Donald Trump has taken a bad idea and made it worse. His plan to get Mexico to pay for a wall along the border — by threatening to effectively requisition the earnings of Mexicans working in the United States — would undermine a powerful force for good in the world as well as his goal of reducing illegal immigration.
Mr. Trump is correct that cutting off the remittances that Mexicans working in the United States send home to their families would hurt Mexico. At $25 billion last year, they accounted for roughly 2 percent of Mexico’s GDP.
Overall, the roughly half-trillion dollars of remittances that migrants worldwide send to poor countries each year far outstrip foreign aid and investment and provide direct assistance to those who need it most. And when people send money back home, they may make their families more willing to stay there.
Just last year, Congress appropriated $750 million to El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras precisely to address the violence and poverty that have sent so many of their citizens fleeing northward. But even that generous investment amounted to only one-fifteenth of what those countries received in remittances last year. In Mexico, many of the 6 million households that receive remittances rely on them for half their income.
Never mind the impact of Mr. Trump’s plan on U.S. relations with its neighbor, or the numerous legal obstacles at home, or the staggering impracticalities of carrying it out. From a purely economic perspective — surely one that Mr. Trump can appreciate — it makes no sense.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.