Politicians periodically complain about grade inflation in education, sometimes with good cause. However, nothing ever found in the world of education comes close to the inflated self-assessments originating in the White House.

I wade into this subject with real hesitation, having traveled a non-partisan path throughout my adult life, more than 40 years of which have been spent here in Southwestern Pennsylvania. The two political leaders I admire most are Dick Thornburgh and Tom Ridge, each a two-term Republican governor of Pennsylvania who went on to serve with distinction in Washington -- Gov. Thornburgh as Attorney General under Presidents Ronald Reagan and George H.W. Bush and Gov. Ridge as our country’s first Secretary of Homeland Security, under President George W. Bush.

To some considerable extent, in fact, I have been motivated by the public statements of former Gov. Ridge, as well as the statement of Michael Hayden – a retired four-star general, a bronze star recipient, the former director of both the NSA and the CIA and also a revered native son of Pittsburgh. As they both have indicated, this is an important moment, an American moment, one that should be focused on character and country and not on policy and party. Among the critical national values at stake are a commitment to the truth, concern for the well-being of others, respect for all, and the equal application of the law.

Here, then, are the thoughts of one experienced grader regarding end-of-term marks.

Advertise with us

In late September, President Donald Trump was asked to grade his performance in managing the COVID-19 pandemic. He asserted that he had done a “phenomenal

job” and awarded himself an A+. Commentators described that assessment as “preposterous,” “embarrassing,” and “a stunning departure from reality.”

Maintaining his practice of not directly criticizing the president’s performance, Dr. Anthony Fauci said, “Take a look at the numbers and make up your own mind.” Key measures showed that COVID-19 had infected 6.8 million Americans and claimed 200,000 American lives, the worst numbers for any country in the world.

Just in the last few days, the White House science policy office listed “ending the COVID-19 pandemic” as one of the first-term accomplishments of the Trump administration. However, this week brought our highest single-day number of cases ever, and in many parts of the country, rates of infection, hospitalization and death are rising, with no end in sight. Responding to similar trends, leaders in some European countries are preparing to again limit activities, and even Vladimir Putin has imposed a mask mandate.

Our president, on the other hand, has repeatedly claimed that we are “rounding the corner” with respect to the pandemic, an assessment that bears no relationship to reality. Instead, in a matter of weeks, the number of Americans who have contracted COVID-19 skyrocketed from 6.8 million to more than 9 million, and our death toll rose to more than 230,000.

Advertise with us

The U.S. mortality rate also provides evidence of a failed response. We have suffered more than 69 deaths per 100,000 people. To provide some meaningful points of comparison, the mortality rate in Canada is 27; in Germany, it is 12; and in South Korea, it is less than 1.

The fact that South Korea was able to control the virus and keep its death toll so low – less than 500 – is especially telling because it is so close to China and was an early “hot spot.” However, that country developed a plan by following medical and public health guidance, encouraging the wearing of masks and emphasizing testing and contact tracing.

By adopting these measures, South Korea avoided the need to ever completely close its economy. In this country, on the other hand, having failed to take other steps, we were forced into a lengthy lock-down. Then, having endured most of the resulting pain, many places reopened too early, without adequate plans or protections in place, responding to the demands of an impatient president.

His tactics included encouraging armed militia members to “liberate” their state capitols, leading a former U.S. attorney for Western Pennsylvania to label Mr. Trump our first “vigilante president.” In light of other comments and particularly because some of those who responded to his call to “liberate Michigan” now have been charged in a plot to kidnap the state’s governor, that label seems to fit.

The president has made many other allusions to violence, and they are troubling. However, most of his bullying takes the form of school-yard insults. Simply put, if you are not with him, you are unworthy of the basic respect that most of us reflexively extend to others as the natural product of our upbringing.

Advertise with us

Beyond the impact of such incivility on individuals, our democracy depends on both respectful disagreement and a shared commitment to the truth. Even supporters of the president often concede that he lies about everything, sometimes adding, “just like every other politician.” However, his record of more than 20,000 false or misleading statements since his inauguration demonstrates that, when it comes to twisting the truth, this president is in a class by himself.

These falsehoods, to be clear, go far beyond puffing about meaningless matters. The pandemic itself involves issues of life and death. Still, since the very beginning, he has downplayed its impact, falsely claiming that it would be over by Easter, then by summer, and now at some point just “around the corner.”

Because most of us, as a matter of basic humanity, tend to be more protective of the most vulnerable, the president’s unconditional dismissal of the risks to children, through sweeping claims that they are immune, is a particular concern. Though they do seem to be less susceptible, children can contract the disease, and some have died. Medical professionals also are concerned that those infected may suffer long-term consequences that currently are unknown. That information should not be swept away as parents are making decisions about the safety of their children.

So, where do we stand today? The disease is spreading faster than ever. Cases, hospitalizations and deaths are on the rise. Medical resources are strained in some parts of the country. Millions are unemployed, and nearly 100,000 businesses have closed. The recovery seems to be exacerbating what already were historic and growing economic inequities. Even the stock market is plunging.

On other fronts, foreign adversaries have been emboldened, and allies no longer trust us. Some 6 million acres have burned in California, Oregon and Washington, an area larger than the state of New Jersey. The hurricane season has been so bad that the National Hurricane Center exhausted its annual list of 21 potential names and began labeling storms with letters of the Greek alphabet. Yet, there is a continuing denial of climate change.

Advertise with us

Back in Washington, partisan gridlock has blocked the passage of a new, and badly needed, pandemic relief bill. A major stumbling block reportedly has been the Democrats’ insistence that the bill include significant relief for states and cities, which the White House and Senate Republicans have resisted. A sizable portion of most municipal budgets is public safety, which may, ironically, mean that, by denying this aid, Republicans will have become the defunders of police.

Despite the high stakes and even though one of his advertised skills is that of a deal-maker, there is no sign that the president has chosen to become actively involved in these negotiations. He has, however, prodded the Justice Department to act in ways that would favor his friends and punish his perceived enemies – a violation of what his attorney general has called the “essence” of the rule of law – treating people equally before the law.

Rather than seizing what seemed to be a special opportunity to address a range of racial disparities, including police violence against Blacks, he has deliberately stoked those fires, apparently for what he believes is political advantage.

Asked to assess his own performance today, the president almost certainly would give himself another A or A+. However, the letter that seems most apt in describing his nearly four years in office is a “D” – standing for disease, denial, deceit and division. Of that group, “division” may be the most damaging in the long term.

As Abraham Lincoln, the first and greatest Republican president, said, “A house divided against itself cannot stand.” Sadly, our country has become a nation of deep divisions. To more appropriately employ a phrase that was used so unfortunately by the president to characterize violent clashes in Charlottesville, looking at the American people, hope for the future is tied to the fact that there still are “good people on both sides” of our growing political divide.

Advertise with us

It is unclear whether any president can bridge those differences, but this country desperately needs a leader who will try.

Mark Nordenberg is the former chancellor of the University of Pittsburgh.