When Nikole Hannah-Jones and The New York Times published “The 1619 Project,” people got big mad. The project argues that the history of the United States does not begin with the American Revolution of 1776, as Americans have been taught. It began in the year 1619, when enslaved people came to Jamestown, marking the true beginning of the American experiment.

Historians on the right end of the spectrum decried it as revisionist history, reframing the revered happenings of nation-building around the plight of enslaved African people and the heartless aggression of white Europeans. Historians on the left end of the spectrum decried it for ignoring the previous and continuing enslavement of native peoples.

Questioning history

The first was wrong, the second right. History is meant to be questioned. After all, historians are humans too. They have biases, opinions, and leanings just like everyone else. To pretend that history is objective is to not understand history at all.

Advertise with us

“History isn’t what happened. It’s who tells the story,” scholar Sally Roesch Wagner told the New York Times. And the truth is that American history is often told from only one point of view. Is there more to the story of our continent than what we’ve been told by the white Europeans who conquered it? Obviously.

For example, in the United States, the war that was fought between the U.S. and Mexico is called The Mexican War, or The Mexican-American War. In Mexico, it’s called the Intervention of the United States in México (La intervención estadounidense en México).

From the American perspective, the war was about defending American interests regarding Texas, the independent nation recently departed from Mexico that was on the verge of being annexed into the United States. For Mexicans, it was about the United States straight up invading their country, killing innocent children and taking land that wasn’t theirs.

Whose version is right? Whose is wrong? Depends what side of the border you identify with and what version of history you were taught.

History matters

Advertise with us

Some people don’t care. “History is written by the victor,” they’ll say, a claim often mis-attributed to my problematic fave Winston Churchill. “So what?” they might ask. “The winners get to tell the story, that’s how it works.”

But that’s not how it always works. The story of Jesus Christ is not told through Roman eyes. The story of Anne Frank focused only on Nazi side of things will never be as compelling as the story told from the point of view of the young girl in hiding. Would “Braveheart” have worked so well if it were told only from the English side?

I had a nonfiction writing professor who once told me that anyone researching oral history should talk to as many people involved in a conflict and look for the truth in commonalities. And it’s true — I see it all the time with my children and their fights. My 3-year-old will have one version of what happened, and her 5-year-old brother will have another. What really happened is where their truths overlap.

In order to better understand the history of our country, we need every type of historian, speaking from every possible identity, to step up and retell the story of America. Nikole Hannah-Jones should be only the beginning — and we should embrace this.

As anyone who has ever been to therapy knows, self-improvement comes from self-recognition. We have to be willing to look at our true selves, ugly parts and all.

Advertise with us

America held accountable

The writer Michael Harriot attempts to hold us accountable in his new book “Black AF History.” He’s funny, but in a way that stings. And as he rightly points out, we come to our understanding of history by reading and contextualizing the world around us through the filter of identity.

He writes: “The academic field of history is dominated by white men handicapped by the inability to see whiteness’ impact on America's biography.” Mr. Harriot grew up in a household with books by Malcolm X, Alex Haley, W.E.B. Du Bois, Zora Neal Hurston and Dorothy B. Porter.

The education he received in his home library countered the history books in his classroom. “The history I discovered in [our home library] wasn’t just an alternate version of American history; it was the story of an entirely different place, wholly incompatible with the whitewashed mythology enshrined in our collective memory.”

Mr. Harriot offers a retelling of the American story, one that fully embraces his Black identity and the non-white perspective. He uses Pocahontas’ real name (Matoaka) and doesn’t lie about how she was kidnapped. He reframes the Emancipation Proclamation and the Civil Rights movement through a Black lens, and also breaks down why the two-party system is inherently racist.

Advertise with us

“Black AF History” is certain to make some readers uncomfortable. Some people won’t read it, dismissing it as a revisionist account of American history. But those are exactly the people who need it most.

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com. Her most recent article was “In art and politics, who must pay for past sins?”