BRUSSELS — An easy prediction for 2024? We will be talking a lot about migration.
After a pandemic-era lull, the issue roared back to the forefront this year as Western leaders faced pressure from the right to adopt ever-stricter measures.
In the final days of the year, the European Union reached a landmark deal to overhaul its migration policy and in France an immigration bill pushed President Emmanuel Macron to a crisis point.
Anti-migrant sentiment has propelled the far right to victories in bastions of social liberalism like the Netherlands and shaped debate from Germany to Italy and Britain. In 2024, it will be a driving force in elections in Europe — not to mention the United States.
“In a big election year — in the U.S., the EU and the U.K. — migration is shaping up to be a big issue,” said Catherine Barnard, a professor at the University of Cambridge who specializes in European politics.
Though Europe moved swiftly to welcome millions of mostly White, Christian refugees from Ukraine in the wake of Russia’s 2022 invasion, it seems focused, now, on keeping others out.
Read More
European countries have struggled for years to find common ground on migration policy, but the uptick in arrivals over the past year fed the politicization of migration policy and elevated the importance of the issue in capitals.
During the first 11 months of 2023, the continent saw a 17% jump in irregular arrivals compared with the same period a year earlier. The more than 355,000 arrivals amounted to the highest numbers since 2016, when the region saw a historic influx led by refugees fleeing the Syrian civil war.
As the right and far-right seized on the issue, EU officials faced increasing pressure to find a common EU approach.
The deal, which must still be formally ratified, aims, among other things, to share the costs associated with new arrivals more evenly among member states, to stem new arrivals and to make it possible to deport people more quickly.
Top European officials touted the agreement as a win for Europe and those trying desperately — and often dangerously — to reach its shores.
“It means that Europeans will decide who comes to the EU and who can stay, not the smugglers. It means protecting those in need,” said Ursula von der Leyen, president of the European Commission.
But human rights groups condemned the new measures, saying they undermine critical protections for asylum seekers and will put newcomers at greater risk.
“This agreement will set back European asylum law for decades to come,” said Amnesty International in a statement. “Its likely outcome is a surge in suffering on every step of a person’s journey to seek asylum in the EU.”
In many countries, including France and Germany, the migration debate is pushing centrist parties to the right as leaders try allay concerns about migration and immigration.
This week, for instance, the French parliament adopted a divisive bill that places tough rules on immigrants, such as making it harder for them to access benefits or for their children to become French citizens.
Mr. Macron’s centrist party agreed to tougher measures to win support from the French right. Marine Le Pen, the leader of the far-right National Rally, hailed the bill as an “ideological victory” for her camp.
Migration is also dominating the political agenda in Germany, where asylum applications are up significantly and local governments are feeling the strain of caring for so many newcomers.
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, who has vowed to take a tougher line, faces growing pressure from the right. Support for the far-right, anti-immigration Alternative for Germany (AfD) is on the rise, with the party expected to perform well in regional elections in 2024 and currently polling well nationally.
Even the continent’s conservative leaders are struggling with how to address the issue.
In Britain, immigration will probably remain at the forefront of politics as the country heads into an election year. Like previous Conservative leaders, Prime Minister Rishi Sunak is hoping to rally his base by taking a tough line.
In 2016, many Britons voted for Brexit to leave the EU so that their country could “take back control” of its borders. But immigration to the U.K. is now at record high levels prompting outrage from conservatives.
On the campaign trail last year, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni pledged to solve the migrant crisis — with a naval blockade of Africa if she had to. In office, she has found the issue much harder to fix.
To move forward, Ms. Meloni has forged an alliance with Britain’s Mr. Sunak. After their meeting last weekend, the two announced an Italo-British effort to fund repatriations of migrants in Tunisia, both an origin and transit country for migrants heading to Europe on rickety boats.
Both countries have sought to solve their migration issues by literally offshoring the problem. Italy struck a deal with Albania to house up to 36,000 migrants a year, while Britain planned to deport asylum seekers to Rwanda — until the U.K’s top court rejected the plan. Mr. Sunak’s government is attempting to revive it.
Ms. Meloni has also taken the lead in seeking to forge a deal with Tunisia’s strongman Kais Saied to increase patrols and prevent migrant crossings, despite widespread evidence that his racist statements have inspired attacks against sub-Saharan migrants in that country, prompting them to flee.
But the deals have run into trouble. Mr. Saied has emerged as a mercurial partner, returning 60 million euros of EU funding this month, dismissing it as too meager. Ms. Meloni’s agreement with Albania has been suddenly blocked by that country’s Constitutional Court.
“For Meloni, immigration has been an utter failure,” said Nathalie Tocci, director of the Rome-based Institute for International Affairs.
“Even if the Albania deal does go ahead, it’s little more than a PR stunt,” she said. “If you look at the number of arrivals, compared to the number of people who can be housed, it’s very clear it will be peanuts. It won’t make a real difference.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.