Joe Rockey, Republican candidate for Allegheny County Executive, tried to distance himself from the national party at a recent campaign stop at the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh.
“I stand here representing the middle, and my view [is] that the middle is the true view of Allegheny County,” he said. “We have an opportunity in this election to put leadership in charge that will solve the problems of Allegheny County and do it in a centrist manner.”
Mr. Rockey is trying to appeal to moderate Democrats in a county where Democrats outnumber Republicans two-to-one – and to some degree his strategy is working. “Rockey for County Executive” signs are peppering traditionally left-leaning neighborhoods in Pittsburgh, including Squirrel Hill, Shadyside and Highland Park. He stands the best chance of any Republican candidate in years to win countywide office.
It’s easy to understand why. In a time of divisive politics, an appeal to the middle is attractive to people tired of radicalism, nationally from conservatives and locally from progressives. Mr. Rockey’s calls for moderation allow him to campaign as a Republican-in-name-only.
It’s why Mr. Rockey’s campaign has focused on painting his opponent, former state representative Sara Innamorato, as an out-of-touch leftist, here to destroy society with her … social services for unhoused people and fair property assessments? He calls her “too extreme” for Allegheny County, in direct opposition to his Mitt-Romney-in-a-quarter-zip charm.
The problem is that Joe Rockey is not a moderate: He’s a Republican. The two categories are mutually exclusive. He may play a moderate on television, but he still comes from and runs with the same Republican Party that has been rejected in Allegheny County for decades.
At the same time, despite Mr. Rockey’s attempts to paint his opponent as a radical, he and Ms. Innamorato seem to agree on many things.
He wants more county police to aid municipalities in curbing violent crime. She also wants more police to curb crime – plus more social services to attack the root of poverty.
He wants to help businesses invest in the county. She wants the same, but with protections for workers, the environment and the vulnerable included.
He wants a new warden for the county jail and better oversight. She wants a new warden for the county jail and community oversight.
They both want the new juvenile detention center to be run ethically. They both want to work with community stakeholders to improve outcomes for everyone. What’s different is how they will do it – and who will work with them.
There are serious points of disagreement, of course, like reproductive health and the value of regulations and concern for the environment, but for someone singularly focused on painting his opponent as a crazy person, Mr. Rockey sure seems to agree with Ms. Innamorato an awful lot.
It’s fair to say that Mr. Rockey doesn’t represent the extreme faction of his party. He’s just a normal Republican of a different era, closer to Mr. Romney and George W. Bush than Donald Trump. He believes, dubiously, that more capitalism is the solution to what plagues us, and that his experience as a risk officer for a bank will translate directly into running a county.
But the job of County Executive is unlike anything he has yet experienced, involving a totally different kind of leadership. Most of all, governing involves collaborative leadership, on the local and state level, which means whoever is elected will rely on their political networks.
For Ms. Innamorato, that will include a coalition of progressives, from Mayor Ed Gainey to U.S. Rep. Summer Lee and all the unions in between. For Mr. Rockey that will include his Republican allies, plus a few unions here and there. He has not indicated that he is building a coalition of moderates across the aisle. He has only promised to lead “in a centrist manner,” which in no way implies that his appointees will be like-minded.
And this is where Mr. Rockey’s political party becomes an unavoidable issue.
There’s a saying in Spanish, “Díme con quién andas, decirte he quién eres.” It comes from “Don Quixote” and translates to “tell me who you are with, and I’ll tell you who you are.”
Mr. Rockey, for instance, is with Sam DeMarco, a county councilman and chair of the county GOP – and one of the people who, as the Washington Post put it, “signed up to be a false elector for then-President Donald Trump amid Republican efforts to seize the 2020 victory from Joe Biden.”
The office of County Executive will control the county elections board during a national election that is sure to be controversial. Should someone who runs in the same circles as a “false elector” really be in charge of our elections?
County election boards print and distribute ballots for people who vote by mail, and determine access to drop boxes as well as how to count provisional ballots. If elected, who will Mr. Rockey appoint to these positions? How confident can we be that these appointments will be working “in a centrist manner”?
No matter what Mr. Rockey’s views are, he emerged from, and will be beholden to, Republican leaders, Republican operatives and, above all, his four Republican mega-donors. They will be his advisers and confidants. They will be the people he calls on to fill the boards and committees that really shape Allegheny County.
And we haven’t even mentioned the elephant in the room: Mr. Rockey will not comment on reproductive rights, a silence that strongly suggests he is anti-abortion.
The office of the County Executive may have a marginal impact on abortion providers, but Ms. Innamorato is not claiming that a victory for Mr. Rockey will eliminate access to reproductive health. The idea is to remind voters that Mr. Rockey has Republican views.
Which makes sense, because Mr. Rockey is a Republican. No matter how moderate he pretends to be.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com. Her previous column was “Lessons from Venezuela.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.