The city of Pittsburgh has reached a proposed settlement with victims of the Fern Hollow Bridge collapse, which injured 10 and spawned multiple investigations and lawsuits.

Pittsburgh Deputy Mayor Jake Pawlak on Friday asked City Council to authorize a payment of $500,000 to settle lawsuits from those who were on the bridge when it crashed into a ravine in Frick Park on Jan. 28, 2022.

The resolution Mr. Pawlak has forwarded to council asks for the full liability damage cap and directs the city’s Law Department to discharge the funds.

“Now, the matter rests before the court for its action pursuant to the Rules of Civil Procedure, and we await its decision so we the city and the plaintiffs may bring this matter to a close,” he said in a statement.

Advertise with us

The proposed settlement will need approval from both City Council and Common Pleas Judge Philip Ignelzi, who is presiding over the case, before it is finalized. 

In a joint statement, the attorneys representing victims of the collapse said they did not hear anything from the city regarding the proposed settlement and only learned about it through news reports Friday morning. 

“We appreciate the city finally accepting responsibility for allowing one of its bridges to collapse, and agreeing to pay its statutory limits to partially resolve this case,” the statement read. “No attorneys for any of the victims of the collapse were contacted about this action — we were surprised by the media reports this morning.”

Among the plaintiffs are Daryl Luciani and his wife, Karen. Mr. Luciani was driving a Pittsburgh Regional Transit bus and was partway across the 447-foot span when the bridge began to collapse. A 41-page lawsuit Mr. Luciani filed details the upkeep — or lack thereof — of the bridge in the months and years leading up to the collapse.

Mr. Luciani’s lawsuit describes the fear he said he felt as the bridge collapsed beneath his articulated bus. He first feared he and his passengers would die in the fall. Then, as he heard the roar of the natural gas leak caused by the falling span, he feared they would die in an explosion.

Advertise with us

The details of Mr. Luciani’s lawsuit mirror those laid out in documents from the National Transportation Safety Board earlier this year: A bridge left to wear away over more than 16 years as multiple city administrations failed to heed warnings of corrosion and other damage, until it collapsed under morning traffic into Frick Park below.

Other plaintiffs include bus passengers Anna Nichols and Matthew Evans, as well as several others driving across the bridge when it collapsed: Clinton and Irene Runco, Velva and Tyrone Perry, Thomas and Sara Bench, and Joseph Engelmeier.

The Perrys’ suit describes Ms. Perry’s extensive injuries from the collapse, including a spinal fracture and “prolonged disability and recovery.” Mr. Perry, too, suffered spinal injuries, among other issues. The Benches’ complaint said Mr. Bench’s injuries have caused him severe cervical and back pain.

The lawsuit named the city of Pittsburgh and three engineering firms: CDM Smith, which was contracted to perform bridge inspections from 2005 through 2019; Gannett Fleming, which was contracted from 2020 through 2022; and Larson Design Group, which also performed inspections from 2020 through 2022.

If the settlement between the city and victims of the collapse is finalized, attorneys for the victims would continue pursuing the case against the three engineering firms, according to the joint statement.

None of the attorneys representing the three engineering firms responded to requests for comment.