The collapse of Baltimore’s iconic Francis Scott Key Bridge early Tuesday morning — after a container ship collided with one of its supports — brought forth many questions about next steps for the popular port along the Patapsco River.
Although it will likely take months or longer to fully understand what exactly happened, the collapse also underscored potential infrastructure frailties among bridges across the region.
Despite Pittsburgh’s high number of bridges, the city is less susceptible to the type of damage that occurred in Baltimore.
Carol Vernon, spokesperson for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Pittsburgh District, said seagoing vessels rarely make it this far up the Mississippi and Ohio rivers, because they can’t lock through the system of dams that make navigation through various elevations possible.
“There are 23 locks and dams [in the Pittsburgh District] covering 328 navigable miles,” she said. “Pittsburgh has some of the smallest and oldest locks in the U.S. Most of our locks are 600 feet long by 110 feet wide, but there are exceptions.”
The Monongahela River has three locks, none longer than 720 feet.
Read More
The Dali, the cargo ship that hit the Francis Scott Key Bridge, is about 985 feet long and 157 feet wide. The seagoing vessel, owned by the Maersk shipping company, carried a full load of shipping containers and was traveling from Baltimore to Colombo, Sri Lanka, and moving about 9 miles per hour unpowered when the collision occurred.
Pittsburgh river traffic, by contrast, is mostly barges and dinner cruises.
“Pittsburgh District shipping is 35 percent coal and 8 percent crude materials, including smaller quantities of sand, gravel, building materials, petro, some steel and chemicals, generating $4 billion in transportation costs per year,” paid by the shippers for lock access, said Ms. Vernon.
The Port of Baltimore includes lock oversight by the U.S. Corps of Engineers, and cooperation among districts is common, she said. The Pittsburgh District has not received a request for help from the Baltimore District.
The Appalachian Mountains and craggy Atlantic coast require the region to have a high number of bridges: Pennsylvania alone has 1,804 spans. Because of Pittsburgh’s three major rivers and hilly topography, the city has 446 bridges — three more than Venice, Italy.
Being no stranger to waterways and bridges, the Pittsburgh region has had its share of collisions over the years. (Although when a moving object strikes a stationary one, it’s referred to as an allision.) Usually, barges come loose from tug boats or from the large cylindrical pilings to which they are moored and float down the river uncontrolled, sometimes striking infrastructure like bridges, docks, or locks and dams.
Often, snarled traffic results, as in January 2019 when a towboat traveling the Monongahela River saw a dozen coal barges break loose at the Liberty Bridge. That led to numerous bridge closures downriver, and delays for motorists.
The bigger the vessel, the harder it is to redirect it out of a dangerous situation, said Tom O’Donnell, vice president of Bethel Park-based O’Donnell Consulting Engineers, Inc.
“You can’t stop those things on a dime,” he said.
Mr. O’Donnell’s company has investigated several marine incidents in the region, with some the result of barges coming loose during times of bad weather. Unmoored, the barges will careen down the rivers, bumping into structures.
“A lot of times, barges will hit bridges,” he said.
High river flows make vessels harder to control. Ice on the water is a menacing obstruction.
Mr. O’Donnell anticipated there will be two investigations into the Baltimore collision — one to find out what happened with the vessel that caused it to collide with the bridge, and the other to figure out why the bridge crumbled the way it did upon being struck. The latter one might take a year, he said.
“It may be a function of when that bridge was built,” he said. “Perhaps the piers were largely designed to support the bridge spans and they didn’t really contemplate a large cargo ship striking that pier.”
Pingbo Tang, an associate professor of civil and environmental engineering at Carnegie Mellon University, said the Francis Scott Key Bridge is a steel truss bridge, a design that became popular across the country in the 1960s and 1970s. That means that many bridges in the United States have similar designs, including some in the Pittsburgh region, he said.
But “in this case,” Mr. Tang said, “the structure type is not that important, because the boat hit the foundation and the foundation collapsed and the whole … span collapsed.”
He noted that if nothing had hit the structure such as happened on Tuesday, “it should be safe.”
Consol Energy, a Canonsburg-based coal producer that owns a major coal export terminal in the Port of Baltimore, can’t get its vessels in or out of the facility for the time being.
“The Coast Guard has established a safety zone for all navigable waters of the Chesapeake Bay within a 2,000-yard radius around the Francis Scott Key Bridge,” the company said in a statement. “At this moment, we do not have a definitive timeline of when vessel access or normal operations will resume. We are looking at all available options to us to minimize or address direct and indirect impacts to the company and its operations.”
Last year, around 19 million tons of coal went through the terminal, with 84% of that coal mined under Washington and Greene counties. The frequency of vessels coming and going was not disclosed.
The Baltimore tragedy saw swift reactions from many in Western Pennsylvania, including a statement from Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey that nodded to the Fern Hollow Bridge collapse in 2022. That January, the 49-year-old expanse collapsed into a ravine in Frick Park, injuring four people.
“Please join me in praying for all those impacted by the Francis Scott Key Bridge collapse in Baltimore this morning,” a post on X from the mayor said. “We know all too well what it means to wake up to the news of a bridge collapsing and Pittsburgh is ready and willing to help where we can in the days and months ahead.”
Bishop David Zubik of the Diocese of Pittsburgh also stressed community and prayer in an emailed statement.
“We turn to our faith for comfort and strength as we watch the intense rescue efforts unfold in Baltimore. May we join in prayer for all those involved and impacted by this tragic event. In times of crisis our faith reminds us of the power of prayer and the importance of coming together as a community to support one another,” the bishop said.
Pittsburgh-area bridge collisions
Collisions with bridges along Pittsburgh’s waterways in recent years include:
In April 2011, traveling on a strong current, four barges broke free from a towboat on the Ohio River. Three ended up leaning against a railroad bridge on Neville Island. One sank. The bridge was fine.
In January 2012, a vessel traveling down the Mon River struck the Liberty Bridge and two of its 12 barges broke free, one sinking and the other alliding with a mooring facility. There were no injuries and the bridge was judged unimpaired after the impact.
In December of that year, a towboat with three barges carrying coal allided with the Hot Metal Bridge on the Mon River. Both the vessels and the bridge were inspected and allowed to proceed with operations soon after their meeting.
In 2014, the Gateway Princess boat struck the North Shore pier of the Veterans Bridge, but left no mark on the structure.
In May 2018, runaway coal barges struck the Rankin Bridge and the CSX railroad bridge after 15 barges broke loose, but both bridges were declared safe.
Megan Tomasic contributed to this report.
With AP reporting.
John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.