Around the country, school administrators are melting under the pressure of loud and organized opposition to diversity in children’s books. Astroturfed “grassroots” organizations and well-funded legislative initiatives are aiming to put “concerned parents” in charge of reading lists — and they’re winning.

A Chicago-based librarian told me that even though she hasn’t encountered any parental resistance yet, “it’s certainly something I’m aware of in selecting titles. … I have well-rehearsed reasons as to why they are valuable to our students. It’s an unfortunate reality of today’s librarianship.”

The new battleground is the classic Scholastic Book Fair.

Book fair battles

Advertise with us

When most people think of educational publishers, they remember the in-school Scholastic Books Fairs of their youth, as well as the fun newspaper-style catalog, full of titles that enriched and changed lives.

These days, however, the once innocent sales have become a culture war flashpoint. In response to legislation passed or pending in 30 states that would limit access to diverse titles under the misleading name of “protecting children” or “parent’s rights,” Scholastic has decided to segregate “LGBTQIA+ titles and books that engage with the presence of racism in our country” into an optional collection called “Share Every Story, Celebrate Every Voice.”

In other words, the organization that should represent boldly defending the rights of readers and the value of books for opening hearts and minds is, instead, furthering the idea that everyone but straight white people belong the in the “other” category.

Many writers, teachers, and librarians have spoken out against Scholastic, arguing rightly the company is bowing to a handful of angry bigots at the expense of diversity. Disguised as “parental choice” or “control,” the movement is really about a minority faction demanding to censor public discourse to suit its own tastes and ideology.

Books for, and about, everyone

Advertise with us

The librarians know it. Over the course of several days, I spoke with over ten librarians and English teachers across the nation, none of whom consented to have their names printed. They were afraid of exactly the type of retribution Scholastic outlined.

“It’s insidious,” an educator from Pittsburgh told me, “because it sounds so reasonable at first. We want to protect children, they say. But this is really about getting people like me to quit. To destabilize education. To say it failed. And to some degree, we’re playing right into their hands.” He spoke at length about colleagues in the suburbs of major cities who had quit because of continued harassment. “But they’re complaining about books, when we have a generation of kids who cannot read.”

An educator from the South Hills agreed. “I looked up some of the supposedly offensive books in our library: Two kids had checked them out in the last year. Two. But we got over 20 emails about one of those titles. This at a time when most of our students are at least three grade levels behind on reading. Taking away books that might interest them will only make it worse.”

If these censors succeed, what can we expect from our future generations? I think about this a lot as I raise my children. It’s important that they learn to process the full range of their emotions — including the guilt and shame that might come from reading about the treatment of Black and Indigenous people, and so many others, in American history.

In confronting the realities of life, we learn to be better. A generation raised to think that their people have never benefited from the oppression of others is dishonest at best and harmful at worst.

Advertise with us

“This is about not making white kids feel bad about the role of white people in slavery,” a librarian from Texas told me. “It’s like they think they can completely erase anything that makes them uncomfortable. But the whole point of reading a book is to practice discomfort — that way you’re better prepared to confront real life. Reading is about developing empathy for people who are different. It’s why so many books are about outsiders, rebels, iconoclasts.”

“But what happens when they meet a queer person in a business meeting?” she continued. “What happens when they encounter a museum exhibit on American slavery in another country? Is it better to learn about the ugly side of history when you’re young, or to confront the lie of your education as an adult?”

The real snowflakes

“What I find most ironic is that the same people who call educated liberals ‘snowflakes,’ are the ones who now claim that kids can’t handle reading about racism,” one Pittsburgh-based librarian told me. “Racism is real. Slavery happened. How are we supposed to learn from history if we’re being censored?”

“It’s only a handful of parents who are causing the most damage,” a children’s librarian from Philadelphia told me. “But they are affecting what everyone else can read. But for the most part, parents haven’t even read the books they’re contesting. Just knowing that someone in them might be queer or oppressed is enough.”

Advertise with us

Or as an English teacher from Texas told me, “I fully believe that librarians are experts on books … and parents can object to books for their kids but not my class.”

“Books have value, whether you agree with the contents or not,” the librarian from Chicago said. “There are books I don’t personally want to read, and there are certainly books I would recommend a child read with an adult, but that just means a conversation needs to be had, not that the book shouldn’t be read.”

“If Scholastic really wanted to ‘Share Every Story, Celebrate Every Voice,’ they wouldn’t segregate the titles,” the Pittsburgh librarian offered. “That should be the name of all their offerings — not just the one for people who don’t want to dumb down their kids’ education.”

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.