My daughter and I were going through her Halloween costume options earlier this month, trying on various costumes and working out ideas adjacent to her ideal look (“Unicorn Princess Fairy Ninja”). Between one thing and another, I found an old witch’s hat.

I offered it to her, and she tried it on, declaring that because it had shiny stars, it was a “wizard’s hat.” When I pointed out that lady wizards were called “witches,” she resisted the categorization completely.

“Mama, I don’t want to be a witch,” she said. “Witches are old and ugly.”

It was hard to argue; in every children’s book we own, the witches are by far the most grotesque creatures. Our home library is not alone — a quick image search for “witch” yields some truly hideous crones. Warts abound, as does green skin, pointy noses, impossible chins, and toothlessness.

Advertise with us

“There’s a reason for that,” an expert on witches in Latin America told me in an interview. “You see the emergence of the ‘ugly witch’ in Europe after the discovery of the New World. Consider how so many 15th-through-18th-century fairy tales center on exploring an unknown forest and coming across a powerful old woman. Before then, witches were canonically beautiful seductresses.”

In fact, to hear this anthropologist tell it, we think of witches as aged and unsightly to undermine their power, and to cement the belief that women with knowledge are unattractive. He told me about one scholar who believed that the discolored skin comes from the look of corpses after witch trials; it’s not a stretch of the imagination for someone to turn green after torture.

For the ignorant medieval observer, the witches, in death, had “shed their costumes and become their true selves: bloated hideous olive-skinned devils.” In reality, it was just a bruised and drowned body under scrutiny.

But to designate witches as “other,” or inhuman, furthered a goal. Witches operated at the intersection of faith and the physical, which threatened both the Church and the men who wanted to wield the power associated with healing.

“Witches were usually remedy-makers: curanderas, brujas, medicine-women. They oversaw the domain of childbirth, palliative care and pharmaceuticals — a one-stop primary caregiver. The woman was the center of life. Especially within indigenous cultures, who worshiped goddesses.”

Advertise with us

The anthropologist believes that the medicalization of birth, which consisted of eliminating midwives from the equation and hospitalizing those in labor, is an extension of the colonial practices regarding witchcraft. Men took over matters of reproduction, because women were not to be trusted. To hear him tell it, witch-hunts were a harbinger of present-day sexist behaviors.

“Look at political attack ads against women candidates,” the anthropologist said. “They’re always pictured with their mouths open, as if they’re yelling at us. They’re always in black-and-white, stripped of the life and youth in their skin. And it's effective. The ugly truth of our culture is that it’s easier to hate an unattractive woman.”

I thought about the very ad I’d seen that morning at physical therapy on the television screen as I did my prescribed leg raises. Yes, almost all these conditions were met.

“The witch-hunts never really ended, did they?” I offered.

“We still use ‘witches’ as a pejorative for women we don’t like,” he told me. “All of it is a different face to the same misogyny. Back then and today. Witches alternate between being beautiful temptresses and these ugly old women, but the truth is that most witches look like ordinary people.”

Advertise with us

“I’m sorry, what?” I thought I’d heard the anthropologist incorrectly.

“Most witches today look like ordinary people.”

“There are still witches today?” For a second, I considered whether or not I’d been magicked to an alternate reality.

Of course, I knew he was right. There are obviously witches today. Wiccans exist, and I know various women who call themselves “brujas” or even “brujex.” But I don’t really connect them with Halloween witches. Most of my brujex friends are really into herbal remedies, gardening, and lighting candles.

But that is an extension of the same rituals that have always existed. Women have been doing this work since ancient times. I’m not going to lie, I wasn’t sad when my friend M got me some palo santo to cleanse my office last year. As the stick released its holy smoke, I felt something calming and otherworldly.

Advertise with us

I thought about finding reruns of “Bewitched” to watch with my daughter. Or maybe taking her down to the Occult Shop in Bloomfield. It might be nice to behold a not-hideous modern-day witch.

The anthropologist insisted I do exactly that. Witches, in his opinion, are overdue for a makeover in the public imagination. Or at least some acknowledgement.

“There have always been witches. Witches are eternal.” The anthropologist smiled. “And some of them are pretty cute.”

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com. Her previous column was “Librarians and other educators tell their stories from the culture war frontlines.”