A mere 25 days after he took office, Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey was handed one of the more complex — and expensive — issues his administration would face when the Fern Hollow Bridge collapsed.
Although no one was killed, the early-morning collapse of the bridge into Frick Park between Squirrel Hill and Point Breeze caused a spotlight to be focused on the 146 city-owned bridges.
The new Fern Hollow Bridge opened 11 months later, but the incident exposed years of neglect and lack of investment in the bridges the Gainey administration would have to deal with, including 33 that were listed in poor condition, many of them for a decade or more.
In his four years as mayor, Mr. Gainey hired consultants to recommend plans for improvements, worked more closely with the Southwestern Pennsylvania Commission — which vets federal funding for projects — and took immediate action to close several structures when inspectors found them in questionable condition.
But a lack of available funding to meet the recommendations of consultants leaves Mayor-elect Corey O’Connor inheriting a bridge system with ongoing problems.

When consultant WSP Inc. was hired to review the city’s bridges, its reports outlined the work the city needed to do to care for its 146 bridges at that time, two of which have since been demolished.
Read More
The reports, the last of which was released in February 2024, found that city bridges needed $471.6 million worth of work over the next 32 years: $135.4 million for nine bridges that needed immediate work; $276.3 million for 98 bridges that needed extensive work by 2039; and $59.4 million for long-range projects that should be completed before 2056.
Additionally, the city should start spending at least $9.65 million a year on routine bridge maintenance to reduce deterioration, the consultant said.
The nine bridges are in various stages, from the Charles Anderson in Schenley Park, where a full rehabilitation is underway, to others where preliminary engineering is near completion or a consultant has just been hired to study the project.

Anderson and two other bridges show the city’s increased emphasis on the condition of bridges.
The administration immediately closed Anderson for emergency repairs in February 2023, barely a year after the Fern Hollow incident. Then Mr. Gainey lobbied the SPC to advance upcoming rehab work by several years to get the bridge fully upgraded, rather than performing emergency work, reopening it, then closing it again for the larger project.
At the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation’s recommendations, the city added the nearby Panther Hollow Overpass to the Anderson project, and work began in October 2024, but contractor Mosites Construction Co. found additional problems once work began.
“We’re working toward opening the bridge before the end of 2027,” Deputy Chief Engineer Zack Workman said in a statement. “However, this year as construction ramped up and portions of the existing deck and paint system were removed, the extents of deterioration and the presence of asbestos have resulted in some complicated impacts to the schedule that we are still working to project forward to understand how seasonally-restrictive work will be affected.”
The city also closed the nearby Panther Hollow Bridge in October 2024 after concerns with steel truss members that support the structure, and the Herron Avenue Bridge between Polish Hill and Lawrenceville was closed for four months beginning in May after an inspection discovered problems with support columns. Panther Hollow remains closed, but the city has issued a $1.95 million contract for repairs that will begin in the spring.

The city’s lack of money for routine maintenance remains an ongoing issue. Instead of the $9.65 million annually recommended by the consultant, the city spent $1.75 million in 2024 and $2.3 million in 2025. It has budgeted $2.7 million for 2026.
Overall, the number of bridges listed in poor condition increased from 33 to 38. Mr. Workman said the city actually repaired or demolished about 10 bridges under 20 feet, but its more rigorous inspection program identified others with increased deterioration that need attention.
Mr. O’Connor issued a statement saying the new administration will put even more emphasis on bridges.
“I have spent the past several months meeting with many different stakeholders to investigate new approaches to our bridge maintenance and replacement,” Mr. O’Connor said. “One thing is clear — the current process must change.
“Bridge repair and replacement is a top priority of my Administration and efforts to improve and enhance this work will commence on day one. I expect to make announcements regarding our commitment to maintaining our bridges early in the new Administration.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.