Later this month, I will finish my four-year term as an elected member of the Pittsburgh Board of Education.
Patrick Dowd will join City Council in January. He lives in Highland Park (patrick@patrickdowd.org).
These four tumultuous years have shown that the many different interests and inclinations in Pittsburgh politics can work across the divides of neighborhood, class and race when they find a common agenda for action that benefits all citizens. The process is democratic and naturally difficult; it calls for a balance of particular interests with the greater good. Neither one can be lost or held hostage to the other as was the case four years ago.
Back then, the politically polarized board found it nearly impossible to engage in meaningful dialogue or constructive action. All the while, storm clouds gathered on the horizon of the district's academic and financial future. Making matters still worse, board-superintendent relations were particularly hostile. National newspapers and journals maligned Pittsburgh's school governance. Three local foundations had withdrawn millions of dollars in support. Consistent with these indications, the Mayor's Commission on Public Education recommended the mayor assume control of the school district.
To its credit, the public and the board understood the need for change. In late 2003, a newly reconstituted board reached across the old divides to open new conversations. Board members worked to develop an agenda for action that centered on student achievement and fiscal responsibility.
In the process, ideological differences did not disappear and neither did individual board member's desire to advance the interests of their particular constituencies. Instead, individual priorities were realigned. A common sense of purpose inspired board members to negotiate compromises for the greater good.
Still board-superintendent relations failed to improve. In the most controversial moment of my term, I cast what many have labeled the deciding vote on a resolution to sever relations with Superintendent John Thompson. As I recognized that night, I will always be held accountable for and remember the anguish of that cathartic decision.
The board clung to the compass of its common agenda and conducted a genuine national search. The job advertisement for superintendent clearly outlined its agenda calling for someone who could improve student achievement, enhance fiscal responsibility, increase accountability and renew stakeholder relations. The board selected Mark Roosevelt in 2005 and established a new accountability contract that codified these goals. It remains at the heart of improved relations between the board and superintendent.
Led by Superintendent Roosevelt, this board has amassed an impressive legislative record. The board -- again a by-district elected board -- voted to eliminate the problem of excess capacity by closing more school buildings than any district in America had ever done at one time. The board doubled the size of the early childhood program. The board has not only held the line on taxes, but also has surrendered a significant portion of the wage tax to city government.
In this way, the board has truly done more with less. The board has supported the right-sizing of the central office administration and the reallocation of resources to the schools.
Additionally, this board has doggedly pursued the implementation of systems of accountability. From the board to the superintendent and all the way through the district to the principals, evaluations and accountability have become the norm.
The board, which was long divided on matters of teaching, has voted for major curricular shifts and is supporting the foundation pieces for a plan to redesign and reinvigorate Pittsburgh's high schools. As a part of high school reform, the board has also supported a bold new initiative -- the Pittsburgh Promise, a plan to provide college scholarships for graduating seniors.
Four years ago these reforms would have been impossible and even unimaginable. However, within the polarized camps of that once-divided board there were members -- probably a majority -- who wanted to focus on student achievement and fiscal responsibility. Unfortunately, the uncompromising factionalism that had dominated that board prevented most of its members from realizing their shared hopes for our school system.
The current board has demonstrated that breaking down political barriers and opening up to reform has brought positive changes for students and citizens.
As my colleagues and the superintendent will tell you, the work of the board has been arduous, frustrating and exhausting. Some may say this is the price for a democratically elected board. Certainly, the board has made progress, but its work is still contentious and at times petty. Given that we are still in the early phase of a much longer and larger project, the reforms both of the district and the board must continue. The test of the board's success is ongoing and the results are still by no means clear. The board has reformed but must continue reforming.
My colleagues -- Mark Brentley, Theresa Colaizzi, Jean Fink, Bill Isler, Skip McCrea, Dan Romaniello, Thom Sumpter, and Randall Taylor -- have proven to us all that it is possible to reach across divides and reduce factionalism. They have taught us all the importance of finding a common agenda for action. They have taught us all how to serve citizens and future citizens. I am grateful to have worked and learned with Superintendent Roosevelt and each and every one of my board colleagues.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.