Port Authority service disruptions caused by the agency’s vaccine mandate for employees have given the agency “an embarrassing black eye” over the past 10 days, the head of the Amalgamated Transit Union told the authority’s board Friday.
Ross Nicotero, the union’s president and business agent, criticized the agency for keeping more than 300 employees off of work because they haven’t been vaccinated against the COVID-19 virus. The result has been a substantial increase in the number of service trips the agency has missed because operators aren’t available, which reached a high of 18% the first day of the mandate March 15.
A group of employees opposed to the mandate also demonstrated outside of the meeting Friday at Sixth Avenue and Smithfield Street. The union represents about 2,300 of the authority’s 2,600 workers.
Mr. Nicotero said it is “just laughable” that for nearly two years his workers were called “heroes” for reporting to work during the pandemic. Now, “we’re zeros” and members are facing termination if they don’t receive the vaccine, he said.
The union lost its bid for a court order to block the mandate and wants to continue bargaining with the authority to encourage members to get the vaccine. The authority has refused and started disciplinary hearings against those who refuse the vaccine. Nine workers have been terminated.
Mr. Nicotero said the authority and the union had worked together through most of the pandemic to reach agreement on items such as passenger limits on vehicles, air filtration systems and vehicle cleaning protocols. After financial incentives didn’t move the number of workers vaccinated above 80%, the authority “jammed the mandate down our throats,” he told the board.
Read More
“You prefer to do it alone,” he said.
Following its usual policy, the board had no comment during the meeting. After the meeting, CEO Katharine Eagan Kelleman wouldn’t comment on whether the agency should be embarrassed about missed trips but said situation is improving.
The vaccination rate has risen above 90% since the mandate began, Ms. Kelleman said. Through Thursday, the agency scheduled 158 disciplinary hearings and 81 people are back at work on 30 days’ probation because they showed proof they received their first vaccination shot; 50 had their hearing rescheduled after they didn’t attend; eight retired; and five are still being reviewed after their hearing.
There are 153 who remain off with pay.
When the mandate began March 15, the agency missed 18% of its trips, but Thursday that number was down to 8.5%. The agency’s goal is less than 2% missed trips.
With some employees returning to work, the service problems are “clearly moving in the right direction,” spokesman Adam Brandolph said.
Ms. Kelleman said the agency a year ago worked with the union on a “full court press“ to make sure transit workers were considered first responders so they could get an early dose of the vaccine when it became available. After adding financial incentives for vaccinations, she said, the number was still under 80% in December when virus cases were peaking, so the agency notified the union it was moving to mandatory vaccinations.
“That absolutely was the right time to pull the trigger and move to mandatory vaccinations,” Ms. Kelleman said. “I hope the (virus) numbers continue to improve and it looks like the Port Authority over-reacted. I can live with that.”
In an interview after the meeting, Mr. Nicotero said more than half of those who retired rather than get the vaccine left before they were ready and felt forced out.
“They are losing good people who don’t want to leave, “ he said. “It’s disheartening to my people when they see signs that they are hiring people and they are letting good people leave.“
Ms. Kelleman said many of those who retired had been telling co-workers for months they were looking to retire.
“Clearly we don’t want talented people to leave, “ Ms. Kelleman said. “But people are entitled to move on and enjoy their retirement. We will lose some good folks.“
Disciplinary hearings are expected to continue through next week.
The authority also is having problems finding operators to run shuttle buses through Beechview, which are needed because light rail service through the neighborhood is suspended while the agency makes emergency repairs to the Saw Mill Run Boulevard Bridge. Laura Perkins, who works with advocacy group Casa San Jose, said delays of up to two hours have been particularly hard on the Spanish community she serves because many of them don’t have an alternative to public transit.
Ms. Kelleman said staffing the shuttle system isn’t directly related to the shortage of drivers caused by the vaccine. Because the shuttle isn’t a regular route, it often is staffed with operators who volunteer to work overtime but the agency can’t require overtime.
Additionally, the route has difficult turns on narrow streets that normally don’t accommodate buses.
“What we’re committing to today is putting together a map showing where the stops are [for the shuttle],” Ms. Kelleman said. “There are extreme challenges [in Beechview] and we’re doing what we can to meet them. I know that doesn’t help if you’re waiting for a bus and it doesn’t come.”
Ed Blazina; eblazina@pist-gazette.com, 412-559-2092 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.