At the heart of the Pittsburgh Synagogue Shooting Trial is immense Jewish pain — the pain of deciding how to spend the last few minutes of your life, the pain of debating whether or not to call a loved one during a shooting, the pain of being attacked and not knowing why. All this pain has been recounted during this week’s testimony.
No one knew at the moment what motivated the shooter, and it wasn’t until much later that anyone understood the deep hatred that moved him to kill. During opening statements, defense attorney Judy Clark, an admirable human being who has dedicated her life to fighting the death penalty, tried to explain the shooter’s actions.
As Megan Guza reported for the Post-Gazette this week, “Ms. Clarke told the jurors [the shooter] was at the synagogue that day to stop the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society, a Jewish group that helped resettle refugees. She said those refugees, in his mind, were invaders.”
The shooter attacked Jewish worshippers, but his intent was to punish Jewish people for helping resettle refugees. His attack was driven by racism and the idea that white Americans are being replaced.
Lies have consequences
Bruce Antkowiak, a former federal prosecutor and defense attorney who teaches at St. Vincent College in Latrobe, believes that the defense will argue that the shooter’s hatred of refugees rendered him incapable, and these “incapacities didn’t even allow him to equate this to a hate crime in his own mind.”
Read More

It’s clear, though, that hatred prevailed: hatred of Jewish people for helping refugees, based on an ignorant theory that perpetuates white supremacy. The defense can parse whom exactly the shooter hated, but there is no doubt that this was a hate crime, by definition, as the whole notion of “replacement” is nothing but hatred made manifest.
The “great replacement theory,” as NPR defines it, is “a conspiracy theory that states that nonwhite individuals are being brought into the United States and other Western countries to ‘replace’ white voters to achieve a political agenda.”
Of course there is absolutely no agenda to replace white people, but the concept and the fear it engenders have had tremendous consequences for America, as more and more hate crimes happen on our soil. Most refugees and immigrants are coming to this country to work and live and raise their families away from the sectarian violence that colonialism and global capitalism have wrought. Refugees do not come with a political agenda outside their own survival, something Jewish people have always understood.
An agenda of survival
One of the things that I love most about my religion is how we celebrate exactly that — survival. My husband will often joke that most of our holidays are “they tried to kill us, we survived, now let’s drink wine!” We are a people who have lived through pogroms, forced removals and, of course, the Holocaust.
We are not a religion of hate. I’ve never heard of a “Jewish supremacist” in America. We’ve always been a minority, sometimes within a majority (as many Jewish people are, indeed, quite white). HIAS is an organization that has quietly helped over six thousand refugee families find new homes in 2022. Much like Catholic Charities, HIAS helps refugee families navigate our country, its language, and endless paperwork.
The irony, of course, is that organizations like HIAS help resettle all kinds of people, including refugees who are white, like many Eastern Europeans and Cubans. But those aren’t the people the shooter was upset about.

According to the Anti-Defamation League, “white supremacists blame Jewish people for nonwhite immigration to the U.S., and the ‘replacement’ theory is now associated with antisemitism.”
The shooter believed this, and the theory’s baselessness did not lessen its impact. Even if refugees in his mind were “invaders” that he had to fight, that does not change the fact that he chose to murder peaceful worshippers with several weapons in hand.
Replacing hate with love
HIAS and the congregations affected haven’t stopped their work. In fact, Dor Hadash, one of the congregations the shooter targeted that day, held a bike ride three weeks ago, just as the trial was beginning, to fundraise for refugee resettlement.
Ten congregants hopped on bicycles to raise money to help resettle a family with Jewish Family and Community Services. Photos from the day show bright smiles and caring people — continuing to do exactly the type of work that the shooter tried to stop.
Dor Hadash remains defiant in the face of hatred. Even as the pain of the trial remains an undercurrent in our community, they show a courage that few can fully understand and appreciate.
They know why the shooter targeted them. But no amount of hatred can ever undo the love.
Adriana E. Ramírez is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.