Pittsburgh, of late, is a city of grief. A series of terrible and violent incidents have shocked our sense of peace and normalcy: the shootout in Garfield, a violent arrest downtown and, in Clairton, the fatal shooting of beloved barber Victor “Vic” Musgrove.

At the center of all this grief is Mayor Ed Gainey. He was seemingly aware of the plight of William Hardison Jr., who had personally petitioned the mayor several times before the 63-year-old was killed by the police after a six-and-a-half-hour firefight, involving hundreds of bullets, in Garfield on August 23.

The mayor’s policing strategies for Downtown contributed to the incident with Jashon Martin, who was repeatedly punched during an arrest — an unclear situation with incredibly violent and worrisome optics underscoring the tension between citizens and police.

‘My heart is heavy’

Advertise with us

But the most heartbreaking connection is the decades-old friendship between Mr. Gainey and Vic Musgrove, who was fatally shot on August 25 while in his car coming home after a football game. No motives or suspects have been revealed, and no one knows if it was targeted — or if Mr. Musgrove was simply at the wrong place at the wrong time.

“Again, I woke up to news I didn’t want to hear,” the mayor wrote on social media last Saturday, “my friend of over 40 years Vic Musgrove was killed last night. My heart is heavy right now.”

I believe him. It’s easy to be cynical about these things — to assume insincerity in anything a politician offers after a tragedy. Elected officials, in the eyes of the public, tend to lose their humanity as soon as they take their oath of office.

But Mr. Gainey is a person, with all the feelings and failings involved.

On KDKA last week, Mr. Gainey looked, unsurprisingly, like a man in shock. The reporter noted that he held back tears as he spoke.

Advertise with us

“It’s wild because you don’t expect him to be gone,” Mr. Gainey said. “He went to a football game. You expect people to come home from a football game.”

Community fixture

Ed Gainey and Vic Musgrove met when they were preteens in East Liberty, just two years apart in age, and both went on to impact Pittsburgh — especially the Black community.

While the mayor took the political route, Vic’s service stemmed from his barber shop, VIP Styles on Smithfield Street. I had heard of Mr. Musgrove through mutual acquaintances: He was known in the community for offering free haircuts to kids before the first day of school, and for his work in distributing school supplies. He helped the formerly incarcerated and addicted find jobs, often employing them at his shop, which opened in 2004 and remained a Downtown fixture for two decades.

“It’s a testament to him and his character that a small business was still surviving Downtown,” said Vernard Alexander to the New Pittsburgh Courier. “[Vic] was really passionate about uplifting the community, making the community a better place.”

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh continues to see a steady increase in gun violence. Violent incidents involving a gun rose, according to a report released by the city, from 2021 to 2022. Businesses have closed in the South Side and Downtown because of the violent uncertainty — something Mr. Musgrove knew well, and actively resisted.

“I think the older that Vic got, he understood the challenges that we have in our community, and he wanted to do whatever he could to give back,” Mr. Alexander told WPXI.

Vic’s death will reverberate through the community for a long time. He treated with anyone who sat at his barber’s chair with respect, from politicians to professional athletes to teenagers needing a strong role model.

“It’s a big loss not just for one community but the entire region,” Mr. Alexander said.

Keeping going

Advertise with us

It’s a big loss for Mr. Gainey as well.

I’m not sure if it is good or bad for a politician to be so closely connected to an issue like gun violence. I worry that Mr. Gainey will feel compelled to recede from his public role — for his own mental health and mourning — and I’m not sure that’s the right course of action.

I also worry that Mr. Gainey will instead react with great force to avenge the loss of a friend — increasing police presence and continuing policies that have not helped reduce the amount of gun violence in the city.

I don’t feel comfortable telling someone what to do with their grief. But I also don’t feel comfortable absolving a politician of responsibility because they are grieving. He’s still the mayor, after all, and he still has to answer to the people of Pittsburgh. It falls to him to work with other local politicians, neighborhood leaders and other stakeholders to reduce the violence.

Pittsburgh’s Black communities are the primary victims of gun violence, but they are also the most likely to be harmed by police — as the episodes in Garfield and Downtown demonstrated. Mr. Hardison’s standoff was incredibly violent, but it was also tragic. The aggressive arrest of Mr. Martin does little to ease the tension.

Advertise with us

Right now, the mayor has an opportunity to lead during a crisis. As he processes the death of a beloved friend and community member, Mr. Gainey can honor the work and mission Vic Musgrove embodied.

“[Vic] lived a righteous life and he had a strong character,” William Marshall, the founder of Stop the Violence Pittsburgh, told WTAE. ”You couldn’t find somebody that will say something negative about him.”

It’s a testament to Mr. Musgrove that VIP Styles remains operational, as his fellow barbers keep the doors open in tribute.

“Whoever did this, we just want them to know that you just didn’t take one soul, you impacted this whole city of Pittsburgh,” Mr. Marshall said.

It will be up to Mr. Gainey, both for himself and for his city, to make meaning from this senseless death.

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-ga-zette.com.