Henry David Thoreau liked silence. During his time at Walden pond, circa 1854, aside from building himself a nice little cabin on his friend’s property near Concord, Mass., Thoreau farmed, received callers and took long strolls along the train path into town. He also wrote.

In the cultural imagination, Thoreau’s chronicles of his time near the pond, “Walden,” paint a portrait of a philosopher eking out an existence reliant entirely on his own skills and small community. But aside from espousing a hard-earned do-it-yourself ethos, Thoreau also wrote a powerful and slim volume about the power of silence, solitude and listening.

I’ve been thinking a lot about these same topics. The weather has settled into late spring with hints of summer in Pittsburgh, after flirting with too many cold winds. My children’s preschool has finally sent home their winter gear, acknowledging the promise fulfilled by nesting robins and blooming daylilies.

And every day I hear the unmistakable sound of semiautomatic gunfire, because I live in Highland Park — one of the few urban neighborhoods in America within earshot of an outdoor police firing range.

Advertise with us
Councilwoman Deb Gross stands alongside Highland Park residents protesting the firing range Tuesday May 9, 2023. (Jordan Anderson / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Breaking the harmony

The range is a little over a thousand feet away, but the acoustics of the hills make it feel much closer. When I bought my house almost a decade ago, no one disclosed the incessant sound of guns being fired, and we did not realize the noise was going to be a permanent feature of our lives until we were well-invested in the neighborhood.

In “Walden,” Thoreau discusses his enjoyment of the sounds of nature and industry around him. He writes of hearing the train, and often following its tracks on his many walks. On certain afternoons, from my back porch, I too can hear a train as well as the sound of myriad critters, the wind against some distant chimes, and the slow and smooth hum of cars rolling on the residential streets.

I’ve always loved the idea of living by a park, one full of ponds too. In Highland Park, I’ve fulfilled that dream. I often take walks down by the duck pond, considering the balance of natural and manmade sounds around me, an audible demonstration that it’s possible for us and nature to co-exist in harmony. And then, invariably, the bullets began contributing their overwhelming and dissonant staccato.

Always bullets

Advertise with us

A knee injury has left me recently sessile, so I’ve decided to lean (metaphorically) into my immobility. I’ve moved from reading on the couch by the window to outside on the back porch, on a long and sturdy brown bench in the shade.

As I finished “Walden” on the porch yesterday, my neighbor leaned over the fence to talk to me. It was nice, and brief, the chorus of pleasantries across two yards. After he went back to sweeping his deck, I flipped through my book and found an underlined passage, where Thoreau describes the interaction I just had:

I have found it a singular luxury to talk across the pond to a companion on the opposite side. In my house we were so near that we could not begin to hear, — we could not speak low enough to be heard; as when you throw two stones into calm water so near that they break each other’s undulations...

The noise from the police firing range in Lincoln-Lemington ricochets off the hills of Highland Park. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

For Thoreau, these were perfect conversations — conversations that allowed for silence to fill the space of yet-to-be-uttered words. I considered whether or not our interaction was one of luxury, one that allowed our undulations to remain unbroken. But as my neighbor retreated into his home, the cacophony of shots-fired began once more.

Then my eyes landed on the passage above the one I’d just underlined:

Advertise with us

The bullet of your thought must have overcome its lateral and ricochet motion and fallen into its last and steady course before it reaches the ear of the hearer, else it may plough out again through the side of his head.

The bullets in my thoughts were more literal than I preferred.

I hoped the bullets hit the ground before their explosion reached my ears. I told myself that I am listening to the past, to the sound of something that was, not the sound of something that is. It didn’t help.

I worry that it won’t be the police one day, and I will not be able to tell the difference. I worry about my children, growing up in a neighborhood where the firecracker sound of violence is normal. I worry about how good I am at pretending it’s only another animal, flying through the air, ricocheting and falling into its steady course.

Most days, I venture back indoors to the relative peace of the air conditioner and screaming children.

Advertise with us

No silence, no peace

I am a creature of solitude, and I was so long before any injury rendered me stationary. I tend to drive in the car without the radio or any music on; I will often sit in still contemplation for hours on end; and I’m perfectly happy to stroll with only my thoughts to keep me company. Few people know this about me — I tend to be social when I’m social. But I rarely seek out companionship.

This is a product of the circumstances of my life, but it’s also a choice I’ve made. Like Thoreau, I find much to be gained by simply listening to the life around me, being alone with myself, even as I walk in a world full that refuses to be still.

In 1854, even in the middle of his country’s slow descent into the Civil War, Thoreau found something bigger than himself by just being outside and listening. He heard nature; he heard man; he heard the trains; and together, they made the symphony of everyday life. For Thoreau, bullets were metaphors for thought, not the source of their disruption.

There was a deep pleasure in the sounds of life for Henry David Thoreau. And on the afternoons when the firing range is quiet, I find it as well. The high chirp of an angry blue jay is the opposite of a gun fired, a sign that we are living, far enough away from the sound of violence that we can actually begin to hear.

Adriana E. Ramírez is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.