There are a lot of problems with the latest attempt to update Pennsylvania’s Right to Know law, which the Senate unanimously passed on Wednesday. Fortunately, the House has a chance to fix the defects and make the open-records law stronger.
The 7-year-old law, which for the first time said that, when in doubt, state agency records are to be open to the public, was a big step forward for Pennsylvania. However, it shortchanged taxpayers by giving widespread exemption to the state’s three biggest university systems — Penn State, Pitt and Temple.
Senate Bill 411 would add significantly to what the schools must provide. Beyond listing the salaries of its officers, directors and top 25 highest-paid employees that the law now requires, they would have to provide salary ranges for the next 175 highly paid workers. The universities also would have to file information on faculty salaries, data on the number of employees and how they are deployed, what portion of undergraduate classes are taught by graduate students versus full-time faculty members and more.
That’s all good, as are provisions that add the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association to the list of agencies covered by the law. Even a change that would allow the state to charge organizations that request records for purely commercial purposes is satisfactory, since it wisely does not apply to scientific or academic research and media coverage.
But other changes in the measure are problematic.
It would create a blanket exemption on disclosing the home addresses of public employees, even though such information often is readily available from many sources. The bill also would create an exemption for the home addresses of individuals who call for emergency services. The financial records of volunteer fire and rescue organizations would be off limits to the public, as would the records of tax collectors.
Other troubling provisions would allow state agencies to deny access to records simply because a requesting party is involved in related litigation, and it would all but ban inmates from taking advantage of the open records law beyond accessing their own records.
As written, the bill would create too many impediments for individuals seeking legitimately public information. Members of the House have a lot more work to do to improve the state’s Right to Know law.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.