Late last week, all eyes were on the U.S. District Court for Western Pennsylvania in a case that had the potential to limit voting access for some 9 million registered Pennsylvania voters. But the federal court sided with voters by upholding the use of ballot drop boxes and declining to impose unwarranted new restrictions sought by the plaintiffs.
While a clear and resounding win for voters, sadly there are a spate of lawsuits across the nation that appear to have one aim: undermine voting rights.
Since the start of the pandemic, nearly 200 voting rights suits have been filed in 42 states, the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico. More than 60 of these cases have been resolved, but 137 of them remain pending or on appeal. These lawsuits vary widely from vote-by-mail eligibility to in-person polling place safety and availability. What is both disheartening and disturbing, however, are the cases that are clearly anti-voter — where plaintiffs are suing state and local officials to block efforts to make voting safer and easier. This should be deeply concerning to all Americans.
In Pennsylvania, President Donald Trump’s re-election campaign, the Republican National Committee, several members of Congress and individual voters sued Pennsylvania Secretary of the Commonwealth Kathy Boockvar and county election administrators, originally trying to ban the use of mail-ballot drop boxes altogether.
In September, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled that state law permits the use of ballot drop boxes. Among its other rulings, the court said that mail and absentee ballots that arrive within a three-day window after Nov. 3 should be counted, unless a preponderance of the evidence demonstrates that a ballot was mailed after Election Day.
The court also ruled that “naked ballots,” sent without the required inner-envelope, are invalid. The naked ballot issue has caught the attention of voters in and out of state because, as Lisa Deeley, chair of the Philadelphia city commissioner estimated, 100,000 statewide ballots could be rejected on this basis alone. In 2016, the presidential election in Pennsylvania was decided by a mere 44,000 votes.
Once the Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued its ruling, the federal court weighed in. (For full disclosure, we represent two environmental groups in the federal case — PennFuture and the Sierra Club — who got involved as defendants to ensure that their constituents could participate safely in the democratic process this year.)
The federal court rejected the RNC and Trump campaign’s challenge, which was based on the false premise that voting by mail “invites fraud and undermines the public’s confidence in the integrity of elections.” After extensive discovery, the plaintiffs produced no credible evidence to support their allegations of fraud, consistent with the numerous studies showing that vote-by-mail fraud is exceedingly rare. Unfortunately, the president and other elected officials have nonetheless used the specter of fraud to frighten voters and sow distrust in our voting systems.
In this instance, the federal court declined to interfere with Pennsylvania’s efforts to ensure that voters can cast their ballots safely and with confidence. Sadly, efforts to undermine voting rights are in high gear all across the country and voters are taking the full force of these attacks.
For example, in Texas, the governor issued an executive order limiting ballot return locations to only one per county. Harris County, Texas, covers nearly 2,000 square miles and is home to 4.7 million people of which roughly 50% are registered voters. The Harris County clerk, the person who oversees elections, has said, “to force hundreds of thousands of seniors and voters with disabilities to use a single drop-off location in a county that stretches over nearly 2,000 square miles is prejudicial and dangerous.”
And in Georgia, 159 counties in the state must install a software update on over 30,000 ballot marking devices due to a serious glitch. The secretary of state’s office says advocates are making a “mountain out of a molehill,” but deploying software that hasn’t been thoroughly tested creates very real risks to voters. While Georgia requires emergency ballots to be on hand, regulations don’t require a sufficient number of ballots should a catastrophic machine error occur.
The effort to restrict the vote is not new and it is not behind us, as demonstrated by the flurry of lawsuits seeking to limit voting access during a historic pandemic. But voters should not be discouraged by these court battles. More than anyone else, the election is in the hands of millions of American voters, not a handful of judges.
With the federal court’s ruling in hand, Pennsylvania voters can cast their ballots with greater confidence, whether at a drop box or in person at a polling place. Early voting in Pennsylvania has begun. It’s now up to voters to exercise their solemn right to vote.
Myrna Pérez is director of and Eliza Sweren-Becker a counsel in the Brennan Center for Justice’s Voting Rights and Elections Program.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.