Bouquets of flowers lay at the intersection of Cornell and Highland avenues in West View.

As cars passed the makeshift memorial Monday, a pink cowboy hat and a plaque — outlined with red and white flowers — signed by family and friends leaned against a utility pole.

Addalena "Addie" Maiette, a recent graduate of North Hills High School, died at the intersection late last week, the victim of a two-car crash along a road that several residents who live nearby said is in dire need of increased safety measures.

“There needs to be something put in place to make it safer for everybody,” said Kristina Taylor, Ms. Maiette’s former soccer coach, who said she drives on Highland every day to get to Highcliff Elementary, where she teaches second grade. “We just lost a life because of this.”

Advertise with us

Residents said they weren’t surprised. In their view, the setup of the road  meant it was only a matter of time until a significant — if not tragic — wreck would occur.

Bill Willett, 86, who has lived on Georgetown Avenue one block from the crash site since 1966, said he’s noticed drivers not slowing down for stop signs throughout his neighborhood. “And nobody does nothing about it,” he said.

In the wake of the fatal crash, renewed calls for safety precautions on Highland Avenue have surfaced. 

Between 2006 and 2024, 32 crashes within 300 feet of the intersection were reported to PennDOT, according to data analyzed by the Post-Gazette.

Carlene Bensch, who for 20 years has lived on the corner of Highland and Bronx avenues — about a quarter-mile east of the fatal crash site — said her house was hit by a car shortly after she moved in. 

Advertise with us

Since then, Ms. Bensch said she has been advocating for change for years, and recently started a petition for a “safer Highland Avenue.” 

That effort has led to thousands of signatures and dozens of comments about crashes on the roadway, the bulk of which is a hilly three-quarters of a mile that separates West View from Ross to the north between Perry Highway and Gass Road.

The intersection with Cornell comes at a low point of a valley between two of the hills on Highland, which has a 30-mph speed limit.

“This should have been addressed,” said Ms. Bensch.

Addie Maiette of West View was killed in a two-car crash at the intersection of Highland and Cornell avenues in the borough on Thursday. (Lindsay Shachnow / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

She is urging residents and those who regularly drive on Highland to attend the West View council meeting Oct. 8.

Advertise with us

West View Mayor J.R. Henry told the Post-Gazette that he plans to meet with state Sen. Lindsey Williams, state Rep. Emily Kinkead and PennDOT before then. 

Mr. Henry said the borough has taken several steps in recent years in an effort to improve safety along Highland, including the installation of a 24-hour speed warning sign and banning left turns onto Highland from Bronx Avenue, an intersection that’s blind for westbound drivers on Highland until they reach the apex of a hill. 

“It’s a very tragic situation that the whole community has been touched by,” he said. “We want to work together to try and find ways to enhance safety on Highland Avenue and throughout the entire borough.”

Because Highland Avenue is under state purview, he said, the borough is limited in what it can do.

“We’ve attempted to do everything that the borough [can do] within our power to make it safe,” he said. 

Advertise with us

PennDOT completed two multi-way stop sign studies — in 2017 and 2022 — at the intersection of Highland Avenue and Bronx Avenue/Wellington Drive, just east of the crash site, PennDOT spokesman Steve Cowan said.

While the findings of the studies, which were requested by the municipality, “did not meet the requirements for a multi-way stop,” the department made some suggestions for signage and pavement markings that were implemented, Mr. Cowan said.

There is a future project in the works for a potential roundabout at the intersection of Highland Avenue and Gass Road, Mr. Cowan said, and the municipality can request a speed limit study.

“What we hope to do is re-examine the safety concerns that we have, as well as the residents, to try to make sure this type of situation never happens again,” Mr. Henry said.

Addie Maiette was killed in a two-vehicle crash at the intersection of Cornell and Highland Avenues in West View on Thursday. (KDKA-TV)

A community mourning

Ms. Maiette, who graduated in 2025, studied carpentry at A.W. Beattie Career Center and worked at West Shore Home as a bath installer, according to her obituary, which describes her as a “kind, adventurous, and bright soul.” Ms. Maiette also played on the girls’ soccer team and exhibited an “incredible work ethic” and “passion for the game.”

Advertise with us

“What made her special was the way that she treated all of the players and coaches,” said Ms. Taylor. “She had this smile that could just lift up the entire team.”

Counseling services are available at the high school for students, staff and families for “as long as they are needed,” North Hills School District said. 

“This heartbreaking loss reminds us how quickly life can change,” the district said. “May we find strength in one another and comfort in the love of family, friends, and our community.”

Police said Ms. Maiette was driving a vehicle — the third in a line of cars stopped on Highland at the intersection with Cornell — on Thursday morning. Investigators said she apparently tried to pass the two cars in front of her on the left and crashed into the car trying to turn left onto Cornell.

The driver of that vehicle was uninjured, police said. The crash remains under investigation.

Advertise with us

The damage to the vehicles was so severe that detectives could not initially identify which vehicle was trying to pass and which was turning. 

Sam Bailey-Hockin, another of Ms. Maiette’s former soccer coaches, said she was “something special.”

He said fans at Monday night’s North Hills girls soccer game against Allderdice would wear red headbands in her memory. “She wore one every single day she played and trained,” he said. “I can see her wearing it right now.”