The pioneering social media sites of the late 1990s and early aughts focused on connecting people in shared social circles — hence the yearbook-like appeal of Classmates, or the friend-of-a-friend vibe of Friendster. Livejournal and MySpace were about establishing a personal link through diary entries and music, as well as an eternal stream of dancing-Calvin-and-Hobbes gifs.

Early Facebook was like this too — it echoed the Face Books and Meet Sheets passed out at college orientation sessions. As Gen Xers and Millennials entered adulthood, it felt normal and natural to share life updates like wedding photos, birth announcements and first-day-of-school pictures. We were all friends, after all. No one anticipated that a family could go viral for simply documenting their lives.

But they did. And because of the ubiquity and income potential of social media and media-sharing platforms like YouTube, an entire subset of Gen Zers have been performing for the viewing public since birth. Many of them are eighteen right now, the same age as YouTube. And they’re not happy.

Teen Vogue recently ran an article on “Influencer Parents and The Kids Who Had Their Childhood Made Into Content,” and its conclusions are both predictable and disheartening.

Advertise with us

As people have monetized their kids’ childhoods, they’ve also robbed them of the simple pleasure of being a kid. Children cannot consent to having their lives filmed. Many of them, of course, would love to be on the internet if asked, but children cannot agree to something they simply do not understand. We’re just now starting to see the consequences of a lifetime online.

I’m lucky — cellphones did not have good cameras on them until after I graduated college. My parents have some home videos, but they’re on old cassette tapes lost in a box somewhere, to be unearthed by me at a much later date. My social media presence begins in my twenties, and very little exists of me online before I became an adult.

I had the opportunity to say and do dumb things in private. And I for one appreciate that no one can find footage of my preteen choreography to Ace of Base. I was granted the privilege to fail outside of the public eye — there’s no public record of how much eyeliner I wore in 1997.

Some of us try to balance the desire to post about our children with a respect for their privacy. Photos of my kids do exist on the internet, behind privacy filters and with little reference to their names. I have friends who post on TikTok and promptly delete anything over a week old. I know so many of us who want both to give into the demands of sharing and to make sure our kids don’t end up feeling exploited or embarrassed.

Parenting is not easy — before adding the complexity of earning money into the equation. As Teen Vogue notes over and over again, many of these influencer children were harmed and suffer from trauma-induced mental health issues. Nearly all of them regret their family’s choice to put their lives on the internet.

Advertise with us

Laws exist that protect child actors, but there are no laws that currently protect children from home videos shared online. As the lines between production studios and home studios begin to blur, it’s important to protect our most vulnerable.

My husband and I disagree on when our kids will be getting cell phones. I think we should wait until they can drive, and he believes it should be much sooner than that. We debate how to engage with technology constantly, as do all parents who are navigating an evolving world. But we both agree on limiting our children’s exposure.

When they’re old enough, my kids will have to make their own decisions about social media. And who knows what it will look like then? Right now, we can only do our best to set some guiding principles.

The parents who monetized their children’s childhoods did not know better. In many ways, they were pioneers. The archive of footage may be useful to future anthropologists, but if young adults are telling us it wasn’t a good idea to document their lives, the least we can do is listen — and stop watching.

Adriana E. Ramírez is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.