory? A combination of party politics, name recognition, a lack of clear and informed opinions, and people who like to buck expectations.”
Voters are complicated
Their terms in office will show what’s possible. Mr. Zappala is likely winding down his political career, and while Ms. Innamorato is only beginning, both have a chance to shape the region and its politics for years to come.
“It’s not that a Republican cannot win,” said a voter from Morningside who is also a political analyst. “Everyone wants to make these incredibly dire proclamations about what this election means, but it’s not true. Rockey demonstrates that a good Republican could win — but Rockey himself needed to clarify his stance on abortion. In hiding from it, he did himself a disservice. Sometimes saying nothing at all only makes the problem worse. Without abortion [as an issue], this election would have been very different.”
“I voted for Rockey,” the Morningside voter added, “and I voted for Zappala. We need candidates with experience. And both these guys have that. I’m disappointed that [Ms. Innamorato] won, as a moderate Republican, but I am hopeful that maybe she’ll learn to be more centrist. After all, she has another election in four years.”
“In four years,” a progressive voter in Lawrenceville told me, “Zappala will probably retire. We’ll have some new person to debate over — who is much stronger than Dugan, and let’s be honest, he wasn’t as appealing as he could have been. And by then? Sara Innamorato will have experience doing the job. With her ‘pragmatic progressive’ attitude, a willing coalition of experienced volunteers and four years of work (done, hopefully, correctly), she’ll be unstoppable.”
“Unless,” he added, “she messes it all up. That’s the chance we took in voting her into office. But the beauty of it is that by then, we’ll get another chance to decide.”
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.